The thread here eroded into discussion about good and bad, right and wrong, art, and the emotion that art elicits from the viewer, when the question I ask is: "Is WoodCentral the venue for political discussion that you would choose?"
As mentioned above, there are plenty of forums available to discuss economics, politics, and social issues that divide us, rather than the woodturning issues that unite us.
I'd like to think that this is an open enough minded forum for people to be able to present work that may have some potentially thought provoking content. Whether it is political, religious, or just opinion...we should be able to engage in a discussion civilly...regardless of viewpoint.
I had a bigger issue with Charlie posting a Sketch-up drawing (because it wasn't a woodturning topic) than I did about the "Trickle down" thing. I need the work to be something someone attempted to make on the lathe to give it any thought (in the context of this forum). Saying that I have a piece in my head that has 9,000,000 rhomboid ellipses in it that will be assembled into a model of the universe has very little value to me unless I do it.
So I'm Ok with posting things about . I think we need more of it.
The idea I posted is merely an example for my question.
"Have YOU done, or have an idea for, a piece that reflects your take on an issue of your time - and if so - care to share?"
I posted a piece a while back called Freak Eye about the issue of the need for On Demand Drug Rehab. That piece took a lot of planning since the eyeball component, and the hardware and software to make it move - and appear to be looking out from inside the "space capsule" - had to fit inside, out of sight.
And before that a piece that was on The Barbara's Bowl Project issue, that was an attempt to reflect one woman's means of approaching her issue - of dealing with breast cancer and chemotherapy. She described how she imagined chemo would be - using a bowl analogy. She would have to spend time in a pool of uncertainty in the bowl, with periods between immersions climb out and rest on a wide rim of the bowl - before "going back in the bowl". This was my attempt at putting the issue of breast cancer and dealing with chemo - a pool of uncertainty in the center, steps on which to rest while climbing back up into the sunshine and a wide rim of grass to lay in, rest and feel the sun - before returning to the pool of uncertaintly
Before that I posted images of dragon flies with a parable about the issue of death and one way it can be thought of - merely a transition from one manifestation of a being/soul to another - from underwater dwelling nymph to a winged creature of the air - same being/soul but appearing as two completely different beings.
So here are some other examples:
It could be a piece that reflects your take on women's health issues - like breast cancer for example.
It could be a piece that prompts discussion of - oh let's say - the Obesity Trend.
It could be a piece, or an idea for a piece, that might evoke thought and perhaps discussion of words like Family or Child and issues associated with those words.
It could be a very personal issue, or a universal issue that I was asking about - and wanted to see such pieces or illustrations of the idea and learn more about what lies behind them - and the WHY.
It's one thing to see and experience a piece with beautiful wood, perfect form and propotions, masterful turning technique and a perfect finish for the piece. It's a totally different thing when the image of a piece sticks in one's head for hours, days, months or years later - and makes one THINK in addition to seeing
Now as to the issue of the value of the idea/concept vs the execution of that idea/concept
The image I posted was of a virtual model of an idea I had about an issue of my time. Going from the idea for the "installation" to the illustration of it took a fair amount of time and effort - learning to use a tool to illustrate the idea, deciding on a form for the components, working out the relative sizes and numbers, getting the surface colors and textures diverse enough yet vaguely recognizable to folks familiar with wood, etc.. As with actual turning, I learned as I went and came away with a more refined idea - and a better understanding of how to use the 3D modeling tool to take an idea half way (or more) to a finished set of components and the other elements that would be needed for the "real thing". The rest is "just turning , that I already know I CAN do".
Yes, an actual installation would have more impact on a viewer than just the illustration, but a picture, or a decent illustration, conveys much more than a few hundred words - and can be taken in much quicker. - and may stick with the viewer longer - or maybe not.
Gary (Garry) Knox Bennett won an AAW contest by submitting a perfect cube of wood - with a circle inscribe in and centered on each of the six faces of the cube. With the information he provided, the resulting sphere - of that piece of wood - was obvious. Since he had demonstrated his ability to do the turning to make it into a sphere - wasn't necessary.
Charlie, For some reason, your pictures in your second post won't display for me.
Having spent some time trying to learn a 3D modeling program, I applaud your effort to reach the level of mastery that you have.
In your original post, you posted a 3D computer model of your concept, as well as text that described the model. Computer generated sketches or models hold little interest for me compared to a finished piece. I think they are great tools for use by the person refining a piece or concept. In the text accompanying your model, you put some words in parantheses and quotes that to me expressed your opinion of the economic principle and the current interest in it's reapplication. I do not have a problem with a person creating and displaying a piece that expresses their view. However, when keyboard entry expresses a political view, and others respond with their view, there is a high likelyhood that the forum will become something that no longer holds my interest.
My responce to your post was an indication that I had no interest in a political debate taking over the forum. Had your post not contained what appeared to me to be something that could degenerate into a political debate, my response, if any, would have been different.
From your second post it now is expalined that your intent was not to stir a political debate with your first post, but to encourage others to post work that deals with issues of our time. I agree with that intent. The words in parentheses and quotes made it difficult to see that intent.