Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

unsaleables?

Posts

unsaleables?

#1

unsaleables?

John Lucas

I did a small scale local show this weekend. I did alright on sales. Better than most of the other artists but I have had some interesting results. The two pieces pictured below have been in several shows in the last 2 years and have never sold.

This last weekend I watched them. About 80 percent of the people who came into my booth either looked at or picked up the Walnut piece. I had forgotten to put a price on it but not one single person asked. I had lots of good comments on the piece. Some even looked at it for along time and asked about the piercing. I was amazed it never sold. This is the only show I've done where I was actually there with the work and got to see this.

The other maple box was about the same. It had fewer comments but about half or more of the people who came in picked it up and took the lid off. It did have a price of $40 which I thought was too high for this area but did it anyway. Obviously it was too high.

Do you have any opinions on this.


Re: unsaleables?

#2

Re: unsaleables?

robert

It is the same old story,,OH ,you do nice work,but don't buy. I think you price is ok

Re: unsaleables?

#3

Jerry Louden

Re: unsaleables?

Jerry Louden

John, if you try to drink out of the walnut cup, all the liquid will run out and down the front of your shirt! :D

Re: unsaleables?

#4

Re: unsaleables?

Jim Swank

On the walnut dribble glass, they either didn't know what to do with it or were afraid it would break. Probably didn't know what they'd do with the maple box either. Invent a use or story for each, and label them accordingly. Sewing needle box and dribble glass might just inspire someone to adopt them.

Re: unsaleables?

#5

Who is your target?

Jorge

If you are trying to sell to other turners or collectors, the pierced thin walled dust collector, may go, but most folks like something not so refined, aesthetically pleasing yes, buy useful for something not so frail.

I gave up making small containers because people just have no use for them, the one exemption, containers for prophylactics...

Re: unsaleables?

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: unsaleables?

harry robinette

Jim some places I've been I noticed that super shiny stuff sold, then the next place only matte or semi stuff sold you just never know.

Just my $.02

Re: unsaleables?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Who did you make them for?

steven antonucci

When I make stuff that I think I can sell, I try to envision the person who would be interested in it and how to get the thing in front of them. If you were at a local show, odds are that the pierced piece wouldn't find it's mate. The box is nice, but I think it suffers an identity crisis. What do you do with it?

My answer is that I bring some things to show that I know won't sell, perhaps because of price, or whatever reason, but they might attract a crowd. I might use a really large piece with a crazy price on it to make some of the smaller stuff seem more like a bargin.

If I can, I also put names on some things so that people know what they are. A bowl is just a bowl. I make salad bowls, popcorn bowls, nut bowl, but very few "just a bowls". Can you eat a salad out of a popcorn bowl? Sure...if you buy it, you can eat whatever you want. Sometimes, people need to be lead down the path...

Steve

P.S. One last trick... put a Not for Sale sign on it next time and see if someone asks why. People want what they cannot have.

Re: unsaleables?

#8

Sorry that you have to keep

Mike from St. Clair Shores

packing that stuff up all the time. If you need to just rid yourself of these unsellables, just send them to me and I'll reimburse you for the shipping cost. This is a case of out of sight, out of mind. Oh yeh, please be sure to sign the bottoms. :)

Mike

Re: unsaleables?

#9

Re: unsaleables?

Randy Gleckler

Stability would be my guess. Both are awesome and things I would be attracted to, but knowing people who I've talked to, Stability is probably your answer. The box... if they were to use it as a box has a round top and bottom from the picture that looks like it would be easily knocked over. Lid pops off and SWMBO's earrings are all over the floor. Same with the Vase, right audience would buy it for the collector piece it is. Most would buy it to do something with it. That doesn't look like with dried flowers or any sort of other design element to it, that it would hold it standing up, and the delicate nature of the piercing... yep, Guessing stability.

Re: unsaleables?

#10

Re: unsaleables?

Vince

Hi John,

You said...

"The other maple box was about the same. It had fewer comments but about half or more of the people who came in picked it up and took the lid off. It did have a price of $40 which I thought was too high for this area but did it anyway. Obviously it was too high"

I do not think the box is priced wrong at $40.00 at all. I truly cannot call it when it comes to people and what they might want. What I think is nice will be the last piece to sell. I also think it is common that if a piece does not sell we question the pricing of the item.

I remember talking to a well-known turner about boxes as he make loads of them and has for years. Somehow I asked about making smaller boxes if your material was limited to begin with. He smiles big and said to me “Vince... the smaller the piece the bigger the price!!! Now you've got it!!!" LOL! The value of a piece is often "ones perceived value". Mark down 20% or up 20% if you want it will sell when the right person sees it and not one person before. LOL It is a Very nice box!

