I meant to do this after writing my article in Vol 25 no 2 of American Woodturner. The idea was to write an article and then have a video to sort of back it up. It took a while to get the computer, software and skills to do it. I'm slowly getting there. Hope you get something from this. I did have a slight cold which unfortunately comes through on my new mike. Oh well, can't be perfect.
Looks like I have more practice to do. Never tried a scraper for a cove!
I found myself holding my breath when you did the deep cove with the skew. Now if I watch the skew tip I know I will catch up higher on the skew for sure!
I have been trying to use my skew more from watching your video on the skew.
Turned eight acorn bird houses and probably wasted more wood just using the skew to peel off cuts for practice.
That was very informative, John. I like your teaching style - clear and straight forward.
A little criticism if I may. I know you are a fast talker, but for videos, if you could slow your speech some, it would help. I liked the list of tools used at the end, but please slow down the scroll. I'm getting old. I can't read that fast.
Very well done. By coincidence, I just re-watched the section on turning coves in Alan Lacer's Projects Along The Woodturning Trail. Your self-produced video compares very well.
One suggestion: Try a higher camera angle. Your "handle's eye view" camera angle is nice as a change of pace or to give us a different look at things, but it's NOT the angle from which most of us view our work. I think the presentation would be clearer if the primary camera angle used gave us a view that's closer to what we'll see when we're standing at the lathe. (I know that's not entirely possible -- unless you have a camera mounted to your face shield. I just think an above-the-lathe-view would be better.)
Carol I was born a yankee and by the grace of god became a southerner. still talk faster than most of my neighbors. I'll try to remember on the next video. I tried my best to see if I could slow down the scroll, extend time duration, or just put it all on a simple page. I could not figure it out last night. I'm going to play with that today at work if I get time. My boss or one of the other employees may know how to do it. We are all having to learn to do videos. Still photography is dying, at least for University needs.
David It as a close as I could get it. I could not find my side arm for my tripod. I think I left it at work. It is essential if I want the camera right above my head. Of course without having a camera on my glasses you can't get the true viewers angle. You are either higher and straight above which is good for some cuts. Or your off to the left or right. Either way it still becomes a 2D view and it's hard to see the true angle of the gouge. I'm going to see if there is a way to do split screen so for some cuts you can see from the side and the top how the tool moves. In this video because I was so close up you could not see how far the handle moves to get those cuts.
John, I love your instructive videos. They have been a real asset to me and I have learned a lot from them. Thanks for making the efforts to help us all improve our skills.
I am ready to buy a collection of your videos showing all the turning techniques you have done. When will it be available?
John, Thanks for taking the time to make these videos. They are very informative and will be quite an asset to many turners. You have a unique ability because you are a very good turner and photographer. By using these two skills, and making time to share them, I think the quality of future woodturning will improve, benefiting all of us.
I've referred people to look for your YouTube videos, so keep makin'em!
I wouldn't cut a cove with a scraper if I had any other option, but the result you got was better than I would expect. In the beginning, when drawing on the wood and discussing cutting down the grain toward the center, I'd also draw the arrows right inside the cove itself.
Brad I threw that in partly because it was the way I learned and partly because I did a test last year to answer a question on using a scraper with and without a burr and rubbing the bevel of a scraper with and without a burr. Rubbing the bevel of a scraper with the burr polished off left a pretty good finish. However you had to handle it just like you would a fluted spindle gouge and it didn't leave as good of a finish.
I didn't go back and show shear scraping a cove with a scraper. It does work and if it's all you had you could do it. I should do one with the new Hunter Hercules. It cuts clean enough it may actually let me do the 2 coves side by side with a good edge. I'll try that tonight and see.
Your videos have become as good as anything I have seen on the web. I agree, your audio is simple and concise, yet imparting good information without excess. I'm with Mike, when can I purchase the first dvd?
Thanks for a good, understandable video John - you addressed some areas in particular that I have had some problems with. And I like scooping ice cream!
It's wonderful to have a video link in a text and still photos description of a procedure. Of course that assumes that the video is done well. If the video has a voice over describing what's being seen - that's even better. And if the voice over is done by someone who is well prepared - there are no "uh"s at the beginning or throughout a sentence . . .
Your videos have been good and they keep getting even better. The only thing on my WishList would be to have Picture In Picture - the smaller insert would show the whole tool - and what's happening with the handle and your right hand. Of course that would require another video camera, and tripod and . . . Then there's the synching of the two videos . . .
You're creating a terrific resource for new and intermediate turners.
You can tell that you make these videos with an intention of showing someone how to do something, not that you can do it. It's a lot harder to show something while explaining it than it is to just do it, and you do a great job of doing both things.
thanks Steve. I just following what we do in woodturning. Sharing our knowledge.
Keith I may be hard to reach tomorrow we have several sports cover photos to shoot. I'll probably have lunch free and should be free from 4:30 to about 6.
Thanks for posting this. I am self taught, so I have a lot of stuff to unlearn.
To be hyper critical, if I were going to publish this in final form I see three things I would want to change. About a minute in you say "to cut a bead" and then go on to make a cove. Somewhere in there you say to "raise the handle" and later you correct yourself and say you meant "to lower" the handle. I know these are tiny flaws, but you should be able to edit them out easily for your big million seller version and make it even "Perfecter". ("Perfect" is a relative term. When working within earshot of the client we learned not to say "Good Enough". They would object and say they did not want Good Enough, they wanted the best we could do. So it became "Perfect"...being exactly what was necessary for the job at hand. So for a turning "perfect" on a piece headed to a museum or juried show might be different than perfect for a piece of treen.)
I know others have discussed the camera angle but because it is shot from and angle it makes everything look asymmetrical to me. Could you have a second camera with and overhead shot that is straight on? A little inset frame in the picture?
Also, let me tell a story on myself. I took a class from David Elsworth. He said, "turn the flute in the direction you want to go" very much as you did. I did not understand. I thought the direction of the flute was its long horizontal dimension, as if I were pointing across the room with the gouge. What both of you meant was a line vertical to that, from the bottom of the flute straight up. (Am I the only person who ever misunderstood this? Could be, I know I am dyslexic or dis graphic or dis something.) Anyway, orienting the flute as badly as I did made for a very poor experience. Even the two handed death grip did not help. David came over and showed me the error of my ways and it was an epiphany for me. So, it might be good for us ignorant savages to make that a little more clear.
Thanks for the video and all the work. I will watch it again and again. Please don't take offence at my suggestions, I was trying to be constructive, not critical. Its better than most I've bought and paid for.
And one more thing. I like the length. Just right. Long enough, and to the point. My attention span is fairly short and as much as I like turning, some of the longer ones are a sure cure for insomnia.
Thanks Barry. My editing skills suck. I'm working on that. I'm going to look into the window in window sort of thing or possibly split screen but I don't know if I have that capability in my software.
right now I'm just trying to get some informative video's out there to help out. I want to keep them short. I've watched too many where the guy just rambles on about nothing. One I remember he spent the first 5 minutes talking about putting your remote control in a plastic bag. I'm not exagerating about the time. That didn't have anything to do with the topic.
I'm making these 2 fast. I need to do a run through. Then shoot the video. Then edit and watch it carefully, then go back and correct it. right now I have to much trouble editing and if things go wrong and I lose a part and have to start over it's very very frustrating. I think that will go away with time.