Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Posts

Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#1

Clear vs Black dust collector hose

John Lucas

This fall some time I bought some clear dust collector hose from Woodcraft. I didn't open it up until this weekend. It won't fit any of my black connectors and gates. What gives? I looked in Rockler, Woodworkers supply and Woodcraft and that's all they carry the same clear hose.

Do you have to buy all new gates, T's etc. I did find Black hose in PennStateInd.catalog along with some clear hose so I'll probably order that along with some Y's that I need. I thought they would both be the same size. I don't know what to do with this Clear piece now. It's useless unless I make my own adaptors.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#2

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Barry Irby

I don't know the answer, I have never seen the black hose. I bought a piece of he 4" clear about five years ago when I put my system in. Apparently who ever makes dust collector stuff only has a very casual relationship to any measuring device. 4" must be the nominal or approximate size of every thing as in "you can see that its four inch because the six inch is bigger." I spent a huge amount of time cobbling bits and pieces together and making adapters to go from four inch to four inch.

Also, my clear hose got so dirty you can't tell if anything is flying through it or not, so you might as well go with black. And a piece about 4" long split off the business end of it and I had to cut it off and reinstall the connector. And it has gotten stiffer and stiffer with age.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#3

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Alan Van Art

I've used the clear hose. I like it because it's heavier than the black stuff I've used. I've had difficulty getting it to fit some of my fittings, but I've never had to make adapters. It's tough to get on, but it does go on.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#4

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

John Lucas

this stuff is exactly the same size as the small end of my gates and T's. There isn't any way to get it on unless maybe I heat it to near melting. I also have one screw in connector. It won't fit that either. The box says it's 10 feet but I don't think I can stretch it over 8 and not sure it goes that far.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#5

Chuck Jones - West TN

Sounds like a trip back to Franklin...

Chuck Jones - West TN

They will probably take it back or hopefully explain. I bought some clear hose two-three years ago at the discount tool store that was at Opry Mills. It worked fine, but I agree with what Barry says. In a couple days you won't know it's clear.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#6

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

John Veerkamp

The clear hose is likely vinyl. As it ages it out gasses and shrinks. It also gets brittle with age. Black hose is usually polypropolene. It doesn't have the degree of problems that vinyl has. Your hose probably wasn't new in the store and after two years has degraded even more, It might have even started out 4".

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#7

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Lynn Taylor

I have never seen the black hose. I heat my clear hose with a heat gun and even then struggle a bit to get it on the fittings.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#8

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

john lopez

The same thing happened to me with t-track & toggle screws I purchased from

one of the other big stores.

I had kept some components from an earlier purchase (same store, same packaging) I went to make a sliding mount for a task light and ended up

having to purchase more new screws because the new screws didn't fit into the old track.

There is a name for this type of marketing but I won't use it here.

John, if a return or exchange is not an option maybe you can turn some type of coupler that will fit both types of hose.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#9

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Don Evans

John

I've got cyclone with metal pipe going to all machines in shop and have clear from pipe to each machine but one which has black. Have couple of plastic elbows, one on the black going to planer and another plastic elbow going to drill press with clear between elbow and metal pipe. So point is I have conbination of both and all fit just fine.

I much prefer the clear due to it have heavy duty wire in it where as the black doesn't have any wire at all. Clear is stiffer and thicker also.

Also have a couple of pieces of that 4 foot accordion black plastic pipe, the stuff you can bend at different angles and it stay in that shape, no problem with it either. All this stuff had no problem sliding over what ever I was connecting too.

I've never bought any from woodcraft instead all mine came from Klingspor's "The woodworking shop" except the 4 foot pieces of flex and they came from Peachtreeusa.com.

I'd take it back as something just isn't right about it. In my case I think if it shrinks that much I would have noted it when I moved my system into new shop, the pipe was about 5 years old when I moved it.

Don

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#10

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Don Evans

John:

I've got cyclone with metal pipe going to all machines in shop and have clear from pipe to each machine but one which has black. Have couple of plastic elbows, one on the black going to planer and another plastic elbow going to drill press with clear between elbow and metal pipe. So point is I have conbination of both and all fit just fine.

I much prefer the clear due to it have heavy duty wire in it where as the black doesn't have any wire at all. Clear is stiffer and thicker also.

Also have a couple of pieces of that 4 foot accordion black plastic pipe, the stuff you can bend at different angles and it stay in that shape, no problem with it either. All this stuff had no problem sliding over what ever I was connecting too.

I've never bought any from woodcraft instead all mine came from Klingspor's "The woodworking shop" except the 4 foot pieces of flex and they came from Peachtreeusa.com.

I'd take it back as something just isn't right about it. In my case I think if it shrinks that much I would have noted it when I moved my system into new shop, the pipe was about 5 years old when I moved it.

Don

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#11

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

John Lucas

The pennstate black hose has wire in it and they sell it in 50ft lengths which is very economical. Especially since I'll be cutting into much shorter pieces.

I'll check the Klingspor catalog before I purchase anything because I've dealt with them a lot.

I can make adaptors for the clear plastic but that's awful labor intensive for something that should work right out of the box. Maybe it should say "object shrinks as it gets older". Hey maybe I should have that on my underwear, "NOT"

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#12

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Don Evans

This type problem really raises my curiousity.

How bout next time you have the camera handy and nothing better to do snap 2 pix of it, one a close up of one end.

I'm wondering if it is same type as mine or just totally different.

I'm not a fan of PSI so I don't order or even look at their stuff, I got turned off with them many years ago but in all fairness I cannot remember what it was about. It did deal with some of their less expensive stuff not being up to quality I expected even for the price involved.

I reread my previous messge and realized I had a brain freeze (nothing new) I meant to say the black hose has much smaller diameter wire compared to the clear but somehow it came out as implying "no wire" go figure! I'm getting old, I know.

Don

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#13

Camera is on it's way, soon as my hands warm up.


Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#14

I also discovered that the clear......

JamieDonaldson

..plastic tubing seem to create/hold a more potent static charge, collecting dust more than the rest of the black tubing in my dust collector system.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#15

Clear hose photo

John Lucas

I put the bottom of this hose connector in the clear hose. You can see how much it sticks up over the hose. It would really need a lot of stretching to go over that connector.

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

#16

Re: Clear vs Black dust collector hose

Don Orr

I used some of the clear hose on 4" PVC. It was a struggle but I got it on the fittings. The only black fittings I have are the blast gates and they are much smaller than the hose so I had to build them up with several wraps of duct tape so the PVC would friction fit. I believe I got the hose from Woodcraft many years ago. It sat in my attic for a long time (years) til I got my shop set up and ran DC lines. And it is definitely NOT clear anymore.