Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Posts

Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#1

Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Ron Solfest


I've largely been a lurker on this site for quite a while. A couple weeks ago viewing someones work and the good critical feedback inspired me to put aside some other woodworking I was doing and turn a walnut blank that had been sitting on the shelf for a couple years.

The attached pictures show the result, a walnut bowl approximately 8.25" across and 3.75" deep. I sanded to 400 grit and then used salad bowl finish on it. I would love to get comments on design, technique, or whatever.

Thanks in advance for comments/advice that will make be a better turner going forward.

Ron

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#2

Looking good!


Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#3

I don't see anything to change, because ......

JamieDonaldson

...form, finish, use of material all appear first rate, although these images are a bit too small for careful examination.

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#4

Ron,

GaryG in MD

I'm with Jamie.

First, it's a lovely piece of wood. It reminds me of the great red spot on Jupiter. (A naming opportunity?) You were lucky (or talented) to keep it from cracking at that branch inclusion. The curl and chatoyance really stand out in the completed product. I would have guessed that it had been sanded to finer than 400 -- the finish appears to be flawless, although, as John says, we would have to see a larger photo to really evaluate the finish.

In terms of form, I don't see how it could be any better.

The thickness of the bowl looks very appropriate for its size. I imagine it has a very nice, balanced feel in the hand. At that thickness, it can serve as a functional bowl or a decorative one.

The outside curve appears to be "fair" all the way from the rim to the foot area. (If I were being super picky, I might say that it's possible that it might have a slight flat area about 1/3 of the way up from the bottom, but that could just be the photo -- and one would have to look very, very hard to see it at all, if it's actually there.) I like the way it is turned in slightly at the rim. I like the inward sloping angle of the rim itself. You have chosen to round the inner edge of the rim as it moves inside the vessel, and that's fine. I usually keep mine sharp, but that's strictly a personal preference.

Although I am ambivalent about "feet" (I add them to roughly half my bowls), I like that this one has none -- it seems appropriate for the shape. I can't tell from the photos, but I assume from the one reflection that it probably has a slight concavity to hold it firmly on the table, as opposed to it being a rounded rocker. Either way would be fine.

Overall, you've got a fine piece there that anyone would be proud to have made, and proud to own.

Glad you were prompted into completing this and posting it for us all to see. Now let's see some more!

...Gary

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Keith Tompkins

Hi Ron, I'm partial to walnut, so that's a good start in my book. I like the placement of the knot, and the swirling grain surronding it. The wood appears to have great depth, a sign of a good sanding job. The shape is very attractive, one that I would be encouraged to pick up. A question...how do YOU like it, and why?

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#6

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Skip Beardsley

Ron,

Hope you will share where you got such a beautiful piece of wood. You certainly did it justice.

Both form and finish show lots of care to detail and understanding what goes into a well done piece.

When I first started turning bowls one of my mentors suggested that I include two circles on the bottom to indicate the bottom was turned and not sanded. This is done with the point of a skew. I use the space between the two circles to sign the bowl and identify the wood species and year it was made. That is only a suggestion and has nothing to do with the overall beauty of the piece.

Nice job. Please show us more.

Skip

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#7

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Terry Scott

Nice practical usable salad bowl.

That has been well turned and finished

Just me but id like to see a small bead on the bottom to beak up the large surface area.

This also would serve as border for your signature and the wood name

Cheers

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#8

Don Leydens

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Don Leydens

Ron, it's beautiful as it is, but the few suggestions given would make it even better. Very nicely done and keep up the good work!

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#9

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

Joe Dickason

Ron..I'm with Keith. I'm really partial to walnut also. It's easy to get here in N.E. In. A lot friends burn wood, but don't like it. Its a beautiful wood that is forgiving & easy to manage. I've never tried the salad bowl finish. How many coats? Was it buffed? Really is an eye catcher. I don't think my wife woould let go of it. If she did, my Sis would grab it.

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#10

Brad Vietje

Nailed It, Ron!

Brad Vietje

Nice wood, beautiful profile (especially the slight turn-in at the top), and well finished.

If you have more Walnut, perhaps you can explore a small detail ring on the base, or try different rim profiles. Thanks for taking the leap and posting this. Hope to see more soon.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#11

Thanks

Ron Solfest

Thanks for the feedback, especially the time you took GaryG.

This blank came from a neighbor's tree that came down with a tornado 4yrs ago (flipped our pontoon too). I already gave them a bowl a couple years ago and had roughed this out and it's been sitting on a shelf for a couple years - the rough-out looked pretty ugly so I didn't know what to expect with the branch knot. I was VERY pleasantly surprised with the chatoyance.

Gary is correct about the flat just up from the bottom, I didn't notice it with my eye at first but felt it when I picked it up.

The bottom is slightly hollowed so it sits flat, I've never turned one without doing this - maybe I'll have to try it.

Overall I like it a lot, but I'm a pretty easy grader when it comes to anything with wood grain :)

Concerns/questions I have are mostly around design and finish. I've added pictures of three additional bowls I pulled out of my wife's cabinet. You'll see that I'm not too creative on shapes, I usually have the same general shape in mind and then just go with it as I turn. I'd like to develop a larger shape 'vocabulary.' I put a foot on ~1/3 of my bowls and don't know if I should be doing more, again am not too creative with feet and would like to broaden my repertoire here too.

Regarding finish, I almost always use a few coats of a salad bowl finish. After the first coat it seems I'm just putting it on and rubbing it off though so not sure if it's adding much. I've tried buffing but am not satisfied with my technique as it seems to lint up the shop, and leave lint in the pours of the wood (especially on walnut).

The three bowls below were turned a few years ago, the larger walnut one is ~7.25" by ~2.5", the smaller walnut is about 5", and the butternut one is ~7.75" across by a little over 2" deep. Again note my design space is pretty simple and limited.

Thanks again for the help!

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#12

Re: Thanks

GaryG in MD

Ron,

Those are all good-looking bowls. You obviously know what you're doing, even if you have limited yourself to a relatively small "vocabulary" so far. I like the lift you got on the butternut bowl with that foot. It's large for stability, but not overpowering because of the way you hollowed it into a ring. I think it suits the bowl.

As far as finishing is concerned, we all have our preferred methods. Lint in the grain is certainly a problem with open-grain woods, particularly dark ones. I typically sand to 800 with grit, put on 2-3 coats of Bush Oil (which has a lot of solids and builds very well), and then rub it out with sponge pads or Abralon to 4000. That provides the moderately shiny but not plastic-like appearance that I prefer. There are hundreds of other ways. Read Russ' pages on finishing if you're looking for alternatives.

If you want to get out of your design box, get one of the classic design books -- Raffan or Darlow, or the new one by Derek Hayes. After you read through them, look at your hunks of wood and plan to do something different that fits into one. Draw it on paper first and then force yourself to make the necessary cuts, even if they're not what you're used to.

Have fun, Gary

Re: Looking for feedback on a Walnut bowl

#13

Re: Thanks

Jim Pugh

Gary, I like your very thoughtful critique above. Wish I could do that.

Ron, one suggestion to consider when you are looking for a little style change, the bowl foot is typically around 1/3 the diameter of the bowl. It can be larger or smaller depending on what you choose to do with that bowl. Yours look to be in the 50% range but again, it's your bowl. Put anything on it you want.