Re: PM 3520b clicking
Ron Solfest
Josh, if you do a search you'll find a number of similar threads. I ran through the same issue on my PM3520 2-3yrs ago when I got it. You're troubleshooting list sounds identical to mine. After ruling everything but the motor out I called PM and they sent out someone. He ran through the same issues (ruling out shaft sensor, belt issues, pulley issues, all set screws, motor fan, etc). Finally he said it must be a bearing issue in the motor and ordered me a new one. A few weeks later he came with the new motor.
It solved the issue for a few weeks, within about a month the same clicking was back. It's more noticeable with more belt pressure so I developed the habit of releasing belt tension when I'm not using the lathe, and just allowing motor pressure to tension the belt unless I'm turning something really big and slippage causes me to add a little more.
End story, the clicking comes and goes. It's only appears sometimes when running slowly (either that or the clicks run together when running fast). Honestly the last time I remember hearing it was 4-5 months ago but that may be just because I've gotten used to it and don't hear it often.
When the lathe was new I worried about it more because I paid a lot and wanted it to be perfect, I was also worried it would develop into something worse. After the hassle of chasing it, replacing a motor, and isolating it again to the same issue I've given up on it and thought more about my turning than about the lathe.
Good luck, interested in any solution you ultimately find...if you do...