Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Urn

Posts

Urn

#1

Phil Stivers

Urn 

Phil Stivers

I just completed and delivered this urn for a friend.

Massur Birch and Blackwood (threaded).


Re: Urn

#2

Brad Vietje

Beautiful.  Size?


Re: Urn

#3

Phil Stivers

4.75" dia x 3.25" tall at the knob.


Re: Urn

#4

Re: Urn

Roger Chandler

Very nice........super figure in the wood, and nice form.........likely too small for a useful urn, unless the remains are from a very small animal. Again, nice work!

Re: Urn

#5

Phil Stivers

Re: Urn

Phil Stivers

The urn is for a small dog and is the size the customer specified. Urns don't always have to contain all of the cremains to be useful.

Re: Urn

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Urn

Brad Vietje

Good Point.

When we are asked to turn one, this is a very important question to ask!

Very close call: I turned an urn for the cremains of a friend's son, killed at 19 years old, in a hit & run accident in Oregon a few years ago... I read up on the "correct" size, and thought I had it right. This was an urn that would be filled, displayed at the ceremony, then buried with a few sacred and important family artifacts.

Just before the ceremony began, I met with the dad & mom and the tribal leader performing the largely Native American styled ceremony to fill the urn and glue the finial on. Imagine my horror when it turned out to be about 10% too small to contain all the remains! Even after shaking and tapping the urn to settle the contents, it was still a little too small. Turned out to be a blessing in disguise, as the boy's mom, who lived in another state, wanted some of the remains to spread at a favorite site where she and her son had spent many hours together whenever he visited her out West. She wasn't certain how to make the request, having just arrived from out of state the day before, but the goofed-up urn capacity gave her an opportunity.

Phew! I was off the hook this time, but will try to overshoot the internal volume if I ever do this again. It does confirm that a smaller urn can be used, but its best to know these details and family expectations ahead of time!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Urn

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Urn

Mike Stafford

I have found the sizes recommended to be too small in most instances and increase the volume 20% with the help of my wife who is a mathematician who is able to use the calculus to figure the internal volume of a hollow turning.

When I was making flatwork urns I never had this problem......I can figure square/rectangular volumes but when pi and conic sections are involved I always get a headache....Besides folks alway lie about their weight.

Not me but other people....

Re: Urn

#8

Calculus???

david

Oh yea, the subject that almost got me flunked out of college. So long ago...never thought I would actually experience (vicariously) a real life use for Calculus.

Re: Urn

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: Urn

Ric Taylor

Start off by knowing how much the person or animal weighed. Then figure one cubic inch of cremains per pound. You can test the volume cheaply by filling the completed urn with a known quantity (in cubic inches) of rice. If the rice doesn't all fit, hollow out some more.

It is becoming very common to share the cremains with more than one urn or container, often various family members want a portion of the cremains. It's one of those topics that isn't spoken about much.

Ric

Re: Urn

#10

Re: Calculus???

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Calculus not needed -- just use rice or some similar material, measure the volume required and adjust the hollowing to accommodate that volume.

Re: Urn

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Calculus???  Rice????

Mike Stafford

For some of the people who are gravitationally challenged like me, it could cause a disastrous spike in the rice futures market if you bought that much rice..... :b

Re: Urn

#12

Dale Jablonski

Re: Urn

dale jablonski

Ric, thanks for your estimation formula.

Re: Urn

#13

Re: Urn

Hal Taylor

Phil, your post got slightly hijacked. Your urn is very nice, and I'm sure the pet's owner will be quite pleased.

Re: Urn

#14

Phil Stivers

Re: Urn

Phil Stivers

I used the formulas for figuring the volume of s partially filled trapezoid (ain't the web wonderful). In this case the volume (accounting for wall thickness was 23 cu in. Plenty for this puppy. Additionally the client wasn't concerned if it all didn't fit. The urn (size and shape) is what was important.

If using this formula for figuring the volume I would then "oversize" it by 20%.

Does anyone else have a better formula for figuring out the internal volume?

Re: Urn

#15

Phil Stivers

Re: Urn

Phil Stivers

Thanks Hal. Yes it does seem I was hijacked.

Re: Urn

#16

Re: Urn Design Using SketchUp *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Although this was posted on the Segmented Woodturner's by Lloyd Johnson it is good video showing urn design and volume calculations using SketchUp and a couple plugins.


Urn Volume Calculations

Re: Urn

#17

Ellis Walentine

Stunning form, Phil

Ellis Walentine

It's unusual and classic all at the same time, and that Massur birch is nothing short of remarkable. How is it for turning?

Ellis

Re: Urn

#18

Very nice

Mike Foster

I love it, nice form and the wood can't be topped. I am in the middle of a project with some Masur Birch and have had a log of it in the past. Although expensive, that wood is one of my favorites.

Re: Urn

#19

Phil Stivers

Re: Stunning form, Phil

Phil Stivers

Thanks Ellis. It turns wonderfully. Like butter; especially with sharp tools.

Re: Urn

#20

Re: Urn

Mike Brazeau

I was really struck by the overall shape and design, plus the beauty of the wood combinationof your urn when I first saw your post the other day. I have to admit that I clipped and added to my "Inspiration file" for urns. Have only ever done one and that was for my mom's ashes almost 7 years ago, but you never know when the call is going to come.