Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT: Boxes of judgement

Posts

OT: Boxes of judgement

#1

OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

When I look at Roger's White Oak Box, with envy I might add, why is it that some "experts" who judge a box are so critical of one's accomplishment? After all, the box a person turns is their idea of what it should look like - not what some other's view of what something should look like. Is there a bible of turning to tell us what should be, or not to be, in the art of turning, i.e, should the lid overhang / fit inside, base or no base, finial in excess of proporations? What, if any, are the standards to be judged by? Why, you ask? I went form a novice class, upon entering the state fair and earning 4 first places and best of show, to intermediate and receiving 1 first, 2 seconds, 1 third. I'm not trying to blow my own trumpet here, but to receive comments as, "The base is to big, lid is not congenial(?), finial is not correct for piece". Since then, I have sold those pieces, as someone liked them. Of course they weren't "expert" judges either.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#2

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

john lucas

Jim Most of this is based on personal taste. Most of all it's important to make what you want and enjoy it. I take other people's comments and think about them and try to learn from them. I might not agree and that's fine but it's interesting seeing what other think. I mean customers are the same way they just won't tell you what they do or don't like.

A bible. I think Richard Raffen and Chris Stott's books should both be consulted. These guys have sold more boxes than any of us will even think about doing. I would weight their advice quite heavily.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#3

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

John - I have both books by Richard and Chris. And the pages are well worn. It doesn't bother me to receive constructive critizisim, as it is the way to better learn. But, for someone to look at a bowl and say, "See the perfect arc that creates the roundess, this is the correct way to turn a bowl, and doesn't look like a squashed melon". It wasn't my turning that was being refered to, but someone else. All I could think of was; What if I had wanted it to look like a squashed melon? How could this be wrong? As long as it doesn't have a cruddy finish, flat spots, and tear-outs, what difference does the shape make?

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#4

Betty Scarpino

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Betty Scarpino

Jim, I think part of the problem is that we (as fledgling woodturners) have not yet learned how to write/talk about our work or anyone else's work for that matter. People want to respond, but sometimes that response isn't particularly professional or informed, rather it's simply a desire to connect or to respond to something they've seen.

Then beyond that, your response to criticism becomes a decision of how to react to what's been said or written. We would have to evaluate that, too. Is your (not YOU in particular, but anyone who shows their work) response to comments (positive or negative) as measured and considered as it could be ... consider the source, etc.

I can tell you without any doubt, that most people simply do not (cannot) express themselves very well, either written or verbal. It's an art that can be learned (or improved upon) with practice, though. If you are interested, the book, Nonviolent Communication by Marshall Rosenberg can be a life-changer. It was for me. Not only did I read and study the book, I attended weekly and monthly practice sessions for a couple of years. Even so, I still consider myself not very adept at critiquing the work of others. For me, I would need one-on-one communication with plenty of questions asked, as to the intent of the maker. Which is something you mentioned, the maker's intention. Unless we know that, we simply cannot proceed well.

BTW, I thought both boxes with finials were quite nice, albeit differently designed.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#5

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Bill White

Uhhh! See my post on the underhanded turning by the fellow doin' the bowls with a somewhat unorthodox approach. Whatever works for ya is good for me. I'll try to learn from everyone with a lathe and a sharp turning tool.

Bill

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Keith Tompkins

HI Jim, I think all turners go through stages; at first they are happy just to complete a piece without blowing it up. Then, as they progress, their goals are set a bit higher, and finally they may begin to study shape and form in order to improve. It takes time; consider your first pieces...you may be embarassed by them now. Someday,your award winning pieces won't look all that special compared with your current work. It's a natural progression; we build upon what we know. I would encourage you to study, not just woodturning, but all craft and art forms in order to broaden your knowledge base...then apply what you have learned to your work. If you want to learn, study only with the best you can find...you can learn more in a week with them than by years of trial and error. They've probably learned the hard way, and can pass their experience on to you. Don't be afraid to experiment and try new things.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Mike Stafford

I learned a long time ago not to offer constructive criticism about anything posted. Most folks do not really care to hear constructive criticism.

