Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Observations on Coring -Long

Posts

Observations on Coring -Long

#1

Observations on Coring -Long

Barbara Gill

I was fortunate enough to be able to become the owner of three root burl stumps. The two Red Maple were not very large but did yield 6 bowl blanks >16". The Tulip Poplar root burl was 5' in diameter. I spent about 15 hours pressure washing, trimming roots, pressure washing and pressure washing.

Since I do not own a coring rig but know someone who does I made arrangements to take 9 blanks to be cored. Her lathe could handle 15.5" diameter blanks so that was what I tried to keep the size to.

This wood turned out to be quite a challenge; down near the bottom of each cored bowl where the knife made the turn toward the center the burled root wood was fibrous, knarley and tough as the devil. I watched the banjo actually flex when the knife would hit one of the tough places. All of the Allen screws that could work loose on the lathe did because of the vibration.

Now before some of you jump in here with advice and maybe even some BS let me clarify. The owner of the lathe and the coring rig is not a novice and for sure not a beginner. There were two other Kelton owners there. They both took a go at different pieces. One owns a larger more powerful lathe; he too two blanks that were not small enough home and cored them on his General.

Some of my observations. A coring rig is not something a inexperienced turner should use. Anyone who has a coring rig should be very aware of the stress that can be put on the equipment. There are no absolutes in coring. Every variable affects the results. Wood you would not expect to be difficult to core (Red Maple and Tulip Poplar) can be. Root burls can be dangerous to core if you are not careful.

The last observation I will share is if I were to buy a coring rig it would definitely be a Kelton. I had several different shaped blanks, some rounded, some more cone shaped. There was a knife for each. The outcome could be adjusted just by moving the banjo in or out a little.

I am not going to identify the other turners who so kindly helped me out. If they want to add anything or correct anything I have said, please feel free.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#2

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Donna Banfield

I agree with your assessment. I had the Kelton (sold them) and now use the Oneway. Even the Oneway coring set up is not completely foolproof, when you have wood such as the ones you were coring.

Using a coring set up is not something a beginning or inexperienced woodturner should attempt. The problem is identifying who is the inexperienced turner. Some turners who've been doing it for years are still inexperienced - but good luck trying to tell them that :-)

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#3

BarbS

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

BarbS

You ladies are spooking me away from considering a system!

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#4

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Barbara Gill

Donna, that is the truth.

Barb, you have a substantial lathe. You are also smart and can follow directions. I never felt the need for a coring system simply because wood has never been an issue for me. This wood however is probably something I would get once in a lifetime. If I had not had a friend with a coring system I would have considered getting one. Take a real good look at the Kelton. it is the one I would buy.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#5

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

John Lucas

Well I agree. I'm new at coring but I've been turning for a long time. I've now cored cored 4 large bowls with 3 or 4 out of each so I've cut somewhere around 12 bowls. So you can safely say I'm not an expert at coring.

I core one or two very successfully and easily and then fight the next one for all it's worth. I don't know what I'm doing differently. I've tried lubricating the shaft and cutters with wax and WD-40. No real help that I can see.

I am using the Kelton and have some homemade cutters, Hunter cutter, and the Kelton. The Hunter seems to cut better but I still seem to have problems with the shavings building up inside and causing problems. I try to clear them frequently but wonder if that's the problem as the tool gets deeper.

Mike Mahoney makes it look so simple and I've seen him demo twice now and even ran the camera for him so I could watch really close.

When I get a good clean cut it's fun and easy. When I have problems it's just plain frustrating. Kind of like playing Golf. Heck even thought about tossing the tools just like I throw my golf clubs. :)

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#6

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Carole Valentine

Don't be spooked Barb. Yes there is a learning curve, but that is the case with any tool. You would not want to start on wood such as the root burl Barb described, but you don't want to start with stringy junk wood either. Do you remember learning to ride a bike? You struggled for a bit then all of a sudden it was "Ah hah!" and you were flying along? That's what coring is like. Of course you will hit the odd "rock in the road", but don't be afraid of it. You have a substantial lathe with, hopefully, a substantial banjo. My Nova DVR was pushed to it's limits this weekend, but I don't usually core wood that big or with that gnarly interlocking root fiber. Cherry is a good wood to start with, or even red oak.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#7

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Josh Bowman

John, last week after cutting the bottom out of a nice maple bowl, I through the bowl on the floor just to have it spring back up and hit my curtains and knock them down, so I had to eat crow and climb up on a ladder to replace them. I actually after my tantrum have made several nice cores. I'm anxious to try another to see if I'm on to something. A friend of mine told me even with a laser you have to look at what's out of the bowl and visualize where it is and is going. So I've been stopping the lathe often, looking from above and trying to follow the the shape. Easier said than done. Also use compressed air, WD 40 and pull the blade out a bunch. I think if it's rubbing the bowl somewhere, your screwing up. That's at least my current theory.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#8

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

robo hippy

There are a couple of 'newbie' mistakes that many make on their first cores.

First is that they want to put a great big piece on. NO! Start small, in the 10 to 12 inch range, and take 1 core. Get comfortable with that then step up.

Two is the problem you encountered with the root burls. Just like when you turn, when coring, some woods are a lot easier to work with than others. Crotch wood is more difficult. Really hard woods are more difficult. Dry wood is more difficult.

I can make coring with the McNaughton look simple. It took me a couple thousand cores to get to that point. I do a few things different. One is I grind the spear point off square. Much less cutting pressure, and less clogging. Opening up the kerf a bit helps as well.

robo hippy

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#9

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Jeff Willaford

What Barb said plus what Carole said... AND ... Maybe the tenon can be too long and the chuck might help push the blank out. Or the tenon can be too short and let the blank come out when it would not otherwise.

