Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Why no turning tools that use router bits

Posts

Why no turning tools that use router bits

#1

Why no turning tools that use router bits

charlie belden

With Carbide Cutters being the latest rage in turning tools, why aren't carbide router bits being used? They come in a plethora of profiles turners use, are readily available - and they're inexpensive, relative to the carbide round cutters that are showing up everywhere on turning tools. And they comes with TWO carbide cutters. Adapting them to turning seems to only require drilling an appropriate sized hole for the shank in the end of a piece of round stock, a tapped hole and insert a set screw and all that's left is turning a handle - or inserting the tool in one of the many metal handles available.

Am I missing something significant here?

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#2

Steven Antonucci

There is no reason it wouldn't work


Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#3

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

John Lucas

Charlie I think it was a guy from New Zeland who used a round nose router bit in the end of a tool to hollow boxes. His name will probably hit me later. I think he used HSS. The router bits I have won't get sharp enough to cut really clean. Maybe the newer router bits have better carbide. I haven't done the math to plot surface speed of say a 1/2" router bit at 23000 rpm vs a piece of wood say 8" traveling at maybe 1800 rpm. It could simply be the router seems to cut clean with less sharp edge because of the high speed.

I think I have also seem somewhere that someone is selling some router bits to be used as scrapers. Just don't remember where.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#4

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits *LINK*

Doc Green

Check out the SRB series on this link:


Router Bits as Turning Tools

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#5

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits *LINK*

Guy Bratt

Here you go. Just in. Just what your lookinng for. Or try a ball end mill in place of the router bit.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/LCRBC.html

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#6

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I onced used a carbide core box router bit held in vicegrips to hollow a really nasty piece of teak. Worked fairly well and cured me of ever turning teak again.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#7

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

charlie belden

Did the math

1/2" diameter router bit spinning at 23,000 rpms comes out to 50 feet/sec

8" diameter blank, turning at 1,425 rpms comes out to 50 ft/sec

10" diameter blank, turning at 1150 rpms comes out to 50 ft/sec

But

WHAT IF

rather than a still router bit cutting wood spinning at 1000+ rpms

the bit's turning at 23000 rpms AND the bowl is spinning at 1000 rpms?

Ornamental mills do this - except for the wood spinning, Why not come up

with a means of using a small router, like the Bosch Colt in a holder, riding

on a support platform that can fit inside th bowl?

a bowl?

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#8

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

charlie belden

For $30 from Penn State, it's worth a try.

(I KNEW somebody already had this idea)

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#9

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

jim 9 miles

John- you may be thinking of a hollowing tool-- I think called a Berger tool. I have one and use a lot.

it looks a lot like a router bit. works kind of like a hook tool. Just looked in a couple catalogs to check name, but don't see it anymore.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#10

Re: dont all good  things come out of Nz 

Terry Scott

The Soren Bergen box tool is still available

They cut real clean if used rubbing the bevel



I just happen to have some if anyone is looking

Charlie Ive tried using some router bits for turning even went and brought a green stone that was supposed to sharpen tungsten (I think its silicone carbide ?) However I could never get a keen edge

The only thing I have that has been successful is silver soldering on router cutters to parting tools and my bowl saver blades

They work a treat on hard burl

I think the tungsten maybe brittle as well because Ive had chips come off

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#11

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

Charlie Drake

I've tried a carbide ball nose end milling cutter with less than impressive results-had better luck with Jeff Nicol's specially ground drill bit for hollowing.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#12

Re: dont all good  things come out of Nz

John Lucas

I remember now it was Mark StLeger from Virginia and it was a milling cutter not a router bit. I must have been tired last night.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#13

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

Barry Irby

I tried using a router bit in my big PC Plunge Base Router. Used a fairly large straight cutter, maybe 3/4" and a guide collar. Put a piece on the lathe to be roughed and held the router on the tool rest. Was planning to make a pass and rough the blank to round. Turned on the router and then the lathe. In less than an instant all went wrong. The bit deflected so badly it chewed up the inside of the guide bushing, the router bounced and the bit hit the tool rest and I have a nice nasty gouge in it and after that I don't know what all happened. I might have ruined that part of shorts, but it was over so fast I had no chance to be afraid. That was about five years ago. Ah! To be young and foolish. The bit was trashed. I remember being bummed about throwing away my best go to bit. Will never manage to file that divot out of the tool rest. I have not tried this again. I suspect the cut rate exceeds the capacity of the bit and shaft of the router unless you take very light cuts.

About fifteen years ago I invented the current generation of carbide tipped lathe tools. Sitting in church, day dreaming, getting nothing out of the service, I visualized a set of lathe tools exactly like what is on the market today. That was as far as i got other than acquiring several catalogs with hundreds of cutters in them. Recently I was recounting that tail to Mike Hunter and he explained that while it was clearly a good idea, it was ahead of the technology. The carbide of the time was simply not fine grained enough to have been useful for the turning tools so that if I had proceeded I would not have gotten good results. And you thought there was no benefit to procrastination? Perhaps the carbide on router bits is not what is needed.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#14

HSS Ball End Mill

Dale Miner

Jim Burrowes has a set up that uses a HSS 2 flute 3/8" ball nose end mill. He started using it after a demo from a turner the club had in. I missed the demo and can't recall the turner that demo'ed the use of the end mill.

