Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

No Plan, No Cigar

Posts

No Plan, No Cigar

#1

No Plan, No Cigar

mjonesrdg

With a well thought out plan, I may have been able to avoid some of the self- critiqued boo-boos that I have with this piece. I'll point out two then ask for yours. (1) The tippity-top of the finial could have been much longer and not so stubby looking. (2) The element two thirds up on the stem is redundant and not even well executed. I think the stem would be improved as a long, slender, uninterrupted curve to the bulb.

Then, there is a pretty major construction error that you can see if you try. I'll welcome all comments and criticisms. (Besides the obvious photographic ones)

It's maple and cocobolo, about 11" H x 3 1/2" W, buffed with wax wheel.


Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#2

Ellis Walentine

Nice concept, nice execution

Ellis Walentine

I see what you mean about the top finial. I don't know about longer, but thinner would look better to me. I can't spot the construction error, though.

Nice wood combo.

Ellis

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#3

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

Stan Mac

Nice piece. Is it leaning?

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#4

Re: No Plan, No Cigar/good eye Stan Mac

mjonesrdg

It's out of plumb. The tip of the finial is about 3/16" off of the center line. Lack of planning led to the requirement of finishing the bottom of the cup with a jamb chuck which I jambed against the inside bottom, which was not flat, but rounded.

The error was not apparent until it was all glued up.

I'll do better with the next one.

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#5

Re: No Plan, No Cigar *LINK*

John Lucas

beautiful. It's a well done piece. I don't totally agree with the bottom spindle. I do think the placement of the detail was off but if it was left smooth all the way up I think it would be too plain. It's sort of like this spindles elements are divided into 3rds. I think that's too even. I think if you moved the top element up nearer the bowl it would help your eye flow up and not get bored at the same time.

The top finial is just too thick. Nice shape just needs to be thinner. I would agree with the very top detail.

I finish 90 percent of the bottom of my goblets while it's still between centers. I use the toe of my skew. If I release some of the tension on the tailstock I can get it down to where the tenon that has to be carved away less than 1/8". That solves the tilted goblet problem. My video on skew practice shows a good technique for practicing this.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZVlhr9fLCM

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#6

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

david

Nice piece. Besides what others have commented on, I think the piece would have benefited from applying the rule of thirds (body of goblet to stem) and for the bottom bulge to spring from a coved element like the start of the finial. Just my two cents worth...

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#7

Joe Fleming

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

Joe Fleming

John, I did a skew video too, but it was only about 15 seconds long. Really, how many angles can you show when opening a paint can? :-) Joe

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#8

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

Bob Verne

I like it. Nicely done in many ways.

I agree that the top finial is too thick, both the bulb and the thin part. I think that the stem would be improved by removing one of the two features, probably the larger of the two. Test this by putting your finger over one of them. Breaking the stem into three more-or-less equal sections seems too regular to my eye.

My 2 cents.

Bob

Re: No Plan, No Cigar

#9

Re: LINK

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

John,

Thank you so much for posting that LINK. I've been practicing my skew work on junk wood similar to what you have shown. I like how you pointed out (literlly) using more of the point and not getting the mid part of the cutting edge on the work piece. One of my biggest problems is knowing how to hold the skew when approaching the work piece for a cut. I almost always "catch". Very well shown in your top view.

Thanks again,

Ray