Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Need opinion

Posts

Need opinion

#1

Dan Jechura

Need opinion

Dan Jechura

OK I will try this photo uploading thing.

This is the 1st time I have made a bowl like this and I am still working on it. It's 3 inches tall by 5 in dia. wide. The hole in the top is 2 inches. It’s made out of white Oak. It's not finished ( just sanded, no finish) and I need an opinion. The top is an angle with a slight curve. Would it look better with a flatter angle than a curved angle?

Dan Jechura


Re: Need opinion

#2

Re: Need opinion

John Lucas

It is very nice. Since you asked I'll make a couple of suggestions. I like the top half but what I would do is make the bottom a little smaller and move the wide point up a little. It's just a little to low and divides the vessel into 2 parts. Lift the high point up a little and your eye would flow from the bottom up a little better. Personally I don't like straight lines very often. I prefer a slight curve either convex or concave on most surfaces.

Your doing well, that's a nice bowl.

Re: Need opinion

#3

Re: Need opinion

Terry Scott

Dan John is right on the button

Nice work but with a few subtle changes youll have a winner

The wood is a killer

Re: Need opinion

#4

Fibonacci caliper *LINK*

Dick Coers

Make yourself a Fibonacci caliper for setting the place where you start the top curve. It will give you close to a 3/8, 5/8 proportion. You can use the caliper to set the diameters as well. If you research Fibonacci, you can then apply numbers to pleasing proportion. Here's a link to one guys pattern.


Fibonacci guage

Re: Need opinion

#5

BarbS

Re: Need opinion

BarbS

Very Pretty Wood! Be sure to show us the finished product.

Re: Need opinion

#6

Re: Need opinion

Dan Jechura Temperance Mich.

Thank you John

Yes I did ask for a opinion. I can make the bottom foot and thin ( make smaller) the bottom of the bowl, but I do not think I can raise the mid line highter because the bowl has already been turned inside. But I will try. Next time I will adjust the lines.

Dan

PS thank you all for your remarks. I will post the final pic soon.

Re: Need opinion

#7

Chuck Jones - West TN

Don't mess this one up with too much rework.

Chuck Jones - West TN

It's a beautiful piece of wood. You can't always please Fibonacci, or Fiberme, or whoever. Consider the good advice you get here and use what suits you. Move on to the next one. There's plenty of wood available.

Some of my work that my family treasures most was made before I had a clue about good form. Come to think of it, not sure I do now. :\