Vince

Re: unsaleables?

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: unsaleables?

Jesper, Denmark

I think the two have one feature in common: People would not know what to use them for?

The pierced piece appears too fragile and unstable, and the box looks like one of those Russian boxes with more smaller boxes inside. When people open it and do not find the smaller boxes inside, they are disappointed.

The pierced pie also does not look like it has tactile appeal. It doesn't feel good when you pick it up and fondle it.

From a purely commercial standpoint, the amount of time and work involved in the piercing is not going to be valued.

Re: unsaleables?

#12

jim miles

Re: unsaleables?

jim miles

John- If it is a local show I would assume it is not really an art show.

My experience is people at those kinds of shows want to know "what do you do with it?" Functoinal - They have trouble accepting buying ART to sit on the mantle and enjoy looking at - like a painting. In ten years of doing shows I often have a piece that I do not like, almost don't take to the show- and it is the first thing to sell ! Don't know why? Another old strategy: if it dosen't sell- mark the price UP and see what happens.

I also if someone is "considering" a piece

will make the comment "I can make you a deal on that one" their response tends to get to the bottom of if they are really interested or not.

Re: unsaleables?

#13

jim miles

Re: Who is your target?

jim miles

OK - I gotta ask- can you post a pic of a Prophylactic container-

I thought I had heard it all, but not that one

I can think of some interesting marketing ideas !!!

Re: unsaleables?

#14

Re: unsaleables?

John Scheideman

Hi John--

Don't feel bad. You are lucky that anything is selling in this economy! I don't know what drives people either. I have pieces that I think will sell immediately and don't and then other pieces that I don't think will sell very well and they go right away. Who knows? I had three really nice pieces that sat in a gallery for a little over a year and I wondered why they were not selling. A month ago a lady came in and bought all three of them. It is just a matter of finding the right buyer at the right time I guess! As long as the quality is good, which I'm sure your pieces are, they will probably find a home sooner or later.

John

Re: unsaleables?

#15

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: unsaleables?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

I like many around the world are often asked "What would you use it for"?

May I suggest that you find something of interest to go into each item that neither overpowers the pieces nor gives the impression that it is purely for display?

Perhaps all that the potential purchaser needs is a stimulus to thinking that the pieces would look nice in their home or as a gift.

As for your price, I do not think that has much bearing on these items, they will be purchased and loved whatever your price.

3P'ers are the same the world over (Pick up, Put down, Piss off!) it is just a case of thinking outside the box and I KNOW that I am trying to teach my grandmother to suck eggs! LOL

Regards Peter.

Re: unsaleables?

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: unsaleables?

Mike Stafford

John, there is no rhyme or reason why things don't sale particularly when they are of the quality of your items. The right person just didn't show up.

However the last couple of years have been very tough in the craft market. I don't have a photo booth large enough to hold the items I have not sold. :(

The recession sinks all ships........

Re: unsaleables?

#17

Re: unsaleables?

John Lucas

Fun responses. To cover some of the questions. I had 16 boxes set out. I sold one Cupcake box. Although people seemed to appreciate them they either didn't know what to do with them or didn't like the price.

I often hear, if it doesn't sell raise the price. Doesn't work around here. We tried in one local gallery. I had been selling mirrors for $35 and $45. I made some very exotic ones and we priced them from$45 to $85. I sell 10 to one of the $35 over the higher priced ones. I also hear, if you sold these at the art shows they would sell for $125. Tried that in a nationally know show. Sold over a dozen $35 mirrors and one $75. None of the higher priced ones went.

This was an Art show, called the Art Prowl. It was advertised in about a 35 mile radius and most people seemed to come to see the art. However see it seems to be what it was about because not very much sold. I'll know more after tonight because we are having a follow up meeting and I'll get to hear what others did or didn't sell.

Most people who purchased items walked up, looked at the display, picked out one or maybe two and then bought one. I really felt like the people who picked up these two pieces wanted them. They either didn't know what to do with them or didn't think they could afford them. I've been there. Wait a minute, I still am there.

Re: unsaleables?

#18

Re: Who is your target?

John Lucas

Mine would have to be larger than these containers. :)

Re: unsaleables?

#19

Re: unsaleables?

John Lucas

Randy I don't think stability was a problem. I sold 6 vessels with very small bases. If you filled them with something they would have to be balanced. The people who purchased them didn't even ask that question.

I ask that question when making the pieces and sometimes put bases that are too large because I'm worried about balance.

Re: unsaleables?

#20

Re: unsaleables?

