Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Posts

TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#1

TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

charlie belden

One of the functions of art is to reflect on issues of the times.

Turners turn vessels ( and a lot of other things)

Vessels hold something. Only when full do they overflow, the excess spilling - or trickling - down the outside of the vessel.

During The Reagan Era, the concepts known as Trickle Down Economics and The Laffer (Laugher) Curve were the justification for lowering corporate taxes and lowering the top tax bracket's taxes.

As is often the case, history seems to repeat itself and these "maxims" are back (They're Baaaaack).

So here's an idea for an "installation piece" that reflects one take (mine) on an issue of our times

TRICKle Down Economics - v2.0.

Whether you agree or disagree with my take on Trickle Down Economics really isn't important. My question is:

Have YOU done, or have an idea for, a piece that reflects your take on an issue of our time - and if so - care to share?


Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#2

I'd better not go there...

mjonesrdg

Issues of our times, social, economical, and political, are more polarized today than I've ever seen them. WoodCentral is a place where polarizing ideas are most often set aside, and where we share ideas, tips, and products related to our passion and love for the beauty of wood and where partisan concepts are seen as meaningless. I hope we can keep it that way.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#3

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Roger Chandler

I will leave the political commentary to another forum ........a nice piece of work notwithstanding.............I hope this forum does not degenerate into a series of political statements or political pieces............that will surely cause a bad taste in many mouths...........

A unique piece of work :)

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#4

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

john lucas

Charlie My impression of trickle down economics was a politician standing on the roof relieving himself and me down below getting the benefit of the trickle down. At least that seemed to be the way it worked.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#5

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Dale Miner

There are plenty of websites where political viewpoints can be expressed. Hopefully this is not one of them.

Charlie, when you get the actual piece finished, post the picture then.

What you have now does not interest me, and it seems to be inflamatory.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#6

Thank you, Dale!


Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#7

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

John Lucas

I'm sorry. I didn't mean to start a problem. But going back to Charlie's piece aren't we allowed to make pieces that reflect a strong feeling. Of course it could be Love since Valentines is coming up but could it also be about loss of a loved one, War, or politics. Certainly it could easily be controversial but then Art doesn't have to be pretty.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#8

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Randy Gleckler

Charlie,

Ideas like this are great because they definitely can foster other ideas like them. I have not done one political because I can honestly say I'm not that political though I def understand what your doing with this idea. I've drawn some ideas lately though that were more Song or Sport driven as it where. The piece you show is interesting as some people would get the Political and either love it or hate it because of it and many others may just look at the time/work invested in that kind of piece.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#9

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

bill Crommett

I would like to suggest that if anyone is offended by an artistic idea that they grow up and get over it. Charlie made a beautiful rendition of a disputed theory and left no opinion about it's validity.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#10

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Stuart Johnson

John, Work by Gerrit Van Ness is an example of an art expression I find for the most part disturbing, political, morally worrisome and at times disgusting. But, it is art and every piece I've seen makes me stop and think about it and the meaning I see in it. The problem comes in when the viewers start commenting on the piece and then expounding on their views and what they feel is being represented. This quickly leads to arguments especially on-line where there is no way to really interact and discuss opposing feelings.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#11

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Dale Miner

John,

There have been postings of completed items on several woodturning websites that have political themes. To my way of thinking, the item made or makes the political statement. If the piece is sucessful, the turner/artist needs to, at the most, give the piece a title.

To my way of thinking, if the artist has put in enough effort to complete the piece, then it has a much better chance of holding the viewers interest long enough to consider what the artist is trying to convey.

My statement that the computer mock-up did not hold my interest is true from the point of view, that at this point, very little effort has been put into the posted concept. If the post was of a completed piece and without verbage indicating the artist's opinion of the Regan economics model, then the work would be much more interesting from severl standpoints. Not the least of which would be to determine what the artists was trying to convey.

As is, to me at least, it seems very close to a post intended to cause controversy.

I actually surf woodturning websites to see other turners work and occasionally post mine to get feedback.

Charlies post did ask a question. My answer to the question is Yes.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#12

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

John Lucas

Stuart I certainly agree. It's always difficult to have a serious discussion on the net without it going overboard. My best friend and I are direct opposites on the political arena. Because we are friends we always stop before it goes to far. It's a shame that won't work on the net.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#13

Steven Antonucci

Installation art in general

steven antonucci

Installations are something that I have started viewing differently tahn I used to. I remember walking into a space at MoMA with my kids and there was a big (20'x40') lint mat on the floor. I jokingly said to the older two "World's biggest clothes dryer cleanout" or something. Upon looking at it closer, it became a lot more interesting piece because it went from "anyone can do that" to "I wonder why they did that?"

We can almost think of our shops as a "personal installation" piece. Why did you put screws there? What is the history behind the marks on the bench? How did that wood pile get created? In a sense, the installation takes place over the course of a craftsperson's lifetime.

I like the idea, with or without the political context, but I've always struggled with the idea being the thing instead of the execution. It's like when you walk into a gallery and there is a movie playing of what appears to be everyday life, but is in fact a carefully scripted series of events made to emulate reality.

I guess what I am saying is:

If I moved my shop piece by piece into an installation at the Smithsonian, it would be one thing. If I made a Sketch-up drawing of my shop sitting in a room at the Smithsonian, it is a lot less interesting to me personally. I have dozen of ideas that I'll never do, but the ones that I bring life to are the ones that I think are the best ones.

Steve

P.S. Trickle down... water flowing bowl to bowl, but somehow not making it all the way down to all of the little bowls...?

