Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Update on Boresight

Posts

Update on Boresight

#1

Update on Boresight

John Lucas

I spend just a few minutes last night playing again. I made sure the boresight fit more snuggly than before and that seemed to help. The dot is still off but by about half what it was before. Someone who's a math major could probably figure out the degree it's off. At 32" it's about 1/8" assuming the bore sight is accurate which it may or may not be.

I did loosen the tailstock and headstock to see if I could bring them into alignment. Powermatic did a good job there's almost no slop at all. You can barely move the dot at all from 32" away by twisting the headstock. I'm not even sure it moves 1/32". I could not twist the tailstock enough to barely even see the dot move. Possibly if I put the bore sight in the tailstock and tried twisting you could see some movement 32" away. I did put the sight in the tailstock and it alings dead on with center of the headstock.

Not sure what all of this is telling me but it's interesting. I think mostly what I'm trying to find out is when I have a problem is it me, the tools, or the lathe. If I can narrow it down to the lathe being accurate then it has to be me or the tools. Drilling is the most obvious and I'm pretty sure it's the drllls. They just want to flex and follow the grain. I've ground down one side so only 1 cutter works and they run truer but longer thin bits will still run off center.

Re: Update on Boresight

#2

Re: Update on Boresight

Bart Leetch

What was the original reason for this research?

Re: Update on Boresight

#3

Re: Update on Boresight

Nelson

John, you have to much free time!!!!

Re: Update on Boresight

#4

Re: Update on Boresight

Don Evans

John all this sounds so familiar to me as I followed this path several years ago. It all started with me with the problem of needing very accurate drilling. More specific I was joining thin spindles but wanted it so accurate that no one could tell were to joints were. I accomplished that goal finally but not by finding the perfect head/tailstock alignment.

One thing that did help more than anything was the drills I was using. I found brad points on Lee Valley that are sharped with their CNC machine and that took a lot of the problem away. U can get them metric and sae and I encourage you to look at them if you've never tried them. They have them down to very small bits but take care not all the bits they sell are the one's I'm talking about, make sure they state they are done on the CNC as stated. I use these for any inlay round work I'm doing also.

I've got lots of trial and error idea's on this if you are interested in some, I pretty much boiled it down to "if using laser, you'll have to align it through the middle of the spindle from left to right" in order to be extremely accurate, came up with way to do it but it was just more than I wanted to put into it.

I don't think it will work well with adapters involved nor with it on the right end of the spindle, problem is you don't have a reference that way to align it.

Going through the spindle from left to right you have the spindle itself for reference to accurize it.

Would you share were you purchased this laser sight? I'd like to take a look at it as I'm a shooter also.

PM me if you prefer........

Don

Re: Update on Boresight

#5

Re: Update on Boresight

john lucas

The main reason is trying to solve a problem with the threading using the Baxter threader. When I start a thread it only cuts on one side. I have to go .010" deep before the thread cuts all the way around. If you check the wood while it's still on the lathe there is about 0 to maybe .030 runout.

I took the threader to Vic at Bestwoodtools and my threader for all practical purposes is dead on, I think the runout was 2 or 3 ten thousandths. Vic speculates that my lathe is not dead on meaning the headstock could be twisted. Obviously wood lathes don't have to meet metal lathe tolerances so I think he's probably correct and I'm must trying to prove it.

Nobody who looks at my threaded vessels notices the difference in the threads unless I point it out. With a thread that is only .035" deep .010 or so is noticeable to me but then I'm that picky.

Re: Update on Boresight

#6

Re: Update on Boresight *LINK*

john lucas

Don You can see my reply above to find out why I'm doing this. Drilling is just one of the accuracy things I'm playing with. Below is the bore sight I purchased. I'm sure it's a long way from the best but it was cheap enough that if it didn't work I could just use it chase the dog.


http://www.amazon.com/Bushnell-740100C-Laser-Boresighter/dp/B001AGF9N6/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1329239019&sr=8-1

Re: Update on Boresight

#7

Re: Update on Boresight

joe Dickason

Nelson, I think you may be correct.

John,I figure that this is off approximately 0.0039"/inch.If my quick math as an old die builder is still correct it means that this is off about .2298 degrees. How long are you threading?

Re: Update on Boresight

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Update on Boresight

Keith Tompkins

John, I have come up with an eccentric (who, me?) tailstock center; rotate on its axis until the centers line up, and tighten. It would solve all kinds of alignment problems. I've shown it to a few people, but several have said it doesn't matter that much to most turners. For precision work on a less-than-accurate machine it would be a lifesaver...beats the cost of a new lathe :D

Re: Update on Boresight

#9

Re: Update on Boresight

john lucas

Keith machinist tailstocks are adjustable side to side but not up and down. I think my tailstock is OK it's the headstock alignment that seems to be off.

Re: Update on Boresight

#10

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Update on Boresight

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, I have another experiment that you might consider. One of the sets of jaws that I use on one of my chucks is offset by several thousands of an inch. Knowing this, I don't use it if this error is apt to make a difference. Possibly, you have a similar problem. Try starting a thread on a test piece and then re-chucking the piece rotated 180 deg and trying again to see if the apparent offset has changed.

