Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

It's Easy For The Beginner

Posts

It's Easy For The Beginner

#1

It's Easy For The Beginner

Stuart Johnson

The discussion about the #3 Hunter Hercules got me thinking about a statement that is so often used in one form or another:

This tool is about giving beginners an easy tool to use

Isn't this true for just about every new tool or turning accessory that comes on the market? I doubt if there is going to be a large market for a new tool that is advertised as "hard to master by the pro and impossible for the beginner".

I enjoy turning but also enjoy other activities so I don't spend six or seven hours a day at the lathe. Heck, a great many of you produce more in a week or month than I have in the last ten years. As a result I classify myself as a beginner. I don't pick up a bowl gouge and automatically rough out a bowl with a nice fair curve and even wall thickness. I don't mount the blank and go on automatic instead I have to concentrate on every step: 45-45-45, bevel rubbing, turn the handle, start the cut, oops, dang it, 45-45-45, bevel..... You don't want to think about what I go through when cutting the dovetailed tenon. But, I am enjoying myself and my "skills" are improving but yes bring on more of those "easy for the beginner" tools.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

Steve Kubien

I'd like to see an advertisement that goes something like, "Easy for the beginner but after a few months, once you have some experience, you are toast!"

Seriously Stuart, advertising annoys me to no end. Some of it is ok. The ad I see as I type this reads, "Your Number One Online Source blah blah..." I can live with that, because it says online and is specific to one brand of abrasives. Another manufacturer is really simple and their ads show pictures of their lathes and something along the lines of why their lathes aren't found in catalogues. I like that. When I see things like, "the best XYZ available" I get annoyed because such claims offer no empirical evidence. It's just flash and in my opinion, outright bull.

I would like to see some honesty in advertising. "Pepsi...Sure we copied Coke and we taste the same but we added blue to the colour scheme!" "Ford, built tough but if you get a lemon your are screwed!" "ABC turning tools, really good tools that wont break the bank." "XYZ-stuff-apolooza, great stuff, inflated prices and we cannot tell you why that is."

Somehow I think I'm in dreamland on this....

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#3

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

How many of us have a rack (30+) of tools but really use only ~five of them. The advice that is given to most beginners: "don't buy a set." Is very true, buy them as you need them. Unfortunately, tool makers are much better at marketing hype than they are at inventing something new. That is why 4 out of 5 new GREATEST are getting rusty. The really new and great: Hunters and Thompsons (for example) are very nice. What about the hundreds of $ that I wasted on hype? How about a true, money back guarantee?

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#4

Just To Clarify

Stuart Johnson

In no way was I trying slam Hunter Tools or any other tool maker. Hopefully the Hercules will be shown in the vendor area at SWAT and I will be taking a good look at it. In my mind the object of turning is to take some wood and make something different from it. A hollow form, bowl, pen, platter, art piece it doesn't make any difference as long as you enjoy the process. Any tool that makes that process more enjoyable is a benefit. If in your turning you enjoy mastering a new more difficult tool that tool is a benefit to you. If you enjoy making your own tools that is also a benefit. If stepping up to the lathe is no longer enjoyable then it is work. I'm retired and I don't work anymore.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#5

Steve Kubien

Clear as a bell

Steve Kubien

I, for one, totally understood where you were coming from.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#6

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

GalenVetterick

Stuart

My turning time is much like yours. I chuckle at "tools for beginners" because none that I purchased came with any instructions. Now a beginner might just need some right????

Now I have acess to Youtube videos showing a tool and written opinions in forums. My problem here is the information is both pro and con for the tool and who do I believe???

That said, it is fun trying to figure it out, other than the cost of a tool I never use again! I'm retire and I must have money for my pills too! :o(

At least a lot of the "new tools" are just from metal working so with a background in metal fab I make a few before paying big bucks.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

Lyle Jamieson

Come and see me at SWAT. I will have a lathe set up as a vendor so you can try the Hunter and Jamieson tools before you buy them. And Yes, I have a guaranteed satisfaction policy.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#8

Alan Zenreich

Re: Just To Clarify

Alan Zenreich

There are lots of reasons why people (like me) accumulate tools.

Some of us just enjoy tools (toys), and like to use the "right tool for the job".

Hey, I own a lobster scissor and a truffle mandolin... very dedicated kitchen tools.

In the past 3 years, I've outfitted my home hobbyist wood shop with lots of tools.

Do I need a small lathe dedicated just to bore holes in small blanks (pens, bottlestoppers, etc)? Nope, But one came along at the right price.

