Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Axminster chucks

Posts

Axminster chucks

#1

Steve Kubien

Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

Lee Valley has recently started carrying the Axminster chucks & I'm considering picking one up for bowl coring. � I currently have 3 of the Supernova 2's and I'm thinking of getting the Goliath (4-7/8" diameter body) and whichever jaws fit the 4"-6" range.

My 2nd option is to simply pick up a set of #4 jaws by Oneway (i believe they'll fit my SN2's). � The thing that stops me from doing this is those jaws are a larger diameter than the SN2 body and I worry about them being properly supported. The 4-7/8" Goliath would eliminate this issue.

A 3rd option would be to pick up a Stronghold and the #4 jaws but this is more money than I'd like to spend.

So, what are your thoughts? If the #4 jaws by Oneway will fit my SN2's, is that sufficient or am I better getting a larger diameter chuck body and if so, is the Goliath by Axminster up to the job?

Cheers!

Sent from my iPhone

Re: Axminster chucks

#2

Re: Axminster chucks

Fred Holder

Since your have three Super Nova 2 Chucks, I would recommend the Nova Titan Chuck it is a large solid chuck designed for use on large lathes and for larger projects.

This solid 5” diameter chuck with it’s larger jaw capacity, and unique 3 hole jaw slide, is capable of handling much larger projects than the SuperNova2 Chuck.

The Titan can also take all the Teknatool chuck Accessory jaw sets in the range (although with it’s larger size, we recommend appropriate larger accessory jaws as the perfect match)

Most of the above is from the Teknatool website. I have two of the Nova Chucks in the 5" diameter range. The first one I purchased when in New Zealand in 2003 and the second one I got a year or so later when it had been updated. They are excellent chucks.

Re: Axminster chucks

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: Axminster chucks

Bill Blasic

Steve,

Why not get the Nova 5" bowl jaws? Used for 16" and up bowls.

Bill

Re: Axminster chucks

#4

Steve Kubien

Re: Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

Have they officially re-released the Titan?

Re: Axminster chucks

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

Ive kinda got a love-in thing going with the Oneway profiled jaws. Besides, I got me a hankerin' to try a new type/brand of chuck and Lee Valley is 15 minutes down the road from me. :)

Re: Axminster chucks

#6

Re: Axminster chucks

jspelbring

I'm in a similar boat - about to upgrade to a PM 4224, and would like a larger chuck. I'm holding out for the Nova Titan though - when they finally release it.

Re: Axminster chucks

#7

I hate you

john lucas

Well actually it's probably a good thing I don't live close to Lee Valley. I would not have any income left, ever.

Re: Axminster chucks

#8

Re: Titan jaws?

david

I did get a Titan chuck, but have had trouble locating the Titan big bowl jaws, as none of the resellers =Packard, Craft Supplies, etc. to my knowledge have them. These were listed as close to $100 per set, which put me off for a while.

Re: Axminster chucks

#9

Re: Titan jaws?  *LINK*


Titan Jaws and chuck

Re: Axminster chucks

#10

Re: Titan jaws?

Dale Long

I would second Fred Holder's suggestion. I have the Titan with the larger "power grip" jaws and that set up is way more beefy that the Stronghold. and if that won't hold what you want to turn, You'ld better get out your large faceplate with some beefy screws. A heads up - only the jaws designated for the Oneway lever action or Talon will fit the Nova (after you pull the roll pin out of the one Oneway jaw that has the pin in it). The Strong hold jaws DO NOT work in the Nova chucks. Another big plus for the titan over the SN-2 is the much greater range of jaw movement it provides.

Re: Axminster chucks

#11

Steve Kubien

Hate me more...

Steve Kubien

I guess you'll hate me more knowing that I used to work at Lee Valley. Great company (store manager was a, well, I won't say that on Ellis' board).

Re: Axminster chucks

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Titan jaws?

Steve Kubien

I feared this about the #4 Oneway jaws. Seems to me to be a simple thing to make all jaws fit all chucks with a product line (like Teknatool has)...but it must be more complicated than my brain can handle.

Re: Axminster chucks

#13

Re: Titan Powergrip jaws?

david

Titan Powergrip jaws are larger than the ones that come standard with the Titan chuck and have three mounting holes per jaw.

Re: Axminster chucks

#14

Re: Titan jaws?

mjonesrdg

Some of the Titans were made in China...I have one of those. I don't know what is currently available. My Chinese Titan, as you might suspect, is not the quality of the rest of the line. Mine works a little stiff, and the body is not plated, which is no really big deal, but if you are fussy about rust and stain, you might want to inquire about the origin of manufacturer before you order.

