Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

HSS turning tools ?

Posts

HSS turning tools ?

#1

HSS turning tools  ?

Terry Scott

HSS 4241( W4Mo2Cr4V1 HSS

If tools are quoted with the above

Is this what we want in tools or is this just a low to medium quality.

How would these sharpen

I am asking this as there are only two things I under stand about steel Its heavy and it gets hot/

Cheers

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#2

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

Carole Valentine

Haven't a clue what it stands for but a Google search turns up mostly Chinese related items and things like "cheap spindle gouges"! LOL

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#3

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

John Lucas

Terry Do a search of High Speed Steel classification. I did that and found lots of info on what the numbers mean. In short they tell you the materials that are in the metal.

Unfortunately the quality of the heat treatment is also part of that and we have no way of knowing how accurately that is done. If the metal was purchased from a known manufacturer then we could assume it's done to pretty high standards. If it comes from the far east then who knows.

Basically M42 is pretty good stuff. Without digging further I don't remember what the last 2 numbers mean. There's just too much info out there for my little brain to remember.

One of the companies I photograph for makes particle metal steel parts and apparently the heat sintering process (sort of very sophisticated heat treating) is pretty critical and if not done dead on results in lesser quality parts.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#4

Jim Evans

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

Jim Evans

This may help. It's from a chart that Alan Lacer made for AAW mag.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#5

Yeah, but...

Scott in Douglassville

...is there a clear ranking in that chart? I was about to order some Packard tools. Their composition seems different from the others - good thing?

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#6

Jim Evans

Re: Yeah, but...

Jim Evans

This may help explain some of the differences. I don't think there is any ranking of the steel, only to give you an idea of a particular steel.


Re: HSS turning tools ?

#7

Hardness and toughness aren't in the charts

John Lucas

Any one of those steels can be made to be at a different hardness depending on what the company feels is the best for that tool. Harder tools hold an edge longer but they may be brittle and chip or won't hold a good burr if they are scrapers. That is something that is determined by the company.

Toughness (for lack of a better term and I'm really using it loosely here) is it's ability to not break at a particular hardness. Now as I said that's a really loose description but I hope it gets the point across.

The newer particle metal tolls are both tough and hard which is why they seem to hold an edge longer.

Now the tricky part is finding out what each one is made of and understanding the difference. That's what those numbers Terry is asking about help define.

I have been happy with every Packard tool I've bought. I do like my Thompsons better but the Packard's have been good tools for the price.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#8

Scott- I've bought many tools from...

JamieDonaldson

...Packard over the years, and you can be assured they are excellent quality as represented. Brad stands behind his products, and the service has always been outstanding.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#9

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

Galen Vetterick

The HSS 4241 is not an AISI standard number but Chinese. W4 is the tungsten, Mo2 is molybdenum, Cr4 is chromium, and V1 is the vanadium content. To compare to AISI it is probaby just below an M2. How good it is for lathe tools is how good you sharpen and how often they will need sharpening.

A lot of Chinese drill bit are made of this and they dull fast for me in that application.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#10

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

Barbara Gill

A number of years ago I made the mistake of buying some Benjamin's Best tools. The roughing gouge wasn't too bad but the bowl gouge was trash, orange sparks everywhere. I save them in case I am turning off sand or something else I don't want to use my good tools on.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#11

Re: HSS turning tools  thanks ?

Terry Scott

As I thought A risk or you need a crystal ball

I have just imported a box of Chinese chisel samples as I am playing with an idea

My intention was or is to loan sets of tools to new turners .Doesn't mater if they are young or old.If they have that spark in their eye.

The only conditions I will set is when they can afford or can replace the tools ,or are not using them they come back and I lend to the next.

Just my way of trying to keep the craft alive.At the risk of $100 chisels not being returned I thought $20 ones maybe the way to go.Ive re-sharpend the ones I have to the grind I teach with .They did feather and blue up if to heavy handed but the edge

although not as good as a more expensive chisel was far better than the Carbon steel chisels many are still turning with.

The Moq doesnt worry me as I can flick

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#12

RIGHT ON, TERRY

;)

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#13

Jim Evans

Re: Hardness and toughness aren't in the charts

Jim Evans

I was just trying to help. No good deed goes unpunished. I shall adhere to the old adage read more and post less.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#14

Re: Hardness and toughness aren't in the charts

John Lucas

Jim That was lots of help. I downloaded that chart. I have other charts but not one pertaining directly to turning tools. Thanks for posting.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#15

Re: Yeah, but...

Don Evans

Scott, ck that chart a little closer. The top tool listed is a Hamlet 2060, not a standard Hamlet HSS.

