Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

monster help

Posts

monster help

#1

monster help

Steve Criscenzo

About a year ago I purchased a monster hollowing system. I have not had much time to play with it until now. I am having occasional problems with the tool vibrating and/or bouncing. I am using the square cutter in the angled holder, set at the center line. The tool is sharp and speed does not seem to make a difference. I will be going along fine and then the tool starts to shake. Has me perplexed. Any thoughts or suggestions.

Steve

Re: monster help

#2

Steven Antonucci

More data needed...

steven antonucci

At center height, but how far over the rest?

Cutting into end grain?

Bar diameter?

Sharp cutter?

Assume everything tight?

All can cause vibration...

S

Re: monster help

#3

Re: More data needed...

Steve Criscenzo

It is the standard monster bar with a quarter inch cutter. I have the tool rest set across the front of the vessel. Extension over the rest is about 5 inches. The vessel is about 6 inches deep and about 8 inches diameter at the widest point. Going in through a 2 inch hole with side (bowl) orientation.

The tool is sharp.

Re: monster help

#4

Re: More data needed...

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I would try a smaller cutter. I have never had really good cutting with any cutter larger than 3/16". Take lighter cuts and keep the bar between your hand and the tool rest. Just some guesses.

Re: monster help

#5

Re: More data needed...

john lucas

You can always grind a cutter with a smaller radius at the front. However just taking light cuts will help. You might also try cutting down hill on the grain rather than straight into the grain if that's the case.

Re: monster help

#6

Steven Antonucci

Agree with smaller cutter...and...

steven antonucci

If you are cutting a face grain vessel through a 2" hole, are you cutting "inside the hole towards the outside" (side grain/endgrain/side grain...)or "from the top of the hole downward" (all face grain...)

I almost never use a cutter larger than 3/16", and sometimes only 1/8". More cutter doesn't mean faster overall, since the chips get bigger and you end up spending more time trying to get them out.

Steve

P.S. I don't own a Monster, so I don't know what a standard bar is? at 5" deep, I'd want 1/2"-5/8" of bar.

Re: monster help

#7

Re: monster help

Doc Green

Steve, I ground the tip of the square cutter to a V shape, where the angle on the V is about 90 degrees. Then advance the cutter in a direction parallel to either side of the V. If you begin to get the shaking, ease up a little and take a lighter cut.

Do not advance the V straight into the wood. If you do, it will soon be taking a large bite, and you will get the shakes. Also, do not advance the V into a corner or a concave area that you may have formed, for the same reason.

The V grind is capable of leaving a rough surface, but this is not a given. For finishing cuts, grind a cutter with a rounded end instead of the point of the V. Then take a very light cut, and you should get a clean surface.

An obvious point: The cutting tip should not extend more than about 3/4" from the axis of the holder. More extension than this causes torque issues to come into play, and this can increase the tendency for it to get the shakes.

Let me know if this is not clear. Good Luck. ~Doc

Re: monster help

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: monster help

Lyle Jamieson

Some great tips so far...and I agree with most. If you want more details go to my web site, lylejamieson.com, in the instruction menu. The article, Practical Hollow Form Tips-Vibration Issues and Control of the Hollowing Process-Woodturning Design-Summer2007 will help fine tune your methods. (Sorry I dont know how to put a link in) One tip is, it is always easier to cut side grain and harder to cut into end grain. To hog off, the easiest path, in a side grain vessel, would be a pass from the mouth opening to the headstock. This is a little difficult to master because you need to keep the shaving small, as already suggested. Let me make this clear. A small shaving is different then a slow/light cut. - A slow cut with a wide shaving can still cause vibration. - Each shaving should be about 1/16 inch wide, in or out, not side to side.

Re: monster help

#9

Re: monster help

Bob Rogne

I agree with Lyle. A small cut moving slow will give you a better and easier (less vibration-chatter) etc. than a larger cutter because trying to keep depth and speed of cutter is very hard. A smaller cutter will give you leeway as far as depth and speed.

Bob Rogne

Re: monster help

#10

Steve.....

Richard Jones

I was finding the same thing with my Monster set up. Mine turned out to be the knuckle joint screws had gotten a bit loose. Tightened them up, problems almost went away completely. You can get them too tight, of course, but the looser they are, the more the bit can drift away from center as you get farther away from the arm and the more vibration is induced. Also, smaller bit, smaller cut, be sure to remove chips frequently.

Hope this helps.

Rich

Re: monster help

#11

Re: monster help

SuperiorDesign comcast.net

Email sent.

Re: monster help

#12

Re: monster help

David DeCristoforo

One of the problems I have with my hollowing rig (Monster) is getting it set up so that the cutter is on center at the bottom of a vessel. If the boring bar setup is not perfectly horizontal, you can start out with the cutter centered but as you progress deeper into the vessel, it can drop below center which will cause major vibration. It can also end up above center, depending on which way it is "out of plane" and you can end up with a "stalagmite" at the bottom of the vessel which will make the cutter hop around like crazy! This is not a "problem" that can be overcome by reducing the cutter size.

Re: monster help

#13

Re: monster help

George Van Beynen

David, this has been the problem with many type of captured systems versus freehand where we can adjust. I have gotten in the habit with my hollowing rig and McNaughton bowl saver of setting the cutter tips with the bars extended to the final length and accepting any irregularities at the start of the hollowing/coring operation. This has worked well for me.

Re: monster help

#14

Re: monster help

Doc Green

To add to what George said, I have a strip of wood that hangs near my lathe with the distance from the ways to the center marked on it (10.25" for a 3520).

I set the center height of the cutter by standing the strip on the ways and then shifting the tool rest up or down to put the cutter on the mark.

I readjust the cutter height, if necessary, as I get deeper into the vessel.