Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Stuck live center in my tailstock

Posts

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#26

Re: Live Center on Jet Mini

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Mike,

My experience come from my time teaching classes at Woodcraft.

We had several failures of this live center, it may have just been from abuse by new turners in other classes, but they failed just the same.

I use a live center when turning bowls to make sure they are balanced with regard to grain. So a good live center is really important to me.

Maybe I am just spoiled with my Oneway centers. I have a Number 2 for my Jet and a number 3 for my big lathe. I feel that with a little design improvement thay could offer a much better live center. It seems that the Rikon, Delta, and Jet buy their live center from the same place. They look identical to me.

But I am happy to hear that many are pleased with them. But I think they could do way better with a critical part of the whole turning package. Of course, this is just my humble opinion. :)

I am well here in Ohio, and hope the same for you and yours in Apex,NC

Happy Holidays,

Dave

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#28

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

Already tried that Lan.

The ID of the center's taper is exactly the same as the ID of the knockout opening and there is no edge for the larger shaft to catch on.

Thanks anyway.

keithz

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#29

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

Sounds good to me Dave. You are absolutely correct about that God-awful crappy center. It will be replaced, probably with a solid tapered one.

keithz

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#30

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

Thanks for all the suggestions. I have a couple of responses to share.

My first attempt to remove the live center was to turn the handle to the point where the center should pop out as expected. I tried this many, many times to the point where I developed a blister on my hand.

I have not tried using heat. this scares me too much in that I don't know enough about he quality of the metal in the spindle to know how much heat to use and I think that too much heat would make matter worse.

I also own a Jet mini with the same style live center and it has never failed to eject for me.

I'm going to try John's suggestion tonight. Hopefully, I will have success and will be able to report goodness.

keithz

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#31

%^$*&($@ live center!!

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

John,

This was a fantastic idea and was really hoping it would help, but alas, all it did was succeed in knocking the entire end off the taper, ball-bearing and all. >( >( >( >(

I just don't understand what is going with this. :( I tested the tailstock on my Jet mini with the same style of live and and it pops out, slick as oil on ice.

Guess I'll be taking a trip to the local Delta Service Center with the entire tailstock.

I need to get some tenons turned on some blanks so I have things to turn while its gone.

keithz

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#32

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Don Riggs

Kieth,

I had this exact problem when teaching for Fairfax Co. Adult Ed. What I found was the live centers that

I had the problem with were just a little too short and just would not self eject. I solved the problem by inserting a 1/4 inch bolt about 1 inch long in the hole in the tail stock end of it. Masking tape wrapped around the threads to tightened it enough so it would not fall out of the hole and that little extension lengthened it just enough so it would self eject when you backed it off. That was about 10 years ago and they are still working fine.

Don Riggs

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#33

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

Well, my tailstock went to the Delta Service Center today and they got the live center out by heating the tailstock spindle and knocking it out. The live center is toast and they are replacing it, but its time to switch to a good center that doesn't have a hollow taper.

Thanks to everyone that offered suggestions for options to try. Although none of the suggestions panned out for me, I appreciate all of them.

keithz

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#34

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Lan Brady

Keith,

That is good news. I hope you find a live center that fits your needs.

It can be a very useful tool.

Lan