Dale Bonertz

John,

Allow me to be brutally honest. I have seen your work on forums and it is exceptional. I think the bowl suffers from what to do with it. It is thin and the piercing makes it more art than function. However from an art perspective it looks more of a functional piece trying to be art. In other words I like the piercing but if I had it in my collection I would lose interest in it do to not being artsy enough but it has no other useful function. The box I kept going back to and asking myself why is it not selling. I love the spalting and that is where my eye takes me but I am a wood guy. In the eyes of a buyer they pick it up because of the wood but the form looks like a pill. I believe the box suffers from the form and the negative connotations with the shape (pill, suppository or etc.).

As far as shows go I'll speak for myself. I see the advertising for art show or craft show or even art and craft show. I go to them not intending to buy anything but rather get ideas. I think that a lot of these shows draw artists and crafters who just come for ideas especially in down economies. This is speculation on my part but I have seen a lot of people look at things in a booth and when they walk to the next one are talking about how they are going to make this or that. Or they attend to stay in touch with trends.

I hope you don't take offense in my appraisal on your two pieces. I am just expressing my opinion on what would keep me from buying them.

Re: unsaleables?

#21

Re: unsaleables?

john lucas

Dale I think your dead on about the Walnut piece. It just can't decide what it wants to be. I know David Ellsworth has some pieces that are similar in shape to my box. apparently people buy his "medicine". :)

Re: unsaleables?

#22

Re: unsaleables?

Fred Bearman

I look at your pierced walnut piece and I have several thoughts:

1) I would love to have that piece

2) The wood and the piercing, as well as the shape are beautiful

3) If you get tired of packing it up and dusting it, I would be happy to bid on it in the benefit auction here on WC - and I would be thrilled to win it.

I hesitated to suggest the last one, as it seems that you give a lot of yourself on a regular basis, as do a number of the others on here. But the self-centered part of me got the best of me.

Fred

Port Huron,Michigan

Re: unsaleables?

#23

Re: unsaleables?

Richard Jones

John,

Since Randy broached the F-word (flowers), I'll share this with you.

I made an elm HF a month or so ago, and as usual, I brought it to the office to get reviews...............so so was the response. When I returned with it a couple of weeks later, after asking my florist wife to add a couple of bucks worth of silk flowers to it, I sold it to a lady up the hall within 5 minutes of setting it on the counter. She had seen it earlier and hadn't even offered a comment............I guess it now had "A Use" and her mom loved it. Everybody happy.

Also, as you said, stuff that will sell in one locale won't even get looked at in another.

Rich

Re: unsaleables?

#24

My Experience Is.......

Dick Wilson

John,

I do 8-10 outdoor art shows a year. In the past year something interesting happened. I sold enough of my new work that it left empty space in my booth. In order to fill the void I brought out pieces that I did several years ago ( these pieces were in any number of shows ). People were buying them. Go figure!!!!

If I had a dollar for every time people came into the booth, looked at every piece, and made the comment "you do beautiful work", then walked out of the booth empty handed I would be a millionaire. There is no rhime or reason why something sells and others don't. You will drive yourself nuts trying to figure it out. All it takes is one person to walk into your booth and the pierced piece and the box are GONE.

The price on your box seems low to me. IMHO it is worth more than that. Don't know what you were asking for the pierced vase, but a high price is warranted. It is beautiful. Sometimes higher prices work.

Re: unsaleables?

#25

Re: unsaleables?

Dale Bonertz

John,

It is interesting that you bring up David's homage and spirit forms that are similar to your box in form. I had to work that out in my mind (his book still on my desk) before responding the first time. I concluded, in my mind, that your box is more formal than his pieces. What I mean by formal is your box needs to be dry for a good lid fit thus holding a more uniform or permanent shape. David turns his wet, thus they warp and undulate becoming more organic as it were. If you notice he tends to roll in the lip for the hollowing entrance hole which breaks the smoothness across the top (the hole itself accomplishes this to some degree). These subtle differences in my mind is why his pieces seem to work and maybe why the box does not. I say maybe why the box does not only because that is my opinion which is worth around 1/2 cent. I guess you should look at it like this. You have two pieces that don't work out of how many hundred that you have made. I think that is a pretty good percentage, one that we all would like to have. If they don't sell in the next show I am sure you have family members that would cherish them as a gift.

I am going to ask for your critique of my critique. I am trying to learn how to articulate my feelings, emotion and responses toward pieces beyond the "I like it" or "I don't like it". Did you understand what I was saying? Did what I said help in anyway? Did anything I said upset you in anyway and if so what was it and why? If you don't mind taking a minute to critique me I would be most grateful. I don't want to high jack your thread but if anyone else wants to critique my critique please start a new thread - it would be greatly appreciated.