In the case of Roger's box I must have missed the comments to which you refer Jim. I saw Roger's post on WC and WoW and I did not see any negative comments in response to his posts. In both instances Roger did not ask for comments and he did not receive many.

I will say, had it not been for a few people who frequent this board and some others who cared enough to offer constructive criticism I would never have improved. i always value thoughtful design, tooling, sanding, finish, and photographing suggestions. I promise you left up to my own devices I would still be turning bumpy sticks. Some would say that I still am. Heck they may be right..... :D

You know how it is, everybody has an opinion and well, everybody has an opinion. At least Roger's work was not described as brown and round.....

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#8

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

Betty - Critiques I can handle - if they are constructive but, to verbally "attack" someone because an object is not up to whatever standards the attackee has is not right, i.e., my comments previously. I spent 20+ years in the military, so I kinda know what critique is.

Bill - I witnessed your link to that unorthodox turner, scared me! His style works for him. I'm just not ready for that - if ever!

Mike - The negative comments were not directed toward me, it was only what I was thinking at the time. I've turned 8, 3, 4 sided and winged boxes with mixed comments - which is fine. In my grey matter, negative comments are not the same as constructive critisizim.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#9

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

Keith - I try something new all the time AND I've had my share of lathe jumping! Had a box jump off, hit the bed, my lip, the floor and out the door before it stopped. Now I wear a face shield! Also had a laminated bowl explode into a bzillion pieces - because - I was sanding at a to high speed. Suspect the glue got to hot. Yes, the embarrassment level was / is extremely high when first starting out. Those pieces are hidden away in a box somewhere. I've only been at this for two years. My last attempt at turning was the 7th grade, 55 years ago!

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#10

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

Mike - I didn't see any comments about Roger's box either. I was only making comments about my own experience, and the non-constructive critisizisim that some of us unduly receive as a result of somebody's self indulgence of what they think is the perfect turning. Is this making any sense, or am I blowing smoke?

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#11

Three Little Words

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

As Betty mentioned, most of us write poorly. I am a prime example of this. But after reading your post I concluded, three words are missing. They are, "In my opinion."

It is impossible for any one of us to look at a turned piece without forming an opinion. It may, as you suggest, look melon shaped and I don't like melon shapes. It would be wrong for me to state that the shape looks like a squashed melon, but I think it would be OK to say, "In my opinion, it looks like a squashed melon."

Keith gave some good advice. I spent two days with Keith in his advanced bowl turning class this summer. If I learned one thing it was not to accept second class work. He didn't spend time teaching us how to use the tools, but to inspect what we had made with those tools. He pointed out a very small bump on the side of my bowl. I normally would have ignored it. That seemingly little lesson will, hopefully, stay with me forever. Don't say, "That's good enough." Instead don't stop until you can say, "That's the best I can do." Takes longer, but the results are worth it.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Mike Stafford

I'm sorry Jim but I am totally confused. Your first sentence in the post beginning this thread reads, "When I look at Roger's White Oak Box, with envy I might add, why is it that some "experts" who judge a box are so critical of one's accomplishment?" You go on to write "After all, the box a person turns is their idea of what it should look like - not what some other's view of what something should look like. Is there a bible of turning to tell us what should be, or not to be, in the art of turning, i.e, should the lid overhang / fit inside, base or no base, finial in excess of proporations? What, if any, are the standards to be judged by?"

From these comments what else is one to think except that you are talking about Roger's white oak box?

You lost me somewhere but it seems that is becoming a common occurrence anymore....

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#13

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Jim, in woodturning, people go in many directions, and so many aspire to be artists, but at the same time they want rigid standards met as craftsmen. Vases must be narrow 1/3 of the way down, bowls must have feet of a certain diameter, turnings must be thin and a uniform thickness,etc. In woodturning, there are no Picassos allowed, no modern artists, no impressionists -- therefore many turners exhibit schizoid behaviors, torn between standards and free expression.

If you are pleased with what you are doing, that is all that matters. If you like your products, others will also. But, if some don’t like what you are doing, their opinions are not really important. A wise woodturner told me several years ago, “you know you are a woodturner when a stranger offers to purchase something you have made.” Not a bad standard.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#14

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Roger Chandler

Well.........I just saw this thread.........most of the forum participants here know I am fairly new to posting on WC..........so I don't yet know the personalities of most posters here........so I am not sure where anyone is coming from off the bat until I get to know them a bit by the nature of their posts.

