Well it looks like the Christmas gift project for this year will be pepper grinders. I think I'm getting an early enough start to possibly avoid the last minute all nighter. Hope springs eternal.
Which brings me to my quandary. I haven't ever made one before and don't know who makes the best kits. I want to buy the good ones that will last without resorting to titanium or carbon fiber. That said I'm not looking to produce these for sale so I'm not setting up for production. Just a dozen or so.
Any recommendations for suppliers would be much appreciated.
I have had good luck using the 'Deluxe" pepper mill kit from Craft Supplies.
I don't make huge numbers of mills, but the recommendation by Nick Cook (who does) when he did his demo here was enough to convince me that this is a well-made mechanism. There are instructions for using this mill on the Craft Supplies web site (below) which can be downloaded to see them before ordering if you like. Other guys in our club have also had good results with the crush grind kits too. I prefer the type that you need to screw into the blank rather than those that just snap-in. Some turners epoxy the crush-grind mechanism in for better holding power. Instructions for these kits are also available on-line.
Peppermills are fairly easy with the turning part, but can be a 'bit' finicky with the drilling part (pun intended!) - for the deluxe kits you'll need bits for 1-1/16" and 1-5/8", plus a bit extender to match the size of the mills you'll be making (I do mostly 8" and 10"). Having good Forstner bits makes the job a lot easier and the outcome better. I took the plunge and went ahead and bought the top-o-the-line Maxi-Cut bits (See: http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Shop___Safety___Drill_Bits___Maxi_Cut_Forstner_Bit___maxi_cut?Args= ) and don't regret doing so. They are fantastic!
If you can get some advice from or watch a peppermill turner, do so, or surf youtube for possible on-line videos. I understand there is a DVD video available on turning peppermills, but I have never watched it.
I have used the Deluxe metal grinder works from Craft supplies, Woodcraft, Rockler, Penn State Industries, and Packard Woodworks. I believe these are all the same parts just packaged by each of these vendors.
These all work well and it is easy to cut down the metal shaft and "peen over" the end to make a mill of any length shorter than the kit you buy.
I am just starting to use the CrushGrind works and recommend using the shafted version which allows you to make a 2 part mill versus the 3 part mill needed with the Crushgrind wood design (no shaft)
Making mills with the CrushGrind works is slightly more difficult die to the milling required to accept the grinder works and head unit.
I recommend using top quality hardwood (cherry, maple, hickory) since mills take a lot of abuse.
I first used the "Deluxe" (older, more traditional type) kits that I think I bought from Packard. No significant problems except I find it a bit annoying that the adjustment nut has a tendency to back off in use.
The second batch I made were Crush Grind. I think the ceramic grinder actually grinds the pepper (or salt) a bit better, but I have had considerable problem with the attachment of the mechanisms to the wood. I glued the pieces in with epoxy, but several have come loose in use.
If I make any more I will switch back to the Deluxe.
I second the recommendation for the Deluxe Mill kits. I have used the Artisan mills, and found they did not assemble as well. I also endorse the Maxi-cut Colt forstner bits. They really cut well, cut straighter, expel chips better and produce less heat. I'd also get the #2 morse taper extension with the twist-lock, and you will have no slipping set screws. Expensive, but worth the investment if you will be making a few mills.
I am late for this post and have not read the others but if you decide to go with the crush grind, those work very nicely, specially the long ones, Beal gave me an excellent service and the best price I found.
Thanks for that link, Jorge. Decent price for the Crush Grind mechanisms but I was especially attracted to the tool for making threaded jam chucks that are needed for turning the mills. I'll be ordering one of those. I watched Beall's videos on that and was immediately sold.
I went through about three of the ceramic crush grind mechanisms last year. I never could get one to work right. Very frustrating! I won't use them any more.
For the Crush Grind works it is best to use metric forstners for the key holes where the assembly slides in... the position of the notch is critical ... I ground a cheap chinese tool into my notch making tool instead of buying the sorby one. If you use the non-shafted "wood" works.. I cut a key into the top joint where the cap fits on... w/o a key the joint will eventually slip...
Biottom line ... the Crush grind works require more time than the Deluxe grinder mechanism... I have not had a finished one long enough to determine if the grinder is actually better