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#14

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Barbara Dill

Have YOU done, or have an idea for, a piece that reflects your take on an issue of our time - and if so - care to share?

Charlie, I applaud your work and your thinking. I have had a hard time making turning a conceptual art form. But as my work progresses, I am aware that my work represents a feeling and an esthetic, at least to me. To me, I relate to the primitive and tribal feelings that come from form and asymmetry, as opposed to the finely symmetrical and finely sanded and glossy work that is always an option. And, I noticed that you were menioned in the current Journal article. Way to go and keep up your explorations.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#15

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Steve Mushinski

Love your example John. You for one are at the heart of the results.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#16

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Charlie Drake

Bill, you said it perfectly!

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#17

Betty Scarpino

Function of Art

Betty Scarpino

One of the functions of art is to reflect on issues of the times.

Have YOU done, or have an idea for, a piece that reflects your take on an issue of our time - and if so - care to share? --Charlie

Charlie, I find your first sentence of interest, in particular, "issues of the times." You depicted a political issue. If I were to reflect on an issue of the times, I would select something that had to do with personal relationships.

In general political art usually leaves me cold, although I appreciate the brilliance and execution that goes into much of it, such as the work of Gerrit Van Ness. Conceptual art that reflects political issues usually brings up negative feelings and thoughts, which separates people instead of bringing them together.

I have done a number of pieces that reflect issues of the times, but they're not political issues, they have to do with personal relationships: how do we relate to each other ... what are our ways of interacting? Positive and negative spaces in a sculpture can reflect the realities of interactions and viewed as a whole, can be lovely, in spite of containing negative aspects.

The piece pictured below is titled Familiar Strangers. The background is dark, foreground is light, suggestive of negative and positive aspects of any relationship. Sometimes when I meet someone, even though he/she is a stranger, she seems familiar. And sometimes, even though I know someone really well, at times, he seems like a stranger. There is give and take, positive and negative, but the whole is lively, connected, and beautiful.


Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#18

Re: Function of Art

Dale Miner

Betty,

Nice.

I see in the two parts areas that are complete opposites of the other, yet somehow there are areas that will allow for the parts being close with the opposite areas not interfering with the closeness.

Don't know if that is what you were trying to say with the piece, but that is what comes to my mind.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#19

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Carole Valentine

"But going back to Charlie's piece aren't we allowed to make pieces that reflect a strong feeling."

Of course, John. But the "question" could have been asked using a different but less inflammatory and polarizing subject. Or better, it could have been asked without any specific subject. This is an especially inflammatory topic at the moment, no matter where it pops up, and I think Charlie knew that. Just a case of poor judgement, in my opinion. Had he posted a finished piece, where wood, form, execution and finish could be pondered whether or not one agreed with his politics, that would have been different.

Meanwhile, I may go out to my shop to start work on my piece titled "Trickle-Up Poverty". :D (Sorry, just couldn't help myself! LOL)

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#20

Mike Mills

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Mike Mills

Another + on what Dale said.

I’m glad Betty explained “Familiar Strangers”. I would have guessed a fish (left side - water) and some horned animal (land) sharing the earth in different environments.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#21

Betty Scarpino

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

Betty Scarpino

That works, too! It does look sort of fishy .....

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#22

AMEN

bob davis

AMEN !!! stick to turning..enough politics elsewhere

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#23

Re: Function of Art

john lucas

Betty I'm not sure I'm using the right term but I would put your piece in more of the conceptual idea in that it doesn't say what it is right up front. Without a title you can read many things into it. It's beautiful but of course with the right title could be controversial.

Charlie's is still pretty loose in that it could be interpreted a lot of ways without a title. The title obviously brings up a controversial topic and makes you think and respond.

Garrett's pieces on the other hand sometimes slap you in the face with what they are, and sometimes need a title. I think pieces like his lead to much more controversy simply because he's making a very strong statement and it's hard to interpret it any other way. I love his work and think it's his way of setting up a tent on the capital lawn to protest.

Is that a good thing? I don't know. I suppose it depends on what your trying to say and how forcefully you want to say it.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#24

Betty Scarpino

Re: Function of Art

Betty Scarpino

John, I would categorize my work as conceptually ambiguous (or perhaps having layers of meaning). It appeals to me to make something and let the viewer respond, intellectually and/or emotionally as they connect with the piece (either positively or negatively). Titles aren't necessary, but they're sometimes instructive of my intention and thought process. Some of my titles are more meaningful than others. And yes, some were meaningless (dare I say stupid?) .....

Gerrit's work is definitely not ambiguous.

I don't see ambiguity (or the lack of it) as "good" or "bad." We either like a piece or don't like it. We always feel something, though. And not everyone will (or should) feel the same way when viewing a work of art or craft. Our own personal set of biases and our backgrounds affect our responses.

Re: TRICKle Down Economics Instalation Idea

#25

Steven Antonucci

The value of art is in provoking ANY thought

steven antonucci

and intelligient discussion. People can disagree intelligently (it's hard, but possible :) ) and broaden perspectives. Even if I don't agree with someone's point of view, there is value in understanding it.

Unfortunately, it's sometimes the intent of the artist to open a conversation and then sit back and watch the firestorm without expressing their own thoughts or participating in the dialogue. It seems like their interests lie in manipulating and polarizing a conversation, as opposed to the dialogue between the artist and the viewer.

I want to understand what the artist was trying to communicate, as interpretation can often be ambiguous and even incorrect. I don't necessarily need to be hit over the head with everything, but I can see the work from a different perspective if the artist poses a statement about the piece in question.

Steve