Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

what causes this and i hate glue...

Posts

what causes this and i hate glue...

#1

what causes this and i hate glue...

darrin hill

was working on a natural edge bowl, and had some scuffy stuff show up.. these are two photos i took... wondered what caused it...



and then these tearouts... and the bowl gouge is sharp enough to cut paper, so i don't think it's dull..


and then.. right when i took the last photo, the bowl plopped on the ground and came off the glue block. The glue was quite wet.... I had just turned off the lathe and went inside to get my camera... so i had it spinning 10 minutes earlier at 600 rpms..

however, i glued it two days ago... at least 48 hours..

so i checked.. humidity in shop around 41%.. outside 76-95 % over the past two days..

I'm sure my wood could spalt in my shop from the humidity we have in texas. But we did have a big storm yesterday morning.

And both the glue block and the bowl were green... so wet....

advice? how long should i wait to see if these things stick?

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#2

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

darrin hill

and yes... thats a scraper end in the first photo.. i had scrapped a minute or two before i decided to go get my camera... cause i did mention that i used a bowl gouge..

and yes.. my glue block is very long.. bout 6 inches... i won't make them that long anymore, but I'm just starting to use them... didn't know most people use 2-3 inches.. i was using a hollow and a dovetail on my supernova.. i have 130mm jaws for big bowls.. but locals wanted me to do a tenon, so that block is glued to a tenon..

so I'm going for compression instead of expansion...

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#3

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

robo hippy

Okay, the glue block is too long. 1 inch is plenty. About the only glue that will stick to wet wood is the CA/super glue stuff.

The rough surface is tear out, where the wood fibers are tearing before they have a chance to be cut off. If you are using a scraper flat on the tool rest, that will always leave tear out, and worse in some woods, and not too bad in others.

If your gouge is leaving tear out, and it is sharp, then tool presentation (how the cutting edge contacts the wood) is the most likely problem. Find some videos that will show you what to do, or better yet, try to get involved with a local club.

robo hippy

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#4

Rub the bevlel rub the bevel rub the bevel

Terry Scott

If you are you have got a bit of wood that was placed in a heap

Gravity has pulled the water down causing this area to start rotting punky wood

Or it was on the ground and water has been sucked into this area

With a sharp bowl gouge you should be able to get a clean cut on wood like this

Try speeding up the lathe dont push the cut

What this means is you must cut the full rotation before moving on .Slow tools speed across the surface

Using the the bevel with a bit pressure will lie the fibers down as well almost burnishing the wood

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#5

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

darrin hill

. Find some videos that will show you what to do, or better yet, try to get involved with a local club.

im in a local club.. they're the ones who told me to use the glue block in the first place.. they just ddidnt say how long.. I;ve hung out with some of the guys, but our club just started (next week) doing demos and such. The meetings were all talking about stuff and show and tell.. maybe this will help... but I really try to do the bevel riding.. just still need more practice..

and I've watched about every video on the internet. Not really.. but videos and books and tapes and cds and billboards and crop circles can only teach me so much.. Learn by doing,, i only can.. (imagine yoda speaking).

ah well.. I'm still alive and undamaged.

it boils down to the fact that I'm probably one of the most paitent persons u will ever meet. I plant plants that take years to mature, i am primarily a children's photographer (that will teach u patience) and i'm the father of twins.. (more patience)...

however.. I'm probably one of the most impatient people you will ever meet. I want to learn now. My first fish tank was a salt water reef. My second camera was a hasselblad, and my third was a 4x5 view camera. My first lathe was a harbor freight thing i gave away after about 30 days.. my next was a nova dvr xp.. (yep.. bought that size lathe about a month or two into learning).. didn't buy a powermatic or oneway cause i didn't have the room.. or budget for that matter... But i did think about those... I became a master photographer in 2 years, which is close to, but not quite a record, but i was the youngest in texas at one time.

The ideas i have of what i want to make are way beyond my experience.... I'm kinda artsy... but i want to make art pieces for a gallery now.. not later. (yes... i know.. don't need to reiterate..) maybe will take a couple of decades to learn, but i never will quit learning... i just want to make COOL stuff ... NOW...

if you think it's bad.. ask mr tabor from our local group, and the one who showed me WC.. he's the one who started teaching me... every time I'm talking to him, his conversations pretty much end with 'you should slow down.'

k.. im gonna go take my adhd meds and clean shop..