I did briefly see the end mill Jim uses, and if memory serves correct, it had been reground to an different profile than supplied when new.

The lead of the end mill does provied a positive rake to the cutting action, and the reground shape allows for bevel contact. The shape of the flute spirals and ejects the shavings without clogging.

Somewhere I must have a dull endmill that needs a second life. Next time the lathe gets the on button pushed.....

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#15

Steven Antonucci

A better question...

steven antonucci

If you look at almost all of the "hollowing tools", there is a long handle and a long bar with a hole in it that is intersected with a set screw. The "cutting bit" is whatever it is.

So...

it could be a router bit.

it could be a hook tool.

it could be a ball mill.

it could be a reground drill bit.

it could be a piece of HSS.

(by now, you get the idea?)

I have to assume that if you were crazy enough to stick a foot long bar over your tool rest to cut a spinning piece of wood, you are also crazy enough to try inserting different cutters into the end to see what happens? It's a good idea to keep your speed down until you have some concepts, but it makes good financial sense to give it a shot.

Or you end up paying $110 for a router bit...

Steve

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#16

LOVE my Berger cutters!

mjonesrdg

I keep one mounted in the 7/16" bar and another in a heavy 3/4" bar. I can cut flat across the bottom of a box and just keep coming up the side hogging shavings. Then ride the bevel back down and make sweet little light cuts...cleaner than a scraper! Over 8 years old, and one of them has been to the grinder a couple of times, the other still just honed with a flat card diamond hone. I love them.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#17

Steve Kubien

Simply put...

Steve Kubien

...where would the fun be in that? Seriously, you are talking about largely automating the process. Short of a crippling illness/injury/condition, I can see absolutely no reason to ever venture down this path.

There was a thread on here a while back concerning automating woodturning using CAD/CIM technology. The thread veered into the idea that there is just as much artistry in programming a machine as doing the work by your own hand. There may be merit in that, but not in my shop, ever. There is no amount of money that would me there. But that's just me.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#18

Re: A better question...

robo hippy

I always figured that router bits wouldn't work as well as the carbide turning tips because they are two different types of carbide. One cuts clean, the other doesn't. Perhaps the same with ceramic cutters: might work in some situations, but not practical for woodturning.

robo hippy

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Re: A better question...

lyle jamieson

You Nailed It!! The carbide in router bits, or any other woodworking tool for that matter, is the old carbide, not the new nanograin carbide. My article in December, 2011, AAW journal explaines the difference. If you want to use a router bit or a ball end mill use HSS and sharpen it with a diamond hone.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#20

Re: LOVE my Berger cutters!replacement tips

Terry Scott

Same here a diamond hone and the tips last for years

Many make the mistake of sharpening on a grinder Only do this if you have a major like hitting a nail (or like I did yesterday it fell off the bed and straight onto the cutter

A jig is supplied to aid sharpening on the grinder

If anyone wants a replacement tip let me know and I can send one up

Or the tool for that matter

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#21

Steven Antonucci

Why is everyone so hung up on the material?

steven antonucci

The material (HSS, carbide, wet noodle) is completely unimportant for the quality of the cut. The edge matters and how you present it probably even matters a little bit more. The material only dictates how quickly that edge will wear.

If you cannot get a clean surface with sharp HSS, carbide isn't going to do a thing for you, even if it is nanograined carbide. My point was that it doesn't take much to drill a hole in a rod and try different cutters. Odds are if one works better for you than another, it's the geometry of the cutting edge and how it presents to the wood that made the difference, not the material.

S

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#22

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Why is everyone so hung up on the material?

Lyle Jamieson

Sharp tools are easier and safer to use, in any application. HSS and nanograin will start off and stay sharper then the old carbide. I prefer sharp tools and old carbide and wet noodles dont cut very well. The large particulate of the old carbide will never get very sharp. You can do a ride the bevel slicing cut with a sharpened pipe, an old screwdriver, or a chunk of angle iron, but it will not work very well on the lathe or stay sharp for very long. Why not just use an old file?? Because it will break and stick you in the eye. There are unintended consequences to using a wet noodle. It might work better if you dried the noodle first.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#23

Re: Why is everyone so hung up on the material?

robo hippy

I feel that the popularity of the nano grained carbide is that they are scrapers, which are small in size, compared to my heavy bowl scrapers. This makes them much easier to use, especially for beginners who have yet to get the feel for a shear cut with a gouge, fluteless gouge, or scraper.

A scraper is an excellent tool if you know how to use it, but there is no substitute for a bevel rubbing high shear angle/slicing cut for a clean surface.

robo hippy

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#24

Re: Why is everyone so hung up on the material?

John Lucas

That's why I like the Hunter tools. You can use them as bevel rubbing tools and get very very clean cuts.

Re: Why no turning tools that use router bits

#25

Lyle Jamieson

Amen, & Amen!