Does Lauren need her own lathe? Nope, but I'm sure glad she has hers. She's got her own Breathe Easy respirator, smock, and now... turning tools.

Do I need 4 beading tools? Nope, but the tools from NanoTools and DWay make turning tiny beads a pleasure, and easily consistent.

Do I need a few chucks (scroll, collet, mandrel, vacuum, etc.) and various live and dead centers? Nope, could likely get by with a faceplate and a spur drive.

I have two Panasonic drill drivers, a dremel driver, and a new Festool CSX.

Many of my tools have functionality overlap, but it's rare that I sell one when acquiring another... though I've done on occasion (Craiglist is good for buying and selling.)

I won't mention the various ways I have to sharpen tools, or turn, mill or grind metal...

Maybe I'm unusual in that I actually use pretty much every tool I've ever bought. Could I visit a desert island and only take a small subset of my tools? Certainly, but that wouldn't be much fun, and I'd always miss the specialized tools.

Because I don't create only one or two types of work (bowls for example), I never quite know what I'm going to turn next.

I'm exploring pyrography, carving, piercing, airbrushing, ebonizing, stabilization and casting. All excuses for more toys.

So for some of us, much of the fun in the hobby is building out the shop, acquiring and learning how to use new tools and techniques. Actually producing work from the shop is secondary.

Hey, some people enjoy smoking, drinking, gambling and chasing women.

TAS (Tool Acquisition Syndrome) is less dangerous, less expensive and incurable.

Come to think of it, I haven't tried my hand at welding yet.

Bring on the new tools!

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#9

Steven Antonucci

For me, the process is the important thing...

steven antonucci

not the end result.

I have no doubt that I could probably find a contract manufacturer somewhere that would be able to produce something more easily than I could. Probably even higher quality.

It's not why I turn.

I turn because I enjoy the process. If you are looking to make things easier, that's fine, but I can't understand the mentality that people just expect everything to be easy these days? I value the dedication to the medium to learn how to "get good" moreso than "buy good". If I stop caring about the "how" and only the "what", why even bother turning?

Mike's tools are just like any other tool in the arsenal. They require practice and use to develop proficiency. For some people, the promise of "an easy fix" is too hard to resist. Turning is like golf. If you don't play all that often, you probably aren't going to get very good. The odds are that if you can't use the tools you already own, the next one won't solve that problem for you, no matter whose name is on it.

Steve

P.S. I really like Mike and his tools. Oddly, they work better in my hands than some of the other guys I've shown them too...

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#10

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

john lucas

Stewart I understand you perfectly. This however a tool that anyone can use and yet at the same time, I like using it. It's so darn easy. I have a friend coming over in a week or so to turn a vase. He is a very new turner and is fighting this vase. That's why he wants to come over to get me to help him. I can't wait to put this thing in his hand and watch him smile when the shaving come piling off. I won't have to stand there behind him constantly telling him to ride the bevel or change the flute angle. I'll just let him cut.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#11

Re: Just To Clarify

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Alan, You've just identified my disorder. TAS. Now I can tell people the it's not my fault and that it is incurable. Thank you so much. I'm starting to feel better already.

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: Just To Clarify

Alan Zenreich

Mike,

I never meant to imply that TAS is not your fault.

TAS is totally self inflicted (though it's nice when others enable this by inflicting new tools upon us.)

So, offer it as an explanation to others but it's clearly it's not an excuse.

Oh, and it's generally terminal < vbg >

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#13

Katherine Kowalski

Here!  Here!  I love new tools... 

Katherine Kowalski

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#14

Alan Zenreich

Re: For me, the process is the important thing...

Alan Zenreich

"I can't understand the mentality that people just expect everything to be easy these days?"

So, Steve's new motto: "I like it hard"

< ducking/ >

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#15

Bill Blasic

Re: Just To Clarify

Bill Blasic

Alan,

Well said! I agree:D

Bill

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#16

Steven Antonucci

It's a hardknock life for me...

steven antonucci

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#17

Alan Zenreich

Re: It's a hardknock life for me...

Alan Zenreich

Well said, Steve 'Annie'-nucci

Re: It's Easy For The Beginner

#18

We are all beginners

Ruth Niles

Stuart, I agree with what you are saying the advertising of a tool being great for "beginners". My first thought was, hmmm, wonder if they have beginner chopping knives for people who don't cook much? Or beginner cars?

We are all beginners and every tool is for beginners. I've been turning over 21 years, I just started doing hollow forms and I am a beginner at this particular technique.