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#6

that glue block thing...

darrin hill

so since both my glue blocks and bowl are green, should i just take a hammer and chisel and pry them apart, cut down the block to something manageable, put it on a shelf to dry, and just take some pine boards and glue them into a 2-3 inch thick piece and put that on? Im just wanting to hollow out the bowl roughly so it can dry too...

Boy.. can't want to see all the replies in the morning that start with...

'you should slow down...'

or 'you need a higher dosage of meds'..

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#7

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

robo hippy

All that being said, you need to find some one who can teach/guide you at your own rate. There is a lot to absorb. Learning to feel and hear the wood cut is important, but needs hands on experience to learn. If you live any where near Oregon, I might be able to help.

robo hippy

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#8

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

darrin hill

oregon is a foreign country to me... actually anything north of oklahoma is foreign. I live in central texas.. you're free to visit anytime you wanna get outa the cold and into the heat and humidity.

this is like an impromptu therapy session...

i just spent the past 5 hours setting up a studio in the shop and polishing pendants.. it's almost 2:30 am... night all....

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#9

Keep the Faith! *LINK*

Doc Green

Darrin,

Part of learnin' turnin' is finding out what won't work as well as what does. So in that sense, you're making progress, and pretty fast too!

I see a couple of issues with your glue block setup. First, it is too long, as has been pointed out. It is too small in diameter relative to the piece you are turning. And, What about the join between the glue block and the blank? Both should be perfectly flat and smooth. Further, dealing with wet wood presents another issue of a different sort, namely, what glue to use, as you realize.

As far as the rough surface and tearout are concerned, having a sharp gouge is not enough. The way it is presented is critically important. A shearing cut gives you the best odds for getting a clean cut.

May I refer you to my website? (link below)

First, in the section on Fixtures and Chucks, there is a "Clarification" for one of the projects in the book. And, it just happens to be turning a natural edge bowl. A complete step-by-step is given there, and the procedure doesn't use a glue block.

Second, in the Articles Index, down toward the bottom, there are three articles on working degraded wood. The first deals with mounting degraded wood on the lathe. The second describes the use of a gouge in a shearing cut.

It is more difficult to get a clean cut in degraded wood if it is wet.

More about the shearing cut is given in Part 7 of the articles on gouges.

The website is: www.docgreenwoodturner.com

Have fun, and keep the faith. ~Doc


Doc's Website

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#10

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

John Lucas

Robbo is dead on. The tool is not sharp enough or presented at too blunt of an angle. That looks more like what happens when using a scraper rather that a sharp bowl gouge.

Gorilla glue will stick to wet wood but you have to wait overnight for it to dry.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#11

Brian McKearney

Re: what causes this and i hate glue... *LINK*

Brian McKearney

I don't use glue blocks very often, but when I do it's mostly on kiln dried (i.e. "purchased") wood for which I want to use the full thickness and minimize waste. When I do use a glue block, it's typically just a piece off a 3/4" surfaced board - usually pine or whatever scrap is lying around the shop. If you're using a chuck, then the glue block only needs to be thick enough to turn a tenon that your chuck will grab plus a bit extra. Also, I've only used glue blocks on bowls up to about 10" diameter - as the blank gets bigger, you're putting more stress on the glue joint and increasing your chance for failure.

As far as the tear out - it can be quite frustrating. The rest gave good advice. I agree with the advice to ride the bevel and maybe take lighter cuts - the more wood you take off in a single pass, the rougher the surface left behind may be. The final cut should remove a tiny amount of wood with very fine shavings to clean up the surface.

One other thing that I would add - check out Bill Grumbine's DVD (on Amazon or direct from the source) as he presents a lot of great info along with some good cuts to clean up tearout (such as the shear cut - bowl gouge turned almost upside down and produces angel hair ribbons). I got a lot out of it and I think that it improved my turning.

Brian


Bill's DVD

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#12

Re: Keep the Faith!

