Every woodturner who cares about their tools should read this article by Jerry Wright. Dr. Wright is the man who knows about tool steels. There are measurable differences in performance between the different types of steel and points them out.
What this article doesn't try to do is discuss differences in performance caused by different heat-treating processes of the same steel sources. I think of this along the lines of heating soup - you can undercook it or burn it, leaving different tastes in your mouth accordingly.
I have been studying tool steels for about 10 years. But, I am not an engineer, and will it has been a struggle. There is very little information written about tool steels to enlighten the common man. There's tons of information out there, but it is written in that specialized language all professions develop to very precisely describe things and to make it necessary for you to hire a "specialist" if you really want to know what is going on. This is not a criticism of engineers -- every profession does it. And, engineers have good reason for wanting to be very precise and accurate with their information -- far more so than, say, political scientists.
Jerry is the only person I have ever run across who takes the time to simplify the language so that an ordinary interested individual can get very sound, precise and accurate information. He is an "insider" with vast amounts of knowledge. He is highly respected in his field.
Read everything you can find written by Jerry. Every piece I have ever seen has been like a fist-sized gold nugget lying on the ground waiting to be picked up. You don't even have to dig for it.
I know I would very much like to see a good (wood-turners level) piece on heat treatment by you. I'm certain many of us would like to know more about how to recognize a good process from a poor one.
For example, I just learned this weekend that the reason that D-Way tools have a hole in the back-end, is so they can be hung, individually from a rack. The assumption is they get a more even heating then if they were put in a container or stacked on a rack.
The intent is for there to be a new editorial piece every month. At the end of August we will talk about the differences between PM and conventional steels and how they can benefit the woodturner. Effects on heat treating will be very briefly discussed. On my current plan, we will cover heat treating around the end of September. I hope to work in heat treating basics for a range of grades, commercial heat treating furnaces, practices, and common pitfalls as well as heat treating that individuals can safely try on their own shop-made tools. Thanks for your interest!!