Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shear scraping video done *LINK*

Posts

Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#1

Shear scraping video done *LINK*

John Lucas

Sorry about the choppy editing. The book I have is very poor in teaching how to do precision editing so I suck at it. I'll keep working on it and may get it right after another 10 or 15 videos :)


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7oeiVQLeOd4

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#2

Re: Shear scraping video done

Nick Todd

Great video.

I have a comment & A question:

It maybe my computer, But I only heard the audio from the right channel. I had that from some of the AAW videos. Was this on purpose?

What camera are you using? The crispness of the video is outstanding.

Nick

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#3

Re: Shear scraping video done

Skip Beardsley

John,

Thanks for all your videos but especially this one. I like your approach and find the information is very helpful. I will try putting it to use in the morning as I have a bunch of first cut bowls that are dry enough to process to finish.

Keep the videos coming.

Skip

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#4

Re: Shear scraping video done

Mike from St. Clair Shores

John,

I thought this was another very well done video. I know that to do this it is very time consuming. So thank you for taking the time and making all these videos for us to learn from.

Mike

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: Shear scraping video done

Alan Zenreich

Nice content John.

I see you're still having some problems getting audio on both channels.

If you like, I might be able to help with that and/or video editing tweaks.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#6

Re: Shear scraping video done

John Scheideman

Great video, John. Thanks so much for taking the time to make the video and share it with everyone.

John

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#7

another good one, John!


Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#8

Mike Stafford

You are a fine teacher John.

Mike Stafford

All of your videos demonstrate the techniques in a clear and understandable manner and your explanations are well done.

Thanks.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#9

Re: Shear scraping video done

John Lucas

Nick I have no idea about the sound. As far as I know I'm recording stereo but the whole set up is sort of jury rigged to use the cordless mike.

I am using an older CanonZR900 camera that uses tape. I'm changing over to a Nikon D5100 digital camera as soon as I can learn to use the video portion of it. I figured that out yesterday, at least some of it anyway. I'll try a short video later in the week to see if it works.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#10

Dick Hines

Re: You are a fine teacher John.

dick hines

Another great video, John. Keep them coming.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#11

Re: Shear scraping video done

Hal Taylor

Very good job John. With your videos I am still learning. Thanks.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#12

Brad Vietje

Amen.  Nice Teaching Style, John.

Brad Vietje

John,

Your videos are very good, and very well explained, in a clear and professional teaching style. As others have mentioned, very clear photography and lighting, as well. They are such a welcome change from all the danger-riddled creature-feature punk-turning style YouTube videos that have come up for discussion here!

I wasn't sure of the grain orientation on the first piece, so it would be helpful to either comment or add text about the nature of the piece being turned. Some amazing trick of light, frequency, RPM or the video raster rate that makes that bowl look completely oval when spinning!

Keep 'em coming, John -- well done.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

One of my favorite scrapers...

steven antonucci

Most people have seen the Sorby scraper with the D shaped bar and the interchangeable tips. The teardrop that comes with it takes a brilliant edge.

I have long since sold it, but I still have the cutter. I ground a flat on a 5/8" bar and mount it there. Stiff as you need for working over the rest, and the round bar allows me to roll it to find the sweet spot. I don't think a lot of people think about making a scraper, but this is a go-to tool.

Steve

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#14

Re: One of my favorite scrapers...

john lucas

Steve I made quite a few scrapers back when I did my tool making article for American Woodturner. I had fun experimenting with them.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#15

Yep, thanks for your time.

Richard Jones

A most precious commodity.................

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#16

Re: Shear scraping video done

Mike Brazeau

Awesome work John. I noticed that you have most of your older style scrapers ground in negative rake configuration. I need to take that step. I started using many of these same scrapers again a couple of years ago when I started seeing articles talking about the positive aspects of scrapers. Seems we had fallen into the trap that a multitude of bowl gouges was the solution to all of our problems, when scrapers are easy to make, sharpen and use - and do an great job if used with finesse. Thanks for your time and effort to pass on your unending storehouse of knowledge.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: One of my favorite scrapers...

Mike Stafford

Steve, that is the first scraper that I bought and it is still a go to tool. I think it was recommended in one the first turning books I bought and it is still a very versatile tool.

I think it is called a multi-tip shear scraper and comes with the tear drop scraper and a couple of tungsten carbide 1/4" half round scrapers which can be used for hollowing.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#18

Re: Shear scraping video done

john lucas

Mike I really don't use scrapers all that much anymore. Most of the time I get the cut I want from a bowl gouge. I do use them when I have to such as the lump in the middle of the concave area on the platter.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#19

Re: Shear scraping video done

robo hippy

John,

I finally found another advocate of the point that it is a shear CUT, and not a shear SCRAPE. Some think that it becomes a scrape when you are not rubbing the bevel.

I think all scrapers should have rounded bottom edges for shear cutting like skews do.

I had one multi tipped scraper, a Sorby I think, and never use it. It can't do anything that my standard scrapers won't do, and I like the heft of the heavier tool.

I don't use the negative rake scrapers. I do like the burr straight from the grinder, and CBN wheels leave a much better burr than the standard AlO wheels do.

You can burnish a burr on all scrapers using a triangle burnisher (works better than the round ones), even on NR scrapers, and that burr cuts finer and is more durable than the honed burrs.

I do like a bull nosed profile ) rather than square on the nose, or especially for the outside of the bowl, the swept back/inside scrapers. You can drop the handle and hold it more like a gouge.

MORE SHAVINGS AND LESS SANDING!

robo hippy

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#20

Steven Antonucci

That's the one

steven antonucci

Prior to selling it, I used it for hollowing when my openings were that size and the scraper to get a better inside surface. I kept the teardrop and made the thick steel bar, which allows me to get about 10" over the rest. The handle on the Sorby is too short to be used more than 2-3" over the rest...

S

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#21

Another well done video-thanks!


Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#22

Well done John, but you didn't mention.....

JamieDonaldson

...or illustrate that rounding the edge of the scraper that touches the tool rest will eliminate nicks and allow the tool to more smoothly "glide" across the rest. That rounded bottom edge should also be ground on the Jordan scraper, and tool rest lubed with a bit of candle wax to smoooooth the movement of the scraper.. ;)

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#23

Re: Shear scraping video done

Bernie Weishapl

John on the big Henry Taylor scraper you used inside the bowl what is the bevel angle on the top? Would that be considered a negative rake scraper? Just curious.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#24

Re: Shear scraping video done

John Lucas

Bernie I don't know what the angle is. I call it negative rake because the top is a negative rake. The bevel to bevel angle is not as sharp as Stewart Batty's negative rake scraper. His looks more like a skew on it's side. I'm slowly grinding this one to that angle but just didn't want to just jump in and do it yet.

Re: Shear scraping video done *LINK*

#25

Re: Shear scraping video done

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks John. I have one that has been lying around and a PSI big scraper. It hasn't been used in a while so will make a good one to experiment with.