Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Goblets

Posts

Goblets

#1

Goblets

dick gerard

In the past, when I did the art and craft show circuit, I made lots of goblets. Then I branched out to Renaissance Fairs. Made a bunch, sold a bunch. Got burned out. Now, I have agreed to do a 3 hour demo/handson class for the Society for Creative Crafts in Pittsburg later this year, and, you guessed it, the chose goblets.

So I thought I better dust off my goblet making muscles and this is what emerged. Left to right, Queen, King and Prince's goblets. King and Queen "cups" are crotch maple, stem on queen is redheart, base on King and Queen and stem on King are dyed maple. Prince is one piece cherry.

These are patterned after the Nordic-Germanic "pound on the table" goblets as opposed to the more fragile thin stemmed goblets many think of.

Tell me what you think or as they say on that other site ... critique and criticism welcomed.


img

Re: Goblets

#2

Re: Goblets

matt overton

I like them all. How tall? They are a nice departure from the tall thin goblets.

Re: Goblets

#3

Re: Goblets

Bob Salvetti

I like the goblets also. The maple cups are beauties.

As a new "poster" here (been watching for a while) and as a native son of Pittsburgh, PA I just wanted to ask if you were going to THE PittsburgH, or some other place ;-)

Also wanted to test my access here and to say "Hello to all".

Hope you can bear (?) with me as I learn.

Thanks for your help so far.

Re: Goblets

#4

Re: Goblets

bill Crommett

I like the substantial stems. Good cup design, but I don' know about the redwood stem. Send some more goblet pics.

Re: Goblets

#5

Re: Goblets

john lucas

Dick I like the concept and overall designs. I'm not sure about the choice of woods. I like the one on the right. I do like the robust design. Very user friendly.

Re: Goblets

#6

Re: Goblets

keith zimmerman, Phoenix, AZ

I love the King goblet. It has it all. I'm not sure about the stem on the Queen, but the cup is beautiful.

keithz

Re: Goblets

#7

Re: Goblets

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Dick,

Thank you for showing a new perspective on goblets. I really like the departure from the long thin stemmed ones. I like the 2 maple cups the best, and the king's stem the best. This is something I definitely want to try.

Mike

Re: Goblets

#8

Re: Goblets

john lopez

Welcome Bob, I think you will find members here to be

helpful and friendly.

Re: Goblets

#9

Re: Goblets

john lopez

I think the mixed species of wood on the king & queen make for a nice

contrast effect.

The chatoyance of the vessel portion jumps more

when it is against a dark surface and therefore the handle becomes

a complementary component.

I like them a little heavy too.

Nicely done.

Re: Goblets

#10

Leo Cuellar

Lookin' good!

Leo Cuellar

Nice work, Dick. There are times when substantial is better. Not sure I like the contrasting wood, but the forms are most pleasant.

Re: Goblets

#11

Re: Goblets

Barry Irby

I like them. The King is the best. Try it with a base like the one on the Queen. The cherry one gives me a little pause. It looks to me like the base would chip if you slammed it down and the bottom of the stem is a bit fat. Actually, they are great, but you said we could contribute, I mean critique.

Re: Goblets

#12

Ellis Walentine

Welcome, Bob

Ellis Walentine

We're all learning here, so bear with us, too. :)

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Goblets

#13

Re: Goblets

Cyril Griesbach

Dick,

I like all three for their departure from the thin stemmed we see so much of and for their functionality. Great cup shapes but the King rim could be a bit thinner to aid in drinkability. The stem designs all work and the King base could be pulled in a bit on the bottom. I'm sure you know what I mean by that, and a bit larger base on the Prince could add stability there.

I don't care for the Redheart stem but I do appreciate what you've done to add contrast with the dye. And, including the dyeing process in your demo would be an added attraction if you have the time. If not, there is always Walnut as another option.

On another note, I really enjoyed your demo at the AAW symposium and the subject matter was really interesting. I don't recall if I mentioned that to you when we had the chance to visit. It was good to see you again, my friend.

Cyril