I have borrowed an Arbortec 4" cutter and I own a Lancelot. I'm trying to figure out how to do a test to see if the Arbortec is safer than the Lancelot. Do you have any ideas how to do this without getting my self killed.
The first thing I'm going to do of course is just carve with each and see if I can feel the difference. after that I want to purposely make it grab and kick back but of course I want to do this without getting hurt.
I'm thinking I might mount the grinder on an arm and then swivel the wood into the cutting. It will then grab and take off so I need an inexpensive way to figure out if one has much more force than another one. Of course I have to do this on an extreme budget so things like buying a force gauge or some such device is out of the question.
I will also be grinding sideways with the Arbortec, Lancelot, Kutzall fine disc and a grinding disc to see what the differences are.
I won't have time to do any of this until the Christmas holidays I don't expect. We get really busy this time of year.
You could try mounting the tool on a flexible arm with a constant amount of resistance. Then measure the deflection as you swivel the wood into it. I would think you would want the wood to be on a rigid arm that swivels at a constant rate.
John, I have used both. And I use the Arbortech now. And you can imagine I do a lot of shaping/carving on my figurative torsos. You will know immediately when you start to test, there is a huge difference. I would not capture either one of these tools in a test mode. You need the wood scrap you are carving on clamped down and you want both hands on the angle grinder. The tests you describe could send the angle grinder and/or the wood flying accross the shop at 100 miles an hour. Do not get an intentional kick back. No plastic shield will keep you safe.
The learning curve to using the Arbortech is dangerous and scarey. It should not be used like a chain saw plunging straight into the wood at a 90 degree angle. Once you get the hang of it you realize the cutting action must be with the rotation of the blade on an angle to the wood. With the Arbortech this carving position will make it easy and controlable to take heavy or light passes. Control is a huge element here. The arbortec gives you much more control. I would not let any of my students start with a Lancelot. It is way too aggressive. Even if you stay away from a kickback it is very hard to handle compared to the Arbortech. Keep the angle grinder guard on between where your hand is and the spinnind blade. An agressive grab can jerk the grinder out of your hand and violently climb up your arm in a heartbeat. Besides the recent accident where the guy almost cut his head off, I have seen two other people with significant scars from a lancelot.
Thanks for the input Lyle. I've been using the Lancelot for years and will find it really interesting using the Arbortec to learn the differences. I know a plunge cut is the worst case scenario for either of them. I learned that on the first day with the Lancelot.
What I did to control it was rotate the hand guard around to the bottom so the guard becomes a bevel. I can set the guard on the wood and then rotate the too into the wood which controls the depth of cut. It's very user friendly this way.
I will let you know what I learn from this test. I won't try anything unless I know I am totally out of harms way. If I can't come up with a safe method I simply won't do it. To old to hurt myself now.
I agree with Lyle here. Don't play stupid John...we don't need another statistic. Kickback is bad be it on a Lancelot or an Arbortec or a chain saw or a table saw, etc. The emphasis should be on how to avoid it...not determining which one kicks back easier or with more force.
Carole What I'm trying to do is learn more about the tools so I can better answer questions about the use and control of these tools. I've done enough cutting with both the Lancelot, various other cutters on the angle grinder and lots of work with the chainsaw, even the nose. I think I'm skilled enough to be able to test the tools and if I decide to go for a really nasty catch test I can guarantee that I'll be standing far enough away to not get hurt.
I agree this comparison should be done with the tools held mechanically and not necessarily by using in-hand tests. Objective measurements of kickback distances (or forces) under controlled conditions might get at the relative merits and problems of either of the tools. The ideas already suggested about constant tension, swing arms, and means of measuring energy or spatial displacement would be good starting points in designing an objective test to compare these two tools.
Above all, safety comes first. We don't want you, or any part of you to be damaged or lost with this endeavor. You are too valuable a person to all of us John! We'd feel terrible if we found out that this test caused injury or worse!
Like the police sergeant used to say on Hill Street Blues ......
