Hey everyone. I am usually on the other side but am going to pick up my first lathe ever tomarrow. Of course I have been looking at all of the other things that I really need to go with it.
Has anyone ever used the Woodcraft chuck? It is at least 1/2 the price of just about anything else. Is it any good, worth the money? I search the site but nothing with Woodcraft concerned their chucks.
Opinions are like... er belly buttons. Most people have one.
I'm not aware of a "Woodcraft brand" chuck. Woodcraft carries both Teknatool/Nova and Oneway chucks. I'm assuming you are speaking of the Teknatool chucks.
I have 3 SuperNova 2's, one Nova Midi, and one of the very original Teknatool chucks. Our club also has a Nova G-3. They are all very good chucks in my opinion. For about three years I couldn't imagine needing anything any better. However, about six months ago I came into possession of a Vicmarc VM-150 in a used lathe purchase. If the Vicmarc is not somehow tied up, it is now my "go to" chuck.
One good feature of the Nova line is that (essentially) all jaws are interchangeable across all models of their chuck.
I don't particularly care for the two bars used to tighten the Midi. Some people gripe about the direction for tightening/loosening the jaws on the SN2. The SN2 is opposite the Vicmarc and the Oneway chucks. Big Deal? I don't think so. I need something to make me stop and think occasionally.
They have a Wood River 4 jaw chuck, which is there house brand I believe. It runs right at $100.00. I wonder if this is a get what you pay for situation or a good deal for the money situation.
I have their Pinical and their WoodRiver [same chuck]. I've used them for going on 5 years now. No Complaints. They've held 14 inch rough blanks with only the standard jaws. To use them with two hands, you position the tommy bars where you can squeeze them with your left hand while positioning the blank with your right. Once snug use two hands to tighten at least twice in two different locations on the chuck.
As always retighten ocasionaly especialy with green wood. Do this with any chuck you get.
I know nothing about the others. But like I said in the earlier post, I don't particularly care for the tommy bars. Some people seem to prefer them. I guess it's what you are used to.
I agree with Chuck J. I think in the long run you will be happier with the G3 which is a better chuck and is on sale now. It has a key so you can use with one hand. I have used it for sometime as well as its bigger brother, the SN2.
I have 2 Nova's, a Oneway Talon and a Woodriver. One nova and woodriver use the tommy bars and I don't have a problem with them, as someone said bring the tailstock up and no problem. The reason I bought the woodriver is the jaws open wider than the other three and I use it for holding 3" peppermill blanks.It's a good chuck.
Thanks everyone. I was hoping to hear from someone that had used the chuck. Guy and Nelson both had good things to say so I will take a look, and try to compare them next to each other when I go to the store tomarrow.
Everybody's chuck is better than somebody else's. The three main brands are the Nova, Vicmarc and Oneway. I would tell anyone to choose one of these brands. I have used all three and I promise you that I could rip a piece out of all three if I wanted to. What is more important is to properly prepare your piece for use in one of these chucks. Proper blank preparation is the key for the best possible holding power of any of these chucks. I have not used the other chucks from Woodcraft but as you have read above others have and they have good things to say about them. Not many folks have just one chuck, I have 15 as I do not like changing jaws. If your really concerned find some folks with different chucks and try them yourself because as stated elsewhere opinions are like belly buttons - everyone has one!