Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

PM 3520b clicking

Posts

PM 3520b clicking

#1

PM 3520b clicking

Josh Bowman

My PM 3520b is making a clicking sound that seems to be coming from the motor. It's being very hard to isolate, since the cast and steel really seem to carry the noise all over. Here's what I do know: It begins if you put slight tension on the belt. It happens at the same time on the motor shaft, exactly once per revolution.

I have used a hose and stick to try and locate the noise, and it seems very slightly more prominent on the end of the end of the motor. However this are is also more accessible than any other location.

Has anyone ran into this?

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#2

Re: PM 3520b clicking

ihmserv

not that uncommon on the 3520, first thing to check is the alignment of the two pullys and tighten the set screws. that was all it was on my lathe.

IAN

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Chuck Jones - West TN

Josh,

I know there are some similarities and a lot of differences between the 3520 and Jet 1642. Recounting my long battle with this problem on a 1642 might be useful to you.

I finally figured out a collar on the spindle/shaft was rubbing the housing. As best I remember if you opened the little door for access to change belts it was in the inclosure on the end nearest the hand wheel. It was too close to the cast iron housing and it was rubbing against the (uneven) cast iron. I moved it back to the right a slight bit and the problem went away.

The clicking was worst when I applied pressure from the tail stock. Makes sense to me because that probably tends to move the shaft leftward just a smidgen causing the collar to make more contact.

During the long course of finding the problem, I changed both bearings (unnecessarily). Jet TS said I was putting too much pressure on the belt and I have heard of cases where that was the problem, but not in my case.

Good luck.

Chuck

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#4

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Bart Leetch

In any case blue loctite the set screws.

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#5

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Nick Todd

On my 3520a spindle, the tabs on the nut keeper (hand wheel side) was never set from the factory. It loosened over time, and with that, the lock nut loosened, causing the clicking noise.

Nick

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#6

Dick Hines

Re: PM 3520b clicking

dick hines

Josh, thae the spindle lock button out and tighten up the screw on the spindle lock sleve on the shaft. Mine will work loose once in a while.

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#7

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Josh Bowman

The clicking is hard to isolate. But what I know it’s not is the:

speed sensor, I remove it from the hole.

Spindle lock, removed it.

Upper shafts lock nuts tight and locked.

Belt seems clean and the clicking happens on either pulley (but still in the same motor shaft position.

All pulley and sensor set screws checked and were tight.

I believe it must be in the motor, unfortunately, I can’t loosen the belt and isolate it, since the click goes away when I tighten it.

Let me know if you have any other ideas and I’ll try them.

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#8

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Nick Todd

Josh,

Give a try loosening the retaining nut, just to completely remove that possibility.

Nick

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#9

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Josh Bowman

Nick,

You mean the nut between the hand wheel and the casting? I'll try it.....tomorrow. I'm beat from fighting a piece of 13" hickory and my McNaughton! That thing got grabby near the end!

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#10

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Ron Solfest

Josh, if you do a search you'll find a number of similar threads. I ran through the same issue on my PM3520 2-3yrs ago when I got it. You're troubleshooting list sounds identical to mine. After ruling everything but the motor out I called PM and they sent out someone. He ran through the same issues (ruling out shaft sensor, belt issues, pulley issues, all set screws, motor fan, etc). Finally he said it must be a bearing issue in the motor and ordered me a new one. A few weeks later he came with the new motor.

It solved the issue for a few weeks, within about a month the same clicking was back. It's more noticeable with more belt pressure so I developed the habit of releasing belt tension when I'm not using the lathe, and just allowing motor pressure to tension the belt unless I'm turning something really big and slippage causes me to add a little more.

End story, the clicking comes and goes. It's only appears sometimes when running slowly (either that or the clicks run together when running fast). Honestly the last time I remember hearing it was 4-5 months ago but that may be just because I've gotten used to it and don't hear it often.

When the lathe was new I worried about it more because I paid a lot and wanted it to be perfect, I was also worried it would develop into something worse. After the hassle of chasing it, replacing a motor, and isolating it again to the same issue I've given up on it and thought more about my turning than about the lathe.

Good luck, interested in any solution you ultimately find...if you do...

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#11

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Nick Todd

Yes, the nut between the hand wheel & the casting. Loosen it a little past where you started with, before you tighen it. Just to rule out one more thing.

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#12

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Juergen

I'm with Dick on this one. I had the same problem you described. A clicking at the same position on the spindle. I tightened the front pulleys to no avail. Tech support instructed me to tightened the rear pulley by removing the lock button and tightening the 2 set screws. Under one of the set screws is a keyway, make sure it hasn't slid out of position. If so, push it back and tighten the set screw. Turn the shaft 180 degrees and tighten the other set screw. Be sure to tighten the keyway set screw first and for extra security use Loctite.

Re: PM 3520b clicking

#13

Re: PM 3520b clicking

Skip Beardsley

Josh,

I had the same problem some time ago. Since it was still in warranty I took the headstock to our local fix it man who is a powermatic repair shop. It took him some time but he found that there are two set pins on the inside of the housing just inside where the hand wheel is located. One had completely backed out and was gone, the other was well on the way to the same place. YOu might looks in this area.

Good luck

Skip