In the case of the two boxes I turned from the white oak ..........others who were not in my shop do not know the issues I had to deal with relating to this wood.......there are many, let me assure you!

On this last box, I knew it was a cross grain situation.......not ideal, but in order to utilize this historic wood, I had to figure a way to get something done with it for a specific purpose our club is doing........

I made this design off a sketch I made, and decided this was indeed the form I wanted for this particular piece........whether or not anyone else understands my reason for this form or not, is not important to me. I posted just as a way of sharing and participating on the forum.........if one never posts, then one does not get into the flow of the forum and does not get to understand the dynamics that play out with the interaction in the forum.........thank you for your patience with me........I am still learning here.

I have a number of hollow forms, bowls, table legs, spindle work, platters, natural edge bowls I have made as well as other items, that I have not posted anywhere..........so I am not brand new to turning.......been doing it a few years now..........just started posting on forums the last two years.

I appreciated Keith Tompkins critique........had I not wanted it I would have replied to him in a different way, but he was kind and basically asked permission and was in my mind trying to be helpful. Perhaps there were other comments made that I have not seen as of yet, but I will take a look.

Just know that the form I posted was true to my intention and the situation with the wood I had to work with..........if it does not fit someone else's idea of a good piece............that is their opinion, but they did not have the up close and personal knowledge I have with this particular piece of wood.........they don't know anything about that .........they just know what they like and may have a very good eye for form. If my piece here was inferior in their mind.......so be it.....that is their opinion.....it was still what I intended, and I think the artisans intention is what counts more than anything else. You may not agree...........fine with me!

Sorry for the length of this post.........just wanted to express my mind on the question at hand. Thanks everyone!

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#15

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

I guess words of value got lost in all the translations. I was not expressing anything of Roger's work except admiration. Maybe my expressions were out of context, as they were expressions of what others have said in the immediate world I inhabit, such as a club meeting In no way does my reflections have any bearing on Roger. I was tryin to make a point of reference to verbal judgement ciritques by proclaimed experts. How does words of, "This shape does not conform to what is expected of bowl, box, platter, blah, blah, blah, etc", sound? Instead, why can't the "expert" use words such as, "This is a really nice ..(whatever)...and next time it can be improved by ....." Is this to much to ask? These comments were not made to me, but another turner. And, here it is, 'in my opinion', these words, "This shape does not .....", are a take down of an individual's esteem.

self esteem.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#16

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

Roger - I completely agree with you - and everyone else out there in WC.

I guess my point is - Why tell everyone in the room, of near 60 people, that the

object was not up to whatever standards. Just say it's a nice piece and keep going. Then, after the meeting, give the person a private critique of possibilities

to improve on. Is this to much to ask?

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#17

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Roger Chandler

Jim,

I think we can all learn from one another.........some critiques have helped me develop my eye for form and for better finishing as well. In my experience, most turners are truly trying to be helpful..........there are a few, perhaps that may take a dim view of any form that they perceive as not up to the standards in their own mind. One set of criteria in the mind of a turner can be elevated in their thinking as "the way" to do it, and any deviation in their thinking can disqualify a piece as being "good."

I think there is a danger with getting "locked in" on one look or one way of doing something.......it can make one "narrow minded." In my opinion, if an artisan designs and carries out a design for a purpose........that should rule the day on that piece.........it may be inferior to some who fancy their way as the only truly legitimate design for a given form, but again.........that is just one persons opinion.......although in some case a very educated opinion at that.

I don't allow my feelings to be shaped by what somebody else says, if I can help it...........as far as I am concerned, I feel I can learn from others who have achieved excellence in this or any other wood working endeavor. I have been around the block enough times to know how to separate constructive criticism from a snarky attitude [you called it judgmental]

I have learned that no one knows it all.........there are however a few who think they do!