Re: Axminster chucks

#15

Re: Titan jaws?

Peter Hyde

Be aware that KMS rarely has any of it's catalog items actually in stock. They had the DVR on a special price and as far as I know have never filled any of the orders.

Re: Axminster chucks

#16

Steve Kubien

Re: Titan jaws?

Steve Kubien

Interesting Peter. I know that Andre Martel and KMS often split orders in order to fill a container (for Vicmark and Teknatool stuff). I got my lathe from Andre and at the time, he didn't have the Nova live centre in stock. He got it from KMS.

Re: Axminster chucks

#17

Steve Kubien

Thanks everybody!

Steve Kubien

Lots of great info, feedback and suggestions. For that, I thank you. I had some really favorable feedback on the Axminster chucks from Mike Foster. I'm going to go that route as I really like the range of jaws offered. I'll report back once I've got it and have put it through its paces.

Cheers!

Re: Axminster chucks

#18

Get the Stronghold

Jorge

Steve,

The stronghold is your best investment, and it is Canadian

The Axminster is a good chuck, identical to the Bison sold for metalwork and you guess it, the Bison is cheaper, would not be surprised if both are made in the same shop and just labeled different. I don't know who sells it.

Good luck on the hunt!

Re: Axminster chucks

#19

Re: Axminster chucks

Mike Brazeau

Can't imagine why you would need #4 jaws Steve. I have #3's for my Stronghold and rarely use them when coring with the Oneway coring set, except only when I have a blank that way greater than the 16" capacity you have on your Nova.

Re: Axminster chucks

#20

Re: Axminster chucks

Craig Daymon

I've heard that the Axminster chucks are a quality product. I'd consider one just to get a set of the O'Donnell jaws. I also like the idea that they all appear to be direct threaded, no insert needed.

The prices look reasonable too, though they are without jaws.

Even though I have a fair collection of Oneway jaws, I have heard and very much agree with Richard Raffan's argument that you are much better off with smooth dovetail jaws.

-Craig

Re: Axminster chucks

#21

Steve Kubien

Re: Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

Mike, one difference...I don't have a Stronghold. :). I have #3 Oneway jaws on one of my Supernova's and the biggest tenon I can grip is 4". IF I had a larger chuck (Stronghold, Titan or the Goliath) I would be able to grip up to 6" which would be more stable than what I'm doing now. My goal is to reduce vibration while coring and start looking at a tenon diameter of 30-40% like was discussed in a previous thread. Who knows? I may be wasting money and if so, I can either sell it or embrace the idea of never having too many chucks. :)

Re: Axminster chucks

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

As I understand things, the dovetail jaws are only more secure within a very limited range (when the jaws are almost completely closed). No?

Re: Axminster chucks

#23

Re: Thanks everybody!

Roger Turnbough

Steve,

Like you, I am investigating another chuck, and believe that the Axeminster may fit what I need. Could you contact me so I can shoot some questions at you?

Roger

rgt10@comcast.net

Re: Axminster chucks

#24

Re: Axminster chucks

Peter Hyde

Steve I'm more or less in the same boat, but different chucks. I have Oneway Talons and the No. 3 jaws which just tear tenons off when coring anything bigger than 14-16" wet blanks. So I switched to a Oneway 8" face plate on the bigger stuff. I turn a foot the same size as the faceplate and only use the 12 screw holes at the rim. Using No 12 sheet metal screw just long enough to go into the tenon 1/2" - 5/8" allows the foot to be returned and screw holes removed wasting about the same amount of wood as a chuck tenon would.

I also have a Vicmarc100 chuck and that uses dovetail jaws and also will take the Talon jaws. Dovetail jaws do need a tenon that fits the perfect circle formed by the jaws to work well. So you loose the size range that's possible with the Oneway profile jaws. There's an explanation why on the Oneway site.

Having said all that I'm definitely adding to my chuck arsenal 1 Axminster Goliath with the Type M Mega jaws and a set of O'Donnell jaws. You just can't have too many chucks and the Axminster are a high quality product manufactured in a new facility in the UK. They are having trouble meeting UK orders right now, probably because of the LV deal :) Considerable savings when compared with a Stronghold and no O'Donnells

Re: Axminster chucks

#25

Steve Kubien

Re: Axminster chucks

Steve Kubien

Peter, your idea of using the faceplate like that is BRILLIANT. My 8" FP has hOles big enough for 3/8" lag bolts but me thinks I'll add some holes for the #12 screws I use on my other fp's.

Thanks!