Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Posts

Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#1

Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Stuart Johnson

I know there is no such thing as a stupid question but from time to time I think I might come close.

What is it about a 3 jaw chucks that makes them inappropriate for woodturning?

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#2

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

john Veerkamp

33% less holding power.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#3

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Lan Brady

Stuart,

I am not a machinist so this is just my personal observation.

3 Jaws (120 degrees apart) is just not a good grip on softer items like wood. It works great on steel.

4 Jaws (90 degrees apart) have a much better grip on wood.

Have you ever thrown a piece out of a 4 jaw chuck? I suspect we all answer yes. With one less jaw you should expect it to happen more.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#4

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

john Veerkamp

make that 25%

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#5

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Lan Brady

Depends on wheter you margin up or margin down! LOL

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#6

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Jim Pugh

I'll start this off with a few things: Oh by the way, there are no stupid questions here!

1. The typical 3 jaw chuck is made for machining where the tool is mechanically held and fed into the work so there is no likelihood of the operator getting his knuckles busted from working around the jaws.

2. The jaws are shaped for holding metal and consequently stand prouder of the workpiece than the more streamlined woodturning chucks.

3. Because of the tendency for 3 jaws to crush the wood where it is mounted, the hold will probably be less secure.

4. Metal lathe chucks are large. I suspect the attraction is either having one on hand or because some can be had for a very low price. Most woodturners who have been at this for a while have at least one of them. After a brief period of use it didn't take us long to search out a 4 jaw chuck made for woodturning.

5. On some metal lathe chucks, the jaws adjust independently which may be great for mounting an asymmetrical metal piece but is a royal pain when mounting a round wood piece.

Okay boys and girls, add to this.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#7

Mike Mills

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Mike Mills

Can't chuck up square stock.

Jaws on a wood chuck pretty much encircle the entire tenon rather than three small places.

May be possible but I don't think you can use a recess with three jaw chucks.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#8

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Dick Coers

Of course you can use a 3 jaw chuck, you just have to know the limitations.

They will let you grab a wider range of diameters than 4 jaw wood turning chucks. A lot of people used them before there were 4 jaw wood turning chucks on the market. It wasn't that long ago! We used 3 jaw chucks then, because finding a scrolling 4 jaw was next to impossible. On most 3 jaw chucks, the jaws taper down to a narrow contact area that is smooth. It lets you clamp anything from 1/4" and larger. Open that up for a 2" wood tenon, and the contact area is still very small. As other have said, it is very easy to crush the wood, and depending on being on end grain or long grain, the wood may not stay centered. 3 jaws usually have step jaws and work in a recess.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#9

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Actually, the 3-jaw chuck is usable for woodturning. The first 4-jaw scroll chuck was the Nova and it came on the market in 1988. Before that, bowl turners used various ways to hold their work. Collet chucks, faceplates, etc. The 3 jaw machinists chuck was one of them. I used one myself. Still do once in a while. For gripping a tenon on a bowl the jaws are narrow so that if the wood is soft there is a problem. Those jaws sticking out are real knuckle-busters.

If the jaws are reversed I can grip a blank up to about 6 inches to cut a tenon or whatever. Very convenient. Also good for gripping small round pieces.

Grizzley still stocks the chuck and it sells for just under $100 the last time I looked. 5 inches dia. and it is very heavy

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#10

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Bernie Weishapl

I use a 3 jaw chuck on small items. I know Bob Rosand uses them and that is where I got the idea.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#11

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

steve worcester

I was going to say nothing until I came to the square stock statement. Outside of that, it would be availability of jaws. If you use a chuck for metal lathes, the jaws have smooth edges, no undercuts for dovetails and less surface area to grip with.

Not to say it won't work, just less holding power. If you have one already, learn to use it and move forward. But unless it was super cheap, it wouldn't be my first choice to purchase.

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

#12

Re: Stupid (?) Chuck Question

Philip Duffy

Use my 3 jaw machinist chuck all the time for spindle work, holding steel- -pen mandrels, etc. Not all lathe work is on bowl blanks. Philip