Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

Posts

carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#1

carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

John Lucas

While I was looking through the Pennstateind catalog I came upon some interesting items. Cabide tipped turning tools. They have a skew, spindle gouge and parting tool. Just the first inch or so is carbide. I don't know if they are any good or not, or how they recommend you sharpen them.

I'm going to order the parting tool because I love old craftsman 1/8" tool and it would be interesting to see how they compare.

I have diamond hones and a green grinding wheel that you use for sharpening carbide. I'll let you know what I think.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/LCPM3CAR-P.html

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#2

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: carbide tipped parting tool

Chuck Jones - West TN

John,

It's not diamond shaped and that's one of the things I like about my old Craftsman parting tools. But it probably won't matter as much with the carbide tip.

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#3

Re: carbide tipped parting tool

Sam Scalzo

John,

I purchased a set sometime ago and they did not holh up. PSI sent me another set and same thing. So I gave up. Sam

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

What possible "flaw" could this overcome?

steven antonucci

It's a parting tool. How much simple does it get?

Next thing will be a laser on it so we can see how deep we've parted...sheesh!

The only thing this tool does is part you from you money...

I rehandled my Sears tool from that ugly brown handle it comes in and I am good to go...

Steve

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#5

Re: What possible "flaw" could this overcome?

John Lucas

I also prefer the diamond parting tool because I believe it has less friction on deeper cuts. However Stewart Batty shows a deep cut using a flat parting tool and says it's the fresh burr that gives it clearance. How long that burr lasts is a question I have to ask myself.

When doing duplicates I often will make 5 or six or more moderately deep cuts to establish the depth on details. I don't want to stop and sharpen that often. I thought maybe the carbide cutter would hold an edge longer but don't know if you can even raise a burr, as per SB technique.

Also wonder what kind of carbide they are using and whether the skew could be sharpened well enough to do the job.

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#6

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

John Lucas

I just thought it might hold an edge longer. I like my diamond parting tools. I think they cut deeper with less friction and burning of the wood due to the sides. They do take more concentration to sharpen because the edge needs to be exactly on the widest part of the diamond.

Stewart Batty claims that with a fresh burr a flat tool will cut very deep without burning. Jimmy Clewes claims the flat parting tool will cut straighter when squaring up the end of a piece. I don't have any trouble doing that with my diamond tool and I wonder how long the burr lasts on a freshly sharpened parting tool.

when I do duplicate turning I will often make 5 or 6 or more parting cuts on a piece to establish the depth of different elements. I don't want to stop and sharpen any more often than I have to. I thought maybe this carbide tipped tool would hold up longer during these sessions. Sounds like it might be iffy. They also sell a skew and spindle gouge. Again I wonder if the type of carbide they use will sharpen to a razor edge. I posted a link to the set below.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/LCPM3CAR.html

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#7

With a shaft length of only 3" it will.....

JamieDonaldson

...have limited use for many turners. Since it's advertised as a tool for pen turners it may have a customer base for the cost, but quality apparently remains a question.

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: carbide tipped parting tool

Lyle Jamieson

John, I am sure you are aware of the risk you are taking. But I want to address this for others that dont have your experience. You get what you pay for. If it cost $20.00 is there any way it will stack up to a Sheffield steel tool or other reputible manufacturers. There is no such thing as a free lunch. My guess is it will not be as sharp as HSS and it will never get as sharp as HSS...ever. Im sure you know there will be no burr on carbide. It will stay as sharp as it gets for longer then HSS but if it is not sharp to begin with you have wasted the money. I have tried to use some of their HSS bowl gouges and could not get it sharp. It had HSS stamped right on the side of the tool but it was NOT HSS. How can the Chinese get away with that kind of fraud!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Because someone buys that crap.

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#9

There are many grades of carbide -

John Kaner

I was shocked to find that carbide has so many factors. I had new carbide router bits that were dull...

The factors that affect carbide are:

Binder Type and Concentration

Hardness

Density

Rupture Strength

Grain Size

Yes, it's carbide, but what degree? Just a point and something we should know... Yes, you do get what you pay for...

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#10

Re: There are many grades of carbide -

John Lucas

I agree. I doubt this is good carbide. In fact I doubt it would be anywhere near good carbide. I just thought it was interesting.

So far I have not been able to sharpen carbide to a razor edge. The Hunter tools come very very sharp but I have failed miserably to re sharpen a dull one. Very fine diamond hones just chipped the edge.

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#11

Re: carbide tipped parting tool

Dick Coers

I read one post on the pen turners site, IAP, and the guy claims the tips fall off those tools. No details, he just said he was researching other carbide tools since that happens to them. Can't say what skill level he was either, or if he abused the tools. What is surprising me about the posts here on this one, is the hate put out for the carbide parting tool. I read hundreds of posts about people paying hundred + dollars for carbide insert scrapers. So just PSI hate, or parting tool hate? LOL

Re: carbide tipped parting tool *LINK*

#12

Lyle Jamieson

Re: There are many grades of carbide -

Lyle Jamieson

For you non-AAW people I just published an article in the December AAW Journal and the first half addressed the metallurgy of carbide and the second half about how to use them.

What I hate, yes hate, is not a company or brand, but the misrepresentation of the tools.