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#18

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Barry L Elder

Gentlemen, unfortunately we are not allowed to vary from the standards set by a certain group of woodturner/artists who require a college education, "professional" status, teaching certificates, government certification, and AAW membership. (Unless the IRS decides there is no such thing). Michaelangelo, Picasso, Rembrandt, and such other artists are/were not allowed as they are/were able to think for themselves. So, with all due respect to all persons, either "toe the line" or "do your thing"! :D

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#19

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Jim Breeden

Roger - Amen.

And to all the others who have read my rants - thank you. The event horizon has pulled me back into the black hole of whence I emerged to cause havoc, and at this time I am going to take, and disrupt, the words of General MacArthur, "New turners just fade away".

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#20

Steven Antonucci

Then why critique anything?

steven antonucci

If I make something up to my own personal standard and finish it well, what would be the value of asking someone to critique it? If it is exactly what I wanted, then it is perfect.

Unless, it's not...and I am seeking to gain an outside (of my own) perspective to broaden my perspective.

I've never made anything that couldn't be better than it was. That's why I ask for a critique.

Steve

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#21

Re: Then why critique anything?

Terrence Fox

Steve,

It took you only six sentences to cut through all the chatter and hit the target.

Well said.

Terry

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#22

Re: Then why critique anything?

Roger Chandler

Steven.

I agree with your assessment on a general level.........specifically in this instance, I want to point out the following.......

First, I was asked if I would allow a critique..........I did not necessarily solicit one, but Keith was nice and my belief was he was asking in order to be helpful, which I received and appreciate.........I am open to those who offer helpful pointers....we can learn from one another.

Second, Jim has a point related to some folks who come across as self appointed critics whose own judgment and view seem to be held up as "the standard" by which all pieces are to be considered. Let me be clear...Keith was not of this tone or demeanor..........he was trying to help me to avoid a mistake in the future with other boxes I might make............he had no idea of my previous experience or quality of work..........he was being supportive....again thank you Keith!

Now, I have an appreciation for those who are experienced and help those who may not have risen to their level yet..........it is a form of mentoring.

I don't think we disagree on anything here Steven...........I certainly appreciate helpful and constructive criticism and think by and large, most turners are genuinely nice folks who are trying to bring others along in this craft.

thanks for allowing me to clarify, so that no one misunderstands my previous statements. I have good will towards all!

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#23

Steven Antonucci

What I have learned (sometimes the hard way)...

steven antonucci

Some life lessons in looking at other people's work and trying to provide what I think is going to be helpful:

1.) The best way to start a critique is to ask the other person what they don't like about it.

2.) Somethings can be very well crafted, but poorly designed.

3.) Other things can be poorly crafted, but well designed.

4.) It is difficult to address #2 and #3 if you haven't done #1 without causing some level of awkwardness.

5.) Not everyone can take a critique well, no matter how accurate the assessment is. It is of no value to either party if a well meaning message is poorly received.

I have a thick skin, so it's become nearly impossible to insult me. When someone says something "negative" about something I have made, I usually ask them why. It doesn't mean that I agree with them, it just means I am trying to understand their perspective.

(and I have no issues with all arguments presented in these threads... I have made most of them in the past myself!)

Steve

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#24

Re: Then why critique anything?

Jim Breeden

Roger - Thank you for understanding what I was(?) trying to explain, in my own

confused grey matter. The older it gets, the more confused it is.

Re: OT: Boxes of judgement

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: OT:  Boxes of judgement

Keith Tompkins

HI Roger, A critique can be a very helpful tool, or a destructive one if not approached wisely. As a former moderator of this site, I originally proposed that a public forum such as WC could be a very useful tool for learning through online critiques...I still believe it can. I think a critique should be offered only with permission or if the turner asks for one..The intent of a critique should be to help another turner; nothing more. Once you've been at this site for a while, you will realize there's a vast storehouse of knowledge here, and most people are courteous and more than willing to help. I can assure you, you cannot find that spirit in any other craft or art form, quite the opposite. Here's what I tell students or anyone who asks for a critique, or wants to learn my techniques: Listen with an open mind, and give my suggestions a try. Some you may find beneficial, some you may reject outright. Add what you like to your knowledge base, and ignore the rest, that's OK. Over time, each person who influences you adds to what has gone before...Turners can be a myopic bunch at times; don't be afraid to study other art forms for inspiration.