Either way... a lot can be learned from other turners when a group gets together...and a good time had by all.

PS: The coring pros have to re-chuck at times too.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#10

BarbS

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

BarbS

Thanks, Carole. It may be a while, but when I'm ready I'm sure I'll go for it.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#11

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Dale Bonertz

Totally agree with you Barbara in that the tool or coring in general is not for beginners. I suppose someone will make the argument that anyone who starts coring is a beginner. Funky grain wood like that can really beat you and the tool up.

I agree with Robo though for those that want to start with the tool to start with a 10" to 12" size with a larger tenon for more stability. I do disagree with opening the kerf up however. It may help Robo with how he grinds the tip but in general I think it is a bad idea. I use the tool much the way it comes from Kelton and the tip is wider than the tool shaft for the clearance it needs to make the radius and clear chips. In my experience when you open the kerf all you are doing is making it so that chips can more easily bind between the the shaft and the kerf wall. Granted sometimes it can't be help to open it up if you have to realign the angle of entry.

Hope you at least had some fun and laughs to go with it.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#12

Is it worth it?

Carole Valentine

Absolutely! Especially when you find wood like this.



Or this:



Are you going to run into trouble sometimes? Yes...it is tough going when you hit something like this:



But then just when you think, "man, I'm not sure I can handle this wood" you get something like this one that glides through like butter!



We cored these very thick because the wood was so wet and we were not sure how much it would move, but it would have been criminal to turn wood like that into shavings on the floor.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#13

BarbS

I am Very impressed! Dang. I want that.


Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#14

BarbS

Thanks, Barb. I will.


Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#15

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Barbara Gill

A good time was had by all.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#16

Steven Antonucci

one of the few things on a lathe that I still...

steven antonucci

doubt.

Assuming that you've got a good tenon and all of the set-up proper, you can still take a bowl off the lathe with a momentary lack of concentration. Even if you cut it right, aiming the cutter properly and getting a good core is still a cross between black magic and science.

And that's probably after at least 2 dozen cores...

Steve

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#17

Re: one of the few things on a lathe that I still.

Ron Bauer

I agree with all the comments and would add a few. I am not an expert on the Kelton but have cored maybe 20 - 30 bowls. I have broken one large knife at the tang. I suggest that you:

1. Start with smaller conventional rim bowls vs burls or natural edge. The interrupted cuts are always an issue.

2. Loosen the belts so they slip a little on those inevitable catchs.

3. On anything large or potentially problematic core off the biggest face plate that is suitable rather than a tenon/chuck. It requires an extra set up but the safety is well worth it.

4. Speed is important. I core at a slower speed than I would turn.

Burls are trouble. Two days ago I cored a 10" red oak burl and it was the toughest thing I have ever done because of the twisted grain. The whole set up was flexing like an olympic gymnast. At least it was on a face plate.

Good luck.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#18

Re: one of the few things on a lathe that I still.

Dale Bonertz

Ron,

Catches will become more non existent over time. The biggest problem I see when people are getting catches is do to set up. As I watch people set up they will grab any blade and extend it out a couple of inches from the turret and line that up on center of the lathe spindle. This is where the trouble starts. On my system when I extend a blade a couple of inches from the turret and measure from the top of the cutting edge to the ways it will measure say 10 inches (make sure banjo is locked). Now extend the same blade in its full extension and take the same measurement and it may measure 9 3/4". Therefore when coring and you're reaching deep into a bowl you will be cutting well below center and get catches. My cure has been to take the largest blade I own (largest radius jumbo set) and extend it through the turret in its full extension. Now line that up on center of the spindle either by using the point on a spur drive or simply the center of a blank. Use a stop collar on the tool post of the turret and it is now set for any blade in the system. I own the Jumbo, standard and mini and it works for all of them. I do quite a bit of coring so I check mine about every six months to make sure the stop collar hasn't slipped and can say to date and a few years it has not.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#19

"It took me a couple thousand cores

Jorge

to get to that point", thanks for the chin up Robo, just a thou to go... :o)

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#20

Re: Is it worth it?

Jorge

Wow! beautiful, well worth the trouble. Good work Carole!

Ho do you manage to string so many pictures?

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#21

Re: Is it worth it?

Carole Valentine

Just write a bit and upload a pic at the point where I want it in the text, and keep going. :)

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#22

BarbS

Re: one of the few things on a lathe that I still.

BarbS

Thank you, Dale. That is a tip worth writing down and remembering, especially when you don't know what you're doing.

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#23

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Starry Chan

This is a very interesting thread for me as I am starting to appreciate the value of coring.

Last week, I had the chance to buy some very nice Madrone and Big Leaf Maple burls. The lack of coring equipment and experience makes me decide not to make the purchase. I certainly would not want to practice coring with purchased wood.

Everyone is a beginner at learning a new skill or a new piece of equipment. In my case, I am pretty much decided that I will go with the Oneway easy-core in contrary to your recommendation. Kelton is physically demanding and it requires a lot of practice to get the technique down. For occasional coring like myself, the Oneway is a much easier system to learn and the skill is much easier to maintain. With a sharp cutter and patience, I think I can handle coring with the Oneway. I can use free wood for practice. I hope I will be ready for some burl sometime in the future.

Starry

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#24

Thanks!


Re: Observations on Coring -Long

#25

Re: Observations on Coring -Long

Carole Valentine

Not physically demanding (unless you have some really, really contrary wood). Coring is NOT a brute force process. I am a 62 year old weakling and in most cases, I have found that preparing the big blanks for coring and getting them on the lathe is most physically demanding part! :\