A quick shot of a few finials I turned this weekend during my class "The art of the Finial". I just stuck them in holes bored in a piece of scrap maple, the tallest is about 4". (I'll take better shots later) Woods are redheart, black and white ebony, rosewood. They are intended to be "studies" of how small changes can make a big difference in appearance. If you had a favorite, which one would it be?
There are only two which I am not fond of...the first and the fourth (from the left). I can't put it into words but it has something to do with diameter. Something is too wide or too narrow.
I like the finial on the right except for the top. I like the 3rd from the left for the top. I like the expanded area just before the tip but think it's too large on the one on the right.
I like doing multiples like this. It really lets you fine tune the shapes.
Keith, I would like the far right with the element below the tip replaced with the one on the third from the right. As shown I prefer the third from the right.
I also think that it looks more stable. They all look great, but I would be concerned that on some the possibility of breaking off at the bottom of the bulb.
Keith - My favorite is the one at the far right. The "onion"* part of the finial to me is more substantial and dynamic and not as elongated or slender-appearing as numbers 1, 3, and 4, for example.
One of the features I like about the rightmost finial is that the top (terminal) element best replicates the major 'onion' element at a smaller scale. I would have turned the supporting element below the tip a bit smaller in diameter and make it a bit sore subtle; this might reduce the strength of this feature so it does not become overbearing on the uppermost element. The "subtending" or supporting elements should not compete with the major elements, but are used to visually offset them and break-up a monolithic form. Maybe this "competition" between elements is what the other comments about the top section are all about?
*BTW - 'onion' is not my term - it is that used by Cindy Drozda to describe that lower bulbous element of this style finial. I have had numerous conversations with her over the past few years in my ongoing quest to turn better finials. Yesterday I dropped off a piece at a gallery that is a finialed hollow form for which I turned at least 7 different finials before I did one I could live with; it had to work on its own, as well as with the form on which it was mounted (a 12" diameter hollow form out of spalted maple). I had this in the Instant Gallery at the AAW Symposium - the piece is named "Cindy's Revenge" for a reason..... I don't have an image of it on this computer, or I'd attach it.....maybe tonight?
I'm still working hard on learning to make more attractive finials; perhaps I'm getting better (I hope), but I'm certainly far from being 'there' yet....
Thanks for the comments everyone! I love turning these things; I consider finials the "epitome" of spindle turning, representing the very best one is capable of. This group is a fairly simple design, consisting of beads, coves, and filets. Avoiding straight lines was a goal in the class; no V-cuts were used ..I don't feel they normally work in this type of finial. The simplicity of the form allows one to really focus on each element within the finial...notice nobody picked #4. I intentionally elongated the cove at the base, and elongated the base of the "onion", rather than tuck it in as I did in the others. Not much visual appeal. My favorite is #6, in person, it really stands out from the others. The flare under the very tip really highlights the small teardrop, however, as Rob pointed out, pulls the eye away from the more prominent bulge. Toning down the flare just a bit will make this one a real standout. By turning a series, one can learn the limit that each element can be taken before it detracts, rather than adds to the overall form. Note the assemetrical coves, which add a sense of "lift" to the onion forms they support, also the contrast between the largest and smallest diameters add a bit of drama. The idea behind the exercise was to show the effect of even the smallest change has on the appearance, and that simplicity and good proportion, not adding more elements, is most often the key to a successful piece. David, although they appear fragile, they're actually pretty stout..it takes some effort to break one. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
HI Philip, If you compare #2 and 6, you will see #2 has an almost straight-up area supporting the very tip, and more mass under the large bulb, while #6 has more flair at the tip, and less mass under the large bulb. Slight differences, but they do affect the results.