Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

Posts

Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#1

Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

Mike Foster

I got the idea to try out a bunch of new ideas after seeing a SEM of this stitchwort pollen grain. So this is a dodecahedron, which came out well but I used a piece of wet cherry. You can see in the pic of the form in the jam chuck that it was symmetrical, but once it dried the shape came out wonky, about 4" x 3.75" x 3.5". Mistake #1. I wanted to try the Ukibori technique to raise dimples like in the SEM. Now this is no piece to try this on. I was facing different grain orientation on each face, and I had to try to devise some way to back up the piece while making the dimples. I used a mallet and broke out a couple of chunks when the back up I was using by reaching through the opposite hole with a dowel and didn't get the dowel positioned just perfect. Mistake #2. After the dimples were made and the piece carved back I dunked the piece briefly in hot water and raised the dimples. The bumps ended up being quite varied in size, depending on what grain the face they were on had, mistake #3. I decided to try ebonizing the piece similar to a beautiful piece that Keith Holt recently posted on WOW. It still had some cherry color, so I think he used the iron vinegar technique. I decided to try that which became mistake #4. The areas I repaired with CA did not take the mixture, so did not change color at all, I tried some spot sanding and redoing the ebonizing, and that came out splotchy, mistake #5. So I set it aside to dry after the dunking and vinegar treatment and was working on another piece when I heard some little pops. I think I had stressed the wood with my dimpling and getting the wood wet and then letting it dry again, caused the wood to start some little cracks (confined to just around the holes and about 1/4" long). I know that sound and it is not a pleasant one. Mistake #6. So I decided to really ebonize the piece and used some gesso. That worked fine, but then I got the idea to talk to Molly Winton to see if she burnishes gesso to get a little luster. She gave me some hints on this, but also said she will often use leather dye for ebonizing and gets great results, even over areas with CA. So mistake # #7.

I was really pushing with this piece, but really doing it just for fun to see if I could. I certainly learned a whole lot by doing it and that was worth it by itself. I did get a finished piece, but one that will live in my shop as I would never try to sell a failed experiment.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#2

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

John Lucas

Mike Sounds like your weekend was like mine. Just about everything that could go wrong did. On your raised bump technique. I found also found it difficult to control the bumps. I tried making a tool that was a nail with a washer welded on so that each dip was exactly the same depth. Still doesn't work, wood just has a mind of it's own.

What I'm playing with now is epoxy raised bumps. Thicken the epoxy and then dip a nail, drill bit or whatever into the epoxy and deposit that on the wood. The size of metal controls how much epoxy it picks up and deposits a dot the same size. I'm still learning how thick it needs to be because it settles some during the drying.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#3

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

Jorge

To me it was an exciting learning time you had in there, thanks for sharing it. I've tried the Ukibori technique a couple times and still have a lot to learn, did no like the results yet. The most even was on sugar maple, on the outside of a vase made of a branch with the pith on it, so the grain was quite uniform.

A friend suggested using box elder.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#4

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

Hal Taylor

...in so doing you have learned a lot. Except for being "wonky" it's a pretty good representation. Question - it appears the pollen drains are filled instead of hollow. Is this from the SEM procedure or is it real?

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#5

Brad Vietje

Ah,  But Look At What You Learned...

Brad Vietje

Hey Mike,

Looks like you learned an awful lot on that one piece! I'm sure the lessons will come to bear in the next spectacular success story you share, but I'm glad you shared these lessons with the rest of us, so we can learn, too.

The end result is pretty darned cool, even if not what you were shooting for.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#6

I envy your learning opportunity!


Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#7

I know that Mike is very critical......

JamieDonaldson

...of his own work, but there is no failure in this project. Any time you learn something I consider it a plus, and that knowledge will reappear in future successes, so this piece should be labeled as a "prototype" Mike! :D ;)

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#8

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

Randy Gleckler

As many others have said. Wouldn't it have been more of a failure if everything went way to smoothly. Then you'd have learned nothing to apply to future projects. Looks cool to me even with the learning experiences in it, and I do understand how you feel, I've been learning a lot from my work lately :-D

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#9

Steven Antonucci

Not what you wanted, but not bad...

steven antonucci

One of the biggest problems we all have is when we self-critique. I am my own worst enemy. If I make one niggling mistake, it is all that I will ever see in a piece. Sometimes, what I have made is actually pretty good, but I can't see it.

I think that is the case here.

In looking at this piece, you've given me an idea for something that I may just have to "prototype". (gets me away from having to make something perfect) This piece is a great FIRST ATTEMPT.

If it was easy, why would you want to do it?

Steve

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#10

OK Jamie, a prototype, however...

Mike Foster

I am not sure I will do another. It really was a fun experiment and I was trying a lot of new things with it. I learned a lot and that was worth the time spent. The techniques are sure to surface in some other pieces in the future.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#11

Thanks guys, I guess that I came

Mike Foster

across a little hard on myself, but I really was doing it for fun, and to see if I could pull it off. It kind of worked, but I learned a lot about some techniques new to me and that was well worth the time spent.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#12

texture paint

Jim Pugh

When it comes to putting bumps on a piece, I saw a Mike Hosaluk demo a few years back where he used texture paint to put bumps on one of his 'fish'. My daughter bought me something called 3d paint that I used to make larger bumps on my keyboard so I can find the " home keys" with my numb fingers. Another option.

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#13

Or GOLDEN's Thick Gel Medium Clear Tar Gel *LINK*

charlie belden

This stuff is a bit neater to use than epoxy, adheres to just about anything, starts out milky white so you can see where it's been applied but dries clear - and can be painted - or you can add color to it if you don't go ape with the pigment, ink, stain or dye. Cleans up with warm water and maybe a bit of soap - so no Epoxy Fingers - nor epoxy smell when using it. Has about a 30 min set to the touch time - 3 hours or so if you want to handle it, 24 hours to hard.


Rain Drops Example

Re: Stitchwort, a failed experiment (long)

#14

Experiment passed !!  :-)

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I'd say that you succeeded. Looks really cool.

Ray