Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

Posts

Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#1

Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

Jerry Hall

Fully explained in Link below

Couldn't help but think of us all, this forum, and our leapfrogging learning and creative process.

Take the time to watch the video!

It's not in the genes; its in the shavings.


How Language Enabled Innovation and Evolution

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#2

Ric Taylor

Jerry, I Sent You an Email....

Ric Taylor

.... a couple of days ago.

Ric

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#3

Re: Jerry, I Sent You an Email....

Jerry Hall

Ric, Can't find it, nor an email address for you. Try again at jerhall@sbcglobal.net Jerry

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: a bit of a rant

Keith Tompkins

Hi Jerry, thanks for the link....very interesting, but the author overlooks some very important concepts..Yes, many things we take for granted are the result of the learning process being passed from one generation to the next..we build upon what we know; otherwise, we would constantly be reinventing the wheel. The key ingredient he overlooks is individual genius. Some people do indeed learn by copying...if they lose the source they copied from...their advancement comes to a grinding halt. We see that in all aspects of life, including turning. We look to the innovators for our inspiration, while the innovator relys on a fertile mind. History is full of examples; one of my favorites is Nikola Tesla. He invented things that previously didn't exist...at all. The electric motor on your lathe. The AC current that drives it. Wireless technology. The radio...Yes, Tesla, not Marconi. These are a few of his innovations that seemingly came from NOWHERE! Genius at its best. Sir Isaac Newton. Einstein. Edison...the phonograph. Where in hell did THAT idea come from? The light bulb...years of trial and error development to create what seemed impossible. Television. People who refused to accept "that's the way things are done..that's how they've always been done". Yes, language is a key component, but the real secret is the indominable human spirit. I think the author's monkey analogy is flawed...language isn't the barrier...the lack of IQ is the real problem. Even if the monkey could speak, he couldn't tell his partner " Hey, listen chump, if we make a fire hot enough, we can take that red dirt, and melt it down into iron ore, then cast it into a really neat tool." I think that all through history individual effort and VISION, using previous knowledge as a starting point, lead to almost all innovations and advancements. Interesting study...look how resistant the medical profession has been over time to change...even in the face of overwhelming evidence. We don't always know what we think we know. The saddest part of all...if we truly learned from our collective knowledge, there would be no more war. No drug abuse. No senseless murders. No child abuse. No poverty and starvation. Despite all our knowledge and technology, they all still exist. As the Pete Seeger song goes "when will they ever learn? "

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#5

Re: Why Turners share - and steal

John Lucas

Jerry I read it but haven't had time to look at the video yet. Veddddy interesting. I'll get to it sometime tomorrow.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#6

Re: a bit of a rant

Cyril Griesbach

Keith, that's not a rant it's a bit of fact.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#7

Have to agree.

Don Orr

Very good point Keith. Communication of the same ideas over and over doesn't get anyone very far. It's up to the thinkers and idea guys/gals (like you) to innovate and enable progress in any field. Then it's up to the teachers (like you) to get those ideas across to others. Then it's up to the students/learners (like me) to use that information in their own lives. And then those who have learned from others can maybe come up with their own ideas and on and on.

And unfortunately you are also correct about your last few sentences. Many never really learn from their own or others mistakes. Would that it was different.

Interesting article and video though.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#8

Most interesting

john lucas

Although for our purposes the copying statement gets your attention, I think the whole concept he was trying to get to is get across was that we need one common language.

I would love that. Imagine being able to converse easily with the french or German turners. Or Japanese or Chinese. Look how much we've learned sharing ideas with the English, Austrailian and New Zealand turners where our language isn't such a barrier. Notice I left out the Irish, just kidding you guys, love your work also.

Sharing ideas of course does lead to copying. You almost have to copy to some extent to learn new skills. But ideally you take those skills and add your own voice and make pieces that speak for you. Let's face it, all of us can't be Tesla or Einstein.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: Jerry, I Sent You an Email....

Ric Taylor

I sent it again.

Regards,

Ric

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#10

Re: a bit of a rant

david

Keith: I like your points. I read somewhere that a creative person is someone who takes a couple of unrelated principles or ideas and comes up with a new and different entity. I can subscribe to that thought. But to come up with something new and different out of left field, like a genius--and you have to define genius carefully--is very rare. Didn't someone say that everything is derivative?

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Have to agree.

