Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Stuck live center in my tailstock

Posts

Stuck live center in my tailstock

#1

Stuck live center in my tailstock

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

greetings all:

I have a serious problem with the tailstock on my Delta 46-460. Since I moved out to Phoenix, I haven't been able to remove the live center that came with the lathe. I hadn't worried too much about it though since I've been way to busy to do much turning. I've finally gotten the time, but now I can't remove that center.

The center that came with my lathe is the crappy ballbearing type that has a hollow taper. When I tried to use the knockout bar to remove it, all I accomplished was to knock the cover off the bearing, making the center completely useless.

Anyone have a solution? I'm about to take the entire tailstock to Delta and have them do whatever they can do.

keith

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#2

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Bill White

Have ya tried heating the shaft?

Bill

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#3

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

john lucas

It's very simple. find out how big of a gap there is between the back of the live center and the front of the tailstock. Get something slightly wider than this. I usually just use a skew. Crank the quill feed back until the live center hits the skew and the skew is pressed against the tailstock. One more crank should pop it out. If not simply lever the skew or flat bar against the live center to pop it out.

I can't remember if my Delta has self ejecting tailstock centers or not. I'll look when I get home.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#4

Alan Zenreich

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Alan Zenreich

Keith,

You shouldn't need the knockout bar to remove the live center from the tailstock.

The tailstock is a self ejecting design. You should be able to simply turn the crank to retract the quill all the way, and the live center should slide right out.

Did you give that a try?

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#5

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Chuck Bjorgen

Yes, the 46-460 tailstock is self-ejecting but I also had a live center get stuck and could not turn the crank enough to loosen it. I finally was able to hammer a chunk of wood against the shoulder of the center to tap it loose. The lathe was only a couple months old at the time.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#6

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Don at Central Illinois

I have the same problem. It is self ejecting, if the live center MT is long enough. Mine isn't. I usually have to us a piece of wood or an open end wrench. Set the wrench between the live center and the tail stock and tap out with a mallet. I'll have to try John's suggestion of using a flat bar or a skew. At least the skew will then be able to do more than opening cans. Good luck

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Its the dry heat(:-)


Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

dick hines

Good use for a skew, John :b

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#9

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Lewis Dodd

I like this reasoning!

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#10

Re: Its the dry heat(:-)

Mike Gibson

Yeah its never going to come out, give yer $10 and take a chance l not getting robbed......

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#11

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

John Lucas

Keith It is self ejecting as others have said. However as a demonstrator I run into this problem a lot because my accessories may or may not work in the Demo lathe. I learned this technique many years ago. Here's a photo that might help explain it better. Most of the time you can just crank the quill back and when the live center bottoms out on the skew it will pop loose.

As I said before sometimes you have to pry the live center out by levering the Skew. I've also used wide parting tools and upside down roughing gouges to do this.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#12

john, you are priceless! 


Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#13

Mike Stafford

Finally.....

Mike Stafford

a good use for a skew chisel! :b :b :b :b

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#14

BarbS

Re: john, you are priceless!

BarbS

Boy, isn't he though? I'm going to remember this for when I need it. Thanks for the photo, John.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#15

Walt Bennett

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Walt Bennett

I kind of prefer the opening cans use though!

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#16

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Lan Brady

Hi Keith,

Here is a solution I used on our club lathe. Coincidentally, happens to be a Delta as well.

Measure the diameter of your tailstock hole. I bet your generic knockout bar is much smaller.

Go to Lowes and buy a round piece of steel that is larger than the knockout bar but will still fit the tailstock hole. It will probably be big enough to knock out the live center.

I turned handles and made 2 new knockout bars for our club.

Good Luck and Glad you are turning again, Lan

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#17

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Jim Breeden

Had that happen to me numerous times with a Jet mini. The only way I could get it out was to disassemble the tail stock. :b

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#18

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Don Orr

I pried the bearings right off the tapered shat doing that once. It was REALLY stuck!

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#19

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Keith,

Lots of good ideas for you to try. But the real sin it this piece of crap live center that both Jet and Delta ship with their lathes.

The day I got my Jet mini I took one look at the live center and dropped it in the junk drawer. They should be ashamed to send it out with these lathes.

Since Jet had already ripped off the Oneway center, the least they could do in include one on ALL their lathes.

But, I you need a replacement for the one you have, I will gladly send it out to you as a Christmas gift.

Hope all is well,

Dave

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#20

Mike Stafford

What causes this?

Mike Stafford

I am unsure what causes this problem. Are the tapers of the live center and tailstock dissimilar or what?

The only time I have ever had a live center stuck was during a demo on an older 3520 and the club was able to retrieve the center. I finished the demo with the original center that came with the old lathe.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#21

Alan Zenreich

Re: What causes this?

Alan Zenreich

Actually, I'm not sure there is a problem.

If his only approach has been to use the knockout bar to remove the live center... well, this is not the way to do it. This particular center has a hollow taper, and using the knockout bar will go right through the core and eject the tip of the center.

Considering that he's using the originally supplied Delta center, we can be reasonably certain that the taper is long enough to be ejected properly.

The correct way to do it (without damaging the center) is to retract the quill, and let it self eject.

If, and only if that approach fails should any other methods be attempted.

Maybe he tried that (but didn't mention it)... maybe he started with the knockout bar.

So, we'll have to wait for an update from Keith.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#22

Re: What causes this?

John Lucas

Mike the problem with the Delta 46-460 and it's live center is that the live center is hollow so the knock out bar does not work. It is supposed to come out when you crank the tailstock back, and mine always does.

I actually like this center for the mini lathe. It's short so you can turn longer stuff between centers. They have been making this same drive center for a long time. I had one on my first new Delta 46-700 that I bought about 20 years ago.

Granted there are definitely better centers out there but I think this thing is about $35 or something like that and it's not bad for than kind of money.

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#23

BarbS

Re: What causes this? *LINK*

BarbS

I don't know if this is Keith's problem, but I've found it helps on my Jet mini-lathe to 'ream out' the MT with a green rubber 'reamer' I bought from Packard Woodworks. It is conical in shape and spiraled to run on the inside. Only once in a while does it come out a little gummy on the edges, and I've never had filings on it, thank goodness, but I notice it Does clean Something out of there. I use it on both headstock and tailstock, about once a week, and have no problems ejecting things.


Taper Mate

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#24

Live Center on Jet Mini

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Dave,

Just curious about what were the problems with the live center on your Jet Mini? I have had a Jet mini for 10 years and really gotten some use out of it and my live center has never missed a beat. Spins great, pops in and out, etc. Maybe I got the good one they produced that day? My turning is only about 30% spindle work, so I don't use it that much, but it has been a good tool. Again, just curious what issues you saw with yours? Maybe something I could look at on mine and try to be proactive about fixing.

I hope all is well in Ohio!

Mike

Spinning and spinning in Apex, NC

Re: Stuck live center in my tailstock

#25

Mike Stafford

Re: Live Center on Jet Mini

Mike Stafford

I have a Jet mini also and have never experienced a problem. That is why I was so curious about the live center getting stuck.

I routinely clean the Morse tapers on my lathes with the reamer.