The guy that said "let's be careful out there" attended a demo I did at the Woodworking Show in SoCal one time. He hand held a lamp for me at some point.
I wouldn't worry about John. He's smarter than he lets on.
Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryv54aV+RmMmGf6euZ
Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryv54aV+RmMmGf6euZ
Guest
measuring kickback
Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryv54aV+RmMmGf6euZ
I'm thinking that if you have a pivot, on a device holding the grinder, you could let the grinder kick back into a rig that is like the carnival strong man contest. A pivot, a weight on a pipe, measure which one throws the weight the highest. You can add more weight to calibrate to the force. Done right, you won't have to be within 50 feet of the thing. Ropes could pull the wood into a spinning cutter.
Dick I was thinking along those lines. Either a weight hanging from the grinder bar lever and see how for the lever goes up, or just lay a weight on top and see how far the grinder throws it.
One of the reasons I want to do this is to graphically show how serious a kickback is on these machines. My friend Brad Sells had an air grinder get away from him one day. He said it went almost 10 feet in the air. An Angle grinder with a serious cutter is a dangerous machine and deserves a whole lot of respect.
I had an 8" angle grinder with an abrasive wheel on it get away from me one day. It caught the tip of the wheel on an edge and jerked the grinder right out of my hand and I had a pretty firm grip on the tool with both hands. I had to jump back and try and disconnect the cord. Apparently when it spun around and hit the ground the switch on top kicked itself off. Otherwise it probably would have chased me around the yard.
We just started watching the series Murdoch Mysteries. He used a fresh killed pig to determine the blood splatter of a gunshot. This experiment sounds like there could be some splatter involved if there is any kind of error and no way to do a trial test.
Like lyle I have used both tools. After a year of so of use for the Lancelot and lots of "runs" with the tool, I tried the Arbotec and after a few minutes, picked up the Lancelot and threw it away.
The garbage bin is the right place for the lancelot tool. Especially for any work that is somewhat detailed. There will always be a moment where your death grip on the Lancelot will loosen and you will have a nice, choppy slice on the uphill side of your work.
Yes, the Arbortek will run somewhat but comparing the two is, from my perspective, a waste of time. The almost flat angle of the teeth is what makes the big difference. It only takes an instant to feel the major difference as you cut and handle the tool.
I always listen to your advice on tools and admire your skill with them all, but I had rather see you make some more neat mirrors than fiddle around with a test that only takes an instant to feel the advantage and safety of the Arbortek.
I too Ralph agree it is a waste of tome and energy to do such a test. The kickback will hurt you no matter which tool you use. That is not a good indicator of the safety of usefullness of them. Use it in real life carving and you will not have to do any more testing. The differences are huge.
I will make a video if I do it. I'm thinking about getting my son involved. He's a myth busters fanatic and I think would really enjoy it. I think the hands on cutting will prove more than the test but the test will be a fun project for the two of us and making a video might show how dangerous these tools can be if not handled properly.
It will be a few weeks before I have time. The last weeks before graduation are really hectic around my office. After that is slows down until the first of the year but of course by then I'm behind on Christmas presents so it might be between Christmas and new years before I get time to do it.
I make steel gates and use angle grinders a lot. The big 9" grinder is used with a 2mm cutoff blade only. I have six more 100mm and 125mm grinders setup with sandpaper flapper discs and abrasive net type discs. For production it's cheaper to have a grinder per grit setup (the only time I've beaten Terry Scott on the Most Tools competition). I have purposely bought the 9" without a "lock on" button so that the power is cut if I let go of the handle for any reason (it also features soft start that eliminated the "kick" when starting). I have a dedicated 5" grinder with a 1mm cutoff and that also doesn't lock on. This forces you to hold the grinder with two hands and minimizes the chance of mishaps. I have never had a disc explode on me, this might be because I use very thin discs and don't try to grind sidewise with them. I agree on the dangers of the Lancelot, but can see where John is going with the test. Cheers Ian