Hamlet came out several years ago (maybe 10) with two new to the world tools due to a different steel mixture and they were 2030's and 2060's. Of course at the time there was no mention of what was used to make up these tools but they were bragged on as lasting much longer on sharpness than anything out there.

They did hold an edge longer but in my opinion not enough for the higher price deference. the 2060 being the best. There were of course a lot more expensive than the other name brands using HSS. I bought a 2030 just to see and it was ok but not a great deal better.

I like Hamlets regular HSS tools and most of tools I have are those regular HSS's not the 2030 or 2060.

Of course now I get Thompsons only.

Don

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#16

Re: HSS turning tools  ?

R Payne

I don't think that is M42. At least the given composition doesn't match with the reference I have close.

When I see 4 numbers like that I think of the AISI designations where the first 2 numbers tell the type of steel and the last two give the carbon content in points. at 41 points of carbon I wouldn't expect it to take a great edge regardless of the heat treat. It might not even take a good edge. It should be tough.

Note- I'm not a metallurgist nor do I play one on T.V. I do a bit of blacksmithing and have read some metallurgy texts in pursuit of that hobby.

ron

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#17

Chuck Jones - West TN

In blind test not sure I'd know the difference

Chuck Jones - West TN

My bowl gouges include several Thompson, Sorby, Jordan, Elsworth (probably Crown), and four Benjamin's Best that I bought about a year ago to experiment with grinding. In a blind test I do not know if I could tell the difference. I "think" I have to sharpen the BB's more often, but I suspect that's because everyone has told me I have to.

I have way more turning tools than I need and probably won't have to buy any very soon. If I did I'd probably buy Thompson tools because most of you say they are the best for the money, but darned if I could prove it.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#18

Re: In blind test not sure I'd know the difference

John Lucas

Chuck I went through the same thing when I first got the Thompson gouge. I ran gouges side by side and really had trouble telling the difference. Then I turned some really hard wood followed by a stint turning aluminum. That's when it really showed me how well it holds an edge.

I think almost all the gouges out there are good quality and will work well for 99 percent of the people. The production turners who turn all day will quickly learn the shapes and metals that they prefer. We can learn from them and buy better tools but in reality as you say most people will be quite happy with whatever they buy.

It really all comes down to sharpening. If your good at it you will learn to sharpen whatever tool it is to a grind you prefer and then it will work for you. If your not good at sharpening then the best gouge won't work for you.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#19

Reply-long.

Don Orr

Terry,

As you may already know the alloy designation of HSS is a very broad range of alloys depending on the actual elements making up the alloy. As others have said their mechanical properties are usually modified by heat treatment. The tools you describe apparently have alloying elements of W(Tungsten) 4%, Mo(Molybdenum) 2%, Cr(Chromium) 4%, and V(Vanadium) 1% which according to the chart posted by Jim E. is very close to the Grizzly tool composition made in China. I did not go to any specific chart to see what HSS designation this is though. They will probably serve your purposes well.

As an aside, one of the main advantages of powdered metal technology is grain size. In traditional melted, poured, extruded raw stock the grain size and composition can vary tremenously throughout the material. With powdered metals the melted alloys are well mixed and when atomized, all the particles end up much more uniform in their composition. The resulting pile of powder is then screened to very specific sizes to get out the larger pieces which can cause defects in the finished product. These powders are then reheated, but not to the melting point, to fuse back into a solid blank which can then be handled in a normal machining manner. I worked for several years as a metallurgy tech doing QA in a powder metal production facility and the powders we made were screened to a mesh size of -325 which is extremely fine. That means the particles would pass through a screen with 325 holes on each side of a 1" square. The screens were about 2' x 4'. The whole process is done under either extreme vacuum or inert gas (Argon) so nothing was contaminated by air (meaning Oxygen). What this whole process ultimately produces is a very fine grain metal alloy where each grain is very small and of uniform composition resulting in a very high quality material which is unfortunately expensive. We made material for the hot side of Pratt-Whitney jet engines.

Sorry this got so long, but thought you might find it interesting.

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Don't forget the heat treatment

steven antonucci

Aside from the chemical composition of the steel, you also need to heat treat it correctly to get the right material properties. Even two steels with similar compositions can be vastly different in performance if they are not heat treated correctly.

Need proof? Heat up the end of your favorite gouge with a torch and quench it quickly in oil or water. (joking, do not do this unless you want to destroy a gouge)

Steve

Re: HSS turning tools ?

#21

Re: Don't forget the heat treatment

Don Orr

Check the 1st paragraph, 2nd sentence.