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Don, but you are way too kind, and far too humble. But the simple fact is we are not all cut out to be "artists", no more than we are all capable of being rocket scientists, athletes, doctors or accountants or plumbers. I attempt to teach concepts that can be employed by anyone, and will elevate their turning level. So, rather than encourage people to simply copy what I do, I help them understand why some things work, and why some don't. Understanding a concept is important; I can teach someone to recite the alphabet all day long, but that doesn't mean they can read. I also show people how their life experiences can be expressed through their work...a major step forward.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: a bit of a rant

Keith Tompkins

HI David, Yes, I used "genius" as a example, but I think we all have unique gifts. Sometimes the goal of monetary gain can be a great motivator too. I think the subject of art vs craft falls somewhere into this topic as well.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

Good TED talk

steven antonucci

I enjoy a good TED talk frequently. This one is very good.

So copying is innate? And necessary for progress? Doubt that it could be better said for turners.

He uses language as a metaphor for what we do. We use the lathe as a means of expression. Turners copy potters. Potters copy nature. Anyone that thinks that they are truly doing something "for the first time" simply needs to Google their idea...

Steve

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#14

Steve  I disagree, slightly

john lucas

Although forms are often copied, maybe not per se, but when you start on some shape you have probably seen something similar before. However I think each person adds their own little touch.

I'll use mine as an example. hand mirrors are obviously not new. However each one I do is slightly different than the rest, and probably slightly different than any other.

When people do hollow vessels they probably look like some former earthenware version done thousands of years ago. But I'll bet if you look closely the form is not quite the same, the foot is different, the lip different etc.

This is the excuse I often hear for why we copy, because we are all copying someone from the past and it's all been done before.

Not if you honestly put your heart into a piece. There will be a little bit of you in there somewhere.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#15

And I agree again.

Don Orr

It is very true that not all of us have equal abilities and talents unfortunately. We have to do the best we can with what we have. It's also true that your educational sessions not only impart information and technique, but encourage to explore, experiment, brainstorm and have fun. Thanks for all of that. Now if you could just find me some 30 hour days to get some of my ideas into reality that would be very helpful as well. ;) :D

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#16

I agree Steve

Mike Foster

I had a chance to watch it last night. I really like TED talks and this was a really good one. I happen to agree with the speaker. Of course there are those truly amazing moments of inspiration that people like the Einsteins of this world have when an idea/concept comes from out of the blue. I think that even these ideas build on what we know though, so rely on that learning from the past. Would Einstein have come up with his theories on relativity without the foundations provided by Newton and others? Probably not. This is not to detract from the strokes of genius that happen, just that even they rely on learning and building on what was compiled by humanity before them.

With respect to turning, i think this really hits home. Lot of folks have said that some of the work I do is very original. Not really. I am just interpreting the work that mathameticians figured out and were able to render in 3D programs, and they are building on the work of other mathameticians that preceded them. Cetainly we put a bit of ourselves into all of our own work, but we are really building on foundations laid by fellow humans.

That's what I find so cool about TED talks. I find they really get me thinking, often in a way that I have not considered before. I thought this one was excellent.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: I agree Steve

Keith Tompkins

Hey Mike, Keeping the conversation focused on turning, think about the field in the 1970's. Although one could make a living at one time making turned parts, turning as a profession had become irrelevant...training school kids to turn was no longer a way to provide a job skill, and schools began shutting down the wood programs. Schools could train thousands of kids to become the computer experts of the future instead. Skills such as turning were dying...until the likes of David Ellsworth and John Jordan burst onto the scene. Their creativity has inspired thousands of people to take up the hobby...without them to lead the way, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation. So even though they didn't reinvent the wheel, they steered it in a new direction. Progress isn't automatic; it's people like yourself that will take turning to the next level, by constantly pushing the envelope. Everything the author said was pretty much true, but he gave little to no credit to the importance of the individual, and their contributions.

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#18

Steven Antonucci

Transformation

steven antonucci

I understand all of your points and I agree with them. In fact, I think that they all say the same thing: by connecting the maker's experience with the art work, the transformation of something old to something new happens.

The TED talk was interesting because it showed that, much like the monkeys, some turners will never do anything new because they are content to just copy. The talk sort of suggests that it's burned into our DNA... and that the odd birds are the ones who can do something completely new.

Based upon Mike's suggestion that he's leaning on the shoulders of the mathematical geniuses, famous turners copying classic Greek/Chinese forms, and non-famous turners copying famous turners, I'd say that the TED guy is onto something.

Where is my stick? I want some ants...

Steve

Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#19

that's termites Steve


Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#20

no-Steve's stepping out of the box-going for ants


Re: Why Turners share - and steal *LINK*

#21

Steven Antonucci

Termites with a side of ants