Dennis

Re: Update on Boresight

#11

Re: Update on Boresight

Rich Egan

John:

Your Powermatic is obviously defective. Please break it down, crate it and ship it to me immediately, and I will take responsibility of disposing of it properly.

Re: Update on Boresight

#12

Can borsite be used for hollowing

Ed Larson

I'm looking for a more substantial laser than the cheap ones from office depot. Would this be a candidate??

Re: Update on Boresight

#13

Re: Can borsite be used for hollowing

John Lucas

Ed I don't know. This is kind of large for that purpose and since it's designed to be used without firing the gun (duh) I don't know how it would stand up to the abuse on a lathe.

Re: Update on Boresight

#14

laser source

Jim Pugh

Calpac lasers have just about anything you could want in a laser including ones that will take an external battery. The one I have used for years is CP-TI-327-VBD which has an on/off switch on the end. The batteries last just short of forever. http://www.calpaclasers.com/laser_pointers.html

Hope you find something useful there.

Re: Update on Boresight

#15

Re: Update on Boresight

Jeff in WIS

Quoting John........"The main reason is trying to solve a problem with the threading using the Baxter threader. When I start a thread it only cuts on one side. I have to go .010" deep before the thread cuts all the way around. If you check the wood while it's still on the lathe there is about 0 to maybe .030 runout."

John, unless I am misunderstanding, you said it right there! If the wood is running out, then your threader will only cut on one side...until depth of thread equals the runout. Headstock alignment won't cause that. Imagine your headstock is off at a 45* angle to the ways!! If your threader is in alignment with the ways, you will cut a 45* TAPERED thread, but it WILL cut all the way around, not just one side...as long as the wood is running true.

As for drilling, you want everything in reasonable alignment, but following the grain is going to happen, I believe. It just the nature of wood! I've drilled plenty of wood on a metal lathe, and drills still follow the grain or go off center following softer areas of the wood etc. The smaller the bit, the more the problem. Perfectly straight grain, and perfectly consistent density of the wood, you may win!

Re: Update on Boresight

#16

Re: Update on Boresight

Juergen

John

I followed the link to Amazon and read a few of the reviews, 3 stars from 361 reviews doesn't sound to good. Even many of the 4 and 5 star reviews noted some shortcomings of the device. 91 1 stars reviews vs 102 5 star reviews? I suspect this device is not capable of the precision your trying to achieve.

Re: Update on Boresight

#17

Re: Update on Boresight

Don Evans

John:

I spent a lot of time on this as I stated and here is a couple of things that may help you. It isn't so much the cost of the laser you are using as it is the alignment of it. I know, tell me something you don't already know right?

I did note that the laser you are using is adjustable so that has to be done first and be pretty much on the money before you can use it for the lathe.

My idea was to put the laser on the left end of the spindle, align it through the center of the spindle and then use that to align the tailstock and check the ways.

I came up with using 2 morse tapers that were not drilled out for any particular size, these are available from industrial suppliers like MSC, Enco etc. You can then drill them yourself for any size so the smaller you do that the more accurate so about #50 drill would be good enough. With the laser mounted on the left side of the head you would then align it so it shined through both MT's holes. At that point you have a laser that is, as far as spindle is concerned, shooting down the lathe right where you need it.

Now take it from there and align the tailstock. You can go farther with this by making a metal devise that you could set on the ways and it has a hole in it to match the center axis and moving it down the ways would check them for twist etc. As long as the light goes through the hole you are good.

Back to the laser you purchased, it is good that it has adjustments on it, but you gotta have a way like above to make sure it is adjusted straight.

Wear very good sun glasses to avoid the headache!

Don

Re: Update on Boresight

#18

Re: Update on Boresight

joe Dickason

John,

Food for thought. If you mounted a dial indicator in the spindle of your lathe (ie. chuck/collet), move your tail stock say 6-8" from head. Turn the spindle of your tail stock out close to the indicator. Adjust the indicator so that you get a reading on the tail stock spindle. Now rotate your spindle of your lathe and take the reading for concentric. Seems like this would tell that the center lines of the 2 entities were on the same center line.

If you could mount a face plate in your tail stock, indicate the flat face while turning the lathe spindle I believe you would arrive at a much more accurate result. The next issue then becomes how good (square) is the face plate.

Re: Update on Boresight

#19

Re: Update on Boresight

john lucas

Joe Good thought. I could lay the faceplate down on the bed and indicate the rear to see if those surfaces are parallel. then do the test you mentioned.

Re: Update on Boresight

#20

Re: Update on Boresight

Jeff in WIS

If possible, mount the faceplate to a live center in the tailstock. Spin the faceplate and indicate the face to see if its running true. Good luck. Interested to see what you find out, John.

Re: Update on Boresight

#21

Re: Update on Boresight

joe Dickason

Jeff,

Good point, but I think you need to do 2 tests. One with each end stationary. Turning the face plate would prove that it is square with tail stock. Turning the spindle will then prove that the spindle & tail stock are in line. I think

Re: Update on Boresight

#22

Re: Update on Boresight

Jeff in WIS

Exactly Joe. Once the face plate is running true on the tailstock, then do as you said...leaving the faceplate stationary, indicate the face of it from the spindle.