Bill Neddow

Doc, you have a fascinating website and I would really like to read the articles. Unfortunately, I can't get any of them to open. All the other "buttons" on the site work.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#13

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

Lewis Dodd

Hey Darrin!

Been right where you are! Some woods are just that a way! I can't say I got a cure, but I have applied sand and sealer and waited 3-4 months, coated them in CA glue, spoke a different "Language" to them and still had troubles--the sand and seal seemed to help pretty good. My solution was to stay away from those kinda woods! I don't use glue blocks BTW.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#14

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

eliotandmax

Why use a glue block for this application? Safest( and cheap) would be a flange with screws. Or a good quality chuck. Much to large a project for a glue block!(IMHO)

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#15

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

Barry L Elder

Not meaning to offend, but it seems to me that you expect "instant gratification" instead of waiting for the wood to season and the glue to dry before you start experimenting. You need to start learning with a mentor before you injure yourself! ;)

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#16

Re: Keep the Faith!

Grant Wilkinson

Doc's site and all the links work fine for me, Bill. What browser are you using?

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#17

Re: Keep the Faith!

Grant Wilkinson

Doc: Is your shop apron made from bubble wrap? The only bonking that has ever hurt has been things hitting my chest. My wife keeps saying she wants to get me an umpire's chest protector. I think you've hit on a less expensive solution.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#18

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

This appears to be a classic case of tearout as a result of cutting against the grain. When I'm teaching I have 3 basics...sharp tools, ride the bevel and cut WITH the grain. When you cut against the grain, those unsupported wood fibers just pull out as they've done in the pic. Cutting with the grain slices them off cleanly.

Glue blocks are fine, I use them a lot. I recommend no thicker than 1.5 inch and use dry wood. Glue blocks can be used with a faceplate, a screwchuck or by cutting a tenon, a chuck.

Darrin, keep asking questions, both here and at your club. An experienced turner as a mentor would be a big help. Or a lesson from a pro. Ask at your club.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#19

Shop Apron = Bubble Wrap

Doc Green

Hey Grant, Yep, it's bubble wrap. I intended to use the bubble wrap as a pattern to make a real apron out of leather, but the bubble wrap worked so well I just used it instead. Neck strap and waist band are Velcro strips. It has held up well for several years now.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#20

Re: Keep the Faith!

Doc Green

Sorry about the difficulty, Bill. Click on the Words like Part 1, Part 3, etc, not on the (?) symbols.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#21

Lyle Jamieson

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

Lyle Jamieson

You have made a number of errors all on one piece...how frustrating!! You have broken many basic rules that are easily fixed and others have outlined them here. There is a lot more fun to be had, then you are having now, with sharp tools and good tool control. Hang in there and get some help. Its a long way to go being self taught. We have all been there and it seems to be a lot of pieces to the puzzle, but it will come together for you. Pay attention to details in the glue up process, done correctly, it works better then a chuck for most turning. Im sure my bowl basics DVD is in your clubs library (or it should be). It would be a good comprehensive guide to glue blocks, tool control, and the bowl process.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#22

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

jim 9 miles

Glue blocks & glue. I do 95% of my turning on glue block & faceplate. Several comments above are right on. Green wood- no problem. Try this: screw faceplate to what will be TOP of bowl. rough turn outside & bottom. get bottom good & flat, mark center. let sit & dry about a week. Use scrap 2x4 or 2x6 (dry)for glue block. drill hole in middle of glue block to center it, Let dry 2 - 4 days for yellow glue. rough inside. let dry 1 - 2 months- remount on faeplate , use center mark , &finish turn. when finished turn away the glue block. BTW- no need to fear glue blocks on large pieces- I do 24" to 36" pieces on glue block. Just let it dry a week or two. the glue is stronger than the wood.

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#23

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

darrin hill

thanks for all the input...

i was cringing thinking everyone would be negative...

but i don't know if i got a question answered... should i just take a chisel and snap off the tenon and cut it down and put it on a shelf and make one outa pine lumber? or leave it alone for a week or month?

as far as i know, it's still wet glue..

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#24

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

jim 9 miles

If you glued 2 pieces of wet wood together it probably will not hold. Suggest you cut it off, put blank on faceplate as I mentioned above. Flatten bottom, let dry a week & glue 2 x 6 piece to it. Good luck turning !

Re: what causes this and i hate glue...

#25

Brad Vietje

Getting Back To Basics (Long, As Usual!)

Brad Vietje

Hey Darrin,

Your photos show rather severe tear-out, which is typical for beginners using either dull tools, or a poor cutting technique (probably scraping, not really cutting). If you can see light between the bowl and the bevel of the gouge, you're scraping, not cutting.

On your original question -- yes, cut or chisel it off. Save your little tenon, though.

Now, let's back up the truck, here, shall we? .... ;)

1. Why are you feeling compelled to use a glue block in the first place? You have a chuck, and you have enough room for a little tenon (already there) so the glue block is more of a problem than a solution in this case. Glue blocks are best for dry wood, especially when the depth of the wood is insufficient for a tenon or a recess for chucking. Essentially, you glue on a temporary tenon for use with a chuck or a faceplate.

2. Lose the natural edge -- you need to master the basics first. A natural edge bowl is more difficult than a "conventional" bowl with a turned rim, especially when it comes to keeping the bark on. I'd recommend flattening the top and making a natural-edge bowl later, when the "regular" bowl form is mastered.

3. I would mount this piece between centers, with a drive spur at the rim (top, bark), and the tail center where the foot will be. I'd also use a wood chisel to remove the bark where the drive center is inserted to make sure you have good bite. You will turn away the marks later, so don't worry about them. If you have a sharp point on your tail center, don't drive it in there too deeply, or perhaps you won't be able to turn it away later. Some tail centers have a little point surrounded by a ring, which prevents it from stabbing in too deeply.

4. Unless you really, really need this bowl to be natural edge, once you have it between centers, you can turn the top edge flat with a bowl gouge. Either cut toward the tailstock if mounted as described above, or reverse it so the drive center is driving the foot, and the tail center is at the rim of the bowl.

5. Practice making extremely light cuts. The challenge is to make the finest itsy-bitsy shaving you can make with a very sharp tool.

6. Listen to the tool cut. In this instance, the quietest cut that produces the finest little curls is what you want. There's a particular sound to a perfect cut in green wood, and I can't spell it ;) . Through trial and error, you need to experience it. Better yet, turn with someone who's really good.

7. Bowl gouges can be presented to the wood in a number of ways, and someone may have shown you a poor way to do it. There are too many variables for this note, and they depend on the grind, etc... However, the fundamentals are exactly the same for all bevel-supported cuts. This is best seen in person from a skilled mentor, or on a good video that shows how to initiate a cut.

Since you have green wood you need to decide if you want an oval bowl or a round bowl. If oval and warped, you will need to learn about handling green wood, and possibly wet sanding, alcohol soaking, paper-bagging, etc... (There's a lot to learn about). If you want a round bowl, rough turn to about 10% thickness (say 5/8" - 3/4" or so for a 6" bowl), and set aside to air dry. To avoid cracking you can bag it, wax it, microwave it, etc.... When dry, re-mount between centers, true up the tenon for re-mounting in your chuck and finish-turn, sand and polish the outside, then hold by the tenon to finish-turn, sand and polish the inside, then lastly, re-mount between centers again (using something non-marring to drive the inside of the bowl with the tail center at the tenon), and shape, sand and polish the foot to remove chuck marks. Cut away as much as you dare around the tail center, then cut off the rest off the lathe, sand, polish and sign the bottom.

I'd recommend using this piece of wood as a challenging practice piece -- don't worry about the finished product, just relax, slow down, and refine your cutting technique.

The tear-out your show is pretty severe, and has to be due to incorrect tool presentation if the tool is sharp. Notice as you rotate the bowl, there are two patches of end grain, and two areas of side grain. There are 4 transition areas where side grain transitions to end grain and where end grain transitions to side grain. Typical tear-out happens where the end grain transitions to side grain, which you certainly have. With green wood there are sometimes fibers that pull out in the side grain, but if the wood is sound, and your technique is good, you should be able to cut cleanly across the end grain.

You have a lot of fun ahead of you -- don't rush it, as there are a lot of small details to explore.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT