Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Posts

To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#1

Don Leydens

To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Don Leydens

I'm thinking of bolting my 3520b Powermatic to the cement floor in the shop. I'm tossing around the idea of 2 metal plates with a chunk of rubber in between them which will go under the legs and attached to the floor with bolts running from the lathe legs down into the floor.

I've read somewhere that people were worried about a direct attachment to the floor because it might cause the cast iron legs to crack, but have never heard of this happening to anyone. I'm thinking that a good sized piece of rubber in between the metal plates will allow for a little bit of "give".

I'm not planning on turning any car sized chunks of wood, but would like to stop the occasional walking of the lathe.

Any ideas or comments would be more than welcome. Thanks in advance,

Don

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#2

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

roger lance

Don....I'm just a utility turner and have an old Delta 46-541 which I did bolt to the cement floor....the lathe manual had a diagram for locating expansion bolts into the floor that would then receive the lathe....in this case, 6 points of contact....I bought thick rubber pads from a local industrial supply that are made to cushion heavy machines and also cut up an old inner tube in pieces the size of these pads....I used different numbers of inner tube pieces to level the lathe and then tightened the nuts down on the floor bolts to secure the lathe....I did not apply a lot of pressure here, just snugged her down...the lathe passes the nickel test while running the reeves drive all the way up and back down and the head and tail centers come together with only an extremely small offset....so I think I'm ok but the idea of bolting a lathe to the floor seems controversial, so I'm also interested in reading other opinions.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#3

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

bill Crommett

I have never bolted a lathe to the floor in twenty years. My theory is that if your lathe wants to "walk" then you haven't done your home work in getting the workpiece balanced enough before you start turning. My unsubstantiated opinion is that if the lathe wants to "walk" the bearings will take a beating,so it boils down to what is your time worth. Time to replace bearings, or time to slow down the machine and get things in balance before turning up the speed.

Now, let's hear from the heavy-handed turners..

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#4

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Bill Neddow

In my opinion, the lathe has to be bolted to the floor -- otherwise you have half a lathe. Bolting it down gives it stability.

The way to really stress cast iron is to leave it loose so it flexes and wiggles as the lathe bounces across the floor. Cast iron is simply not designed to take these types of forces.

I have heard it argued that bolting down a lathe puts too much stress on the bearings if you are turning an out-of-round piece. Lathes are built with bearings that are meant to handle that stress.

If you don't believe bolting down cast iron equipment is a good idea, go visit a machine shop. Try and find a lathe that is not bolted down.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#5

Steven Antonucci

Agree with both Bills...

steven antonucci

If your lathe needs to be bolted to hold it's ground, you need to slow down. Having a mechanical attachment to the ground doesn't mean you can crank up the speed indiscriminately.

That said, mine isn't bolted to the floor , and occassionally I have to drag it 12" back to the starting point.

S

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#6

Re: Agree with both Bills...

Jim Sebring

My DVR xp has been bolted to the concrete floor since I bought it 3 years ago. So far, the cast iron legs haven't cracked. I did have to Locktite the levelling bolts to keep 'em from loostening. I have roughed out-of-balance blanks (albeit at a low rpm) without any problems.

I can't imagine Teknatool would put holes in the leg feet if they weren't meant to be bolted down.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#7

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Dale Bonertz

I just spoke with a friend (who is an metalurgist and machinest) today on this very subject. He is also a wood turner. He said, as Bill N. said, if you really want to stress cast iron then let the lathe move around on the floor or bounce back and forth with an out of balance piece. He did suggest that if you are going to bolt your lathe the floor that you should add an 1/8" thick hard rubber washer between the nut and top of lathe foot for a very little give. As far as bearing wear once bolted he says there is nothing to worry about. The out of balance piece may wear the bearings but bearing wear is not a product of lathe vibration. He also said equipment like lathes use bearings that are design for these types of loads. They will wear over time but not because of vibration. As we all know turn a little slower until the piece is coming into balance then increase your speed a bit if you choose.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#8

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Dale Bonertz

Sorry, I forgot to mention that leveling the lathe is the most important. You cannot maintain a level lathe if it is sliding around on the floor or twisting back and fourth (even if slightly) form and out of balance piece. So bolting the lathe helps slow vibration but it is more important as a means to maintain level from headstock to end of lathe and across the ways front and back.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Leo Cuellar

Don, if you level the lathe & add a thin rubber pad under the legs you won't have any worries about the cast iron breaking. The extra stability & safety margin you'll gain is worth the effort. Who wants to keep pushing around several hundred pounds of machine all the time?

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#10

Don Leydens

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Don Leydens

Seems like most of you folks are headed in the same direction as me. I'm not looking to over-compensate for an out of balance piece at high PRM's, just stop the walking that happens so slowly, I don't notice it till I see a nearby shelf that appears to be moved closer to the lathe. Like most cement floors, mine is not perfectly level and even when I level the lathe perfectly, it doesn't stay that way for long if it moves even a little.

Thanks for all the feedback and I'll wait for a couple more replies before I go rubber hunting for my lathe (I think it will take extra large).

Thanks again,

Don

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#11

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

George Van Beynen

Bill, what did you use to bolt your lathe to the floor? In between preparing for a timber harvest on the property I have located the hydronic heating lines in the concrete and am ready to bolt mine down. it was the recommended procedure from Oneway.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#12

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Charles B. Watson

Is your cement floor real smooth? Levelers with rubber pads make work better---if you can find them to fit.

The ones that come with the lathe may not be helping the situation.

My lathe sits on wood blocks bolted in the location where the levelers would be. If leveling is needed I use a wood shim, and very seldom have to re-adjust them.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#13

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Bill Neddow

George, I believe my bolts were made by Rawlplug. They have a tapered shaft with a lead sleeve on it. I drilled a 4 inch deep hole in the cement of the size recommended, inserted the special bolt and staarted tightening. As you do, the sleeve jams on the tapered shaft and the whole thing seizes against the cement as well as holding the lathe down (at the other end of the bolt). I hope that makes sense.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#14

My unsubstantiated opinion same as yours

Opelika Edro

Bill, my gut feel is same as yours -- seems like if I need to bolt the lathe down, something somewhere is not as it should be -- whether the stock is out of balance, the lathe is not sitting right, something mechanical is out of whack, or whatever else. I'm only spinning on a Jet 1442VS, but it'll get crazy if stock is way out of balance (faceplate-mounted, typically, and very wet). I give it a good spin or two with the power off to make sure the balance is good before I start up.

And now I'll follow the thread and see what answers the other kids got.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#15

sometimes out of balance is unavoidable

john lucas

For example a spalted piece that is punky on one side and solid on the other. Or if you glue up wood with a heavier piece on one side and light on the other. Sometimes wood itself is uneven density. You can see that in a crotch piece. The knot area can be more solid and sometimes heavier.

It could just be the design of the piece. I have a friend who turns hollow vessels off center so there will be a hole in the side when he hollow them. These have to be turned at high speed to get a clean cut on the inside. Naturally they shake the lathe.

I'm not turning hand mirrors out of one piece of wood. The handle throws it off balance.

I've added 300 lbs of gravel to my Powermatic so it weighs 100lbs now. It doesn't walk but it does vibrate.

What my friend did was to add some heavy angle iron outriggers to the feet. The angle iron was about 4" on each side and 1/2" thick. They were about 6 feet long and bolted to the bottom of the feet. You could not believe how well this worked. I'm looking at that option because I have to change my shop around and bolting the lathe to the floor is not an option. Tripping over the Angle iron outriggers is a problem so you have to arrange things in the shop to prevent that.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#16

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

George Van Beynen

Thanks Bill, very clear , I will get some at Home Depot or Menards the next time I am near a store.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#17

Don Leydens

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Don Leydens

Yes, Charlie, my floor is pretty smooth. I moved my lathe up (vertical) a little bit lately onto 4x4's and added some sand bags. Like you, I have no levelers. I figure once I add the rubber and metal plates I can level it one last time (hopefully). I'd like to lower the lathe a bit anyway, the elbow/spindle way of selecting the height of the lathe just isn't comfortable for me.

Thanks everyone for their input, it's very appreciated.

Don

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#18

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Dale Bonertz

George,

A friend of mine owns roughoutbowls.com. He has had to replace the lead anchors several times because they will crack and break apart over time. I was using his lathe a few years ago when he was out of town and they needed to be replaced yet again. I am a contractor so I replaced them with what I have had very good experience with when it comes to anchors http://www.homedepot.com/h_d1/N-5yc1v/R-100137995/h_d2/ProductDisplay?langId=-1&storeId=10051&catalogId=10053. Since I have put these on his lathe he has not had a problem since. I hope the link works but in case it doesn't they are red devil concrete anchors which you can get from home depot. They are available in different lengths and shaft sizes to fit your needs. I am sure that what Bill uses are working but they are know to have more problems in the constuction industry. Hope this helps.

Dale

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#19

Wedge anchors *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Wedge anchors are available in almost any serious contractor's yard and even hardware stores; not exclusive to Home Depot. I mention this in case someone doesn't live near a Home Depot.

My local contractor's yard argues that Titen concrete screws from Simpson Strongtie (the large version of Tapcon concrete screws) have greater resistance to pull-out even than wedge anchors; worth researching as to the resistance in the particular application here, where constant vibration is an element of the stress.

These pretty well require an impact driver to drive, while wedge anchors require just a suitable concrete-hole-drilling tool and a wrench. I used a couple of them on a retrofit mudsill on a project in my house. I'm not sure what torque my electric impact driver will generate - probably 150 ft-lbs or so - but it just about reached its limit when I noticed the code washers (which are huge) were starting to dig into the wood and stopped, and the anchor was still holding.


Titen screws

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#20

Woodturning on a whole different scale!

Opelika Edro

John, I get your points on a certain out-of-balance often being unavoidable. I reckon that I've not had too many issues there because the stuff I'm turning is typically not as big or complicated -- that, and I don't have near as many hours at the lathe. The inevitable lathe creep would be more obvious if I was turning 10x (or 2x) as much, for instance.

I'm a little squeamish about drilling holes in the garage floor, but that's probably more an issue of knowing that I might want/need to move the lathe, and I'd rather not Swiss-cheese the place with multiple installations. I should have stayed away from this thread, 'cause now you guys have me thinking about bolting down or at least outrigging as a practical matter. These are good ideas coming from experienced folks, so thank you for that. And I'd love to see some of these in pictures.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#21

Re: Woodturning on a whole different scale!

john lucas

Been there done that. My first real lathe (after the shopsmith that only thinks it's a lathe) was a Delta 47-715. I built the Woodsmith lathe stand. Roughing bowls on that was like me being on dancing with the stars. My partner would have shot me long ago. Chasing that thing around the room was like turning with your banjo unlocked. It was challenging to say the least.

Years later I had a Nova 3000. Great lathe, and I built a huge stand with a A shaped frame filled with sand. However the wood to metal still let vibration creep through and even though the lathe never walked, my cuts were less than perfect until the wood became balanced. Even back then I turned pieces that had protrusions or areas that cause an out of balance situation and reduced the cutting smoothness.

Now I have the Powermatic and all the issues are smaller, but still exist. This is I'm sure why everyone is talking about bolting a lathe to the floor, or over on the AAW forum adding ballast or anti vibration arms.

I don't think it's a matter of IF you have vibration, but at what speed. You reach a point where buying a bigger (read that heavier) lathe is not practical so some sort of anchoring, outrigging, or even the Vicmarc balancer are options you look at. Maybe there's a market for bolt on leg extensions. I'm thinking something like a Roof Truss but mounted low on the legs to extend the footprint. Maybe you could make it larger so you had to walk around it like standing in line at Wendy's. :) Imagine walking through this maze every time you went to the grinder. It would then function as a weight loss device and possible get Government funding.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#22

Steve Kubien

How about this idea...

Steve Kubien

If the desire to bolt down a lathe is to keep it from creeping, how about drilling holes in your floor for dowel pins? You could use suitably strong wood pins (that your made, of course) or even hex bolts which simply drop into the holes. This way, your bearings don't take the beating some people fear AND you don't need to reposition a heavy lathe (like Steve A occasionally has to do). Plus, if you want to reposition/relocate at a later date, just lift the dowels out and you are good to go.

My discussions yesterday with Andre Martel have me leaning towards NOT bolting down my DVR and it's cast-iron stand ( but I will be buying some sand bags for mass.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#23

Re: Wedge anchors

Dale Bonertz

Bill,

Those Titans look interesting. I have never seen them before but that doesn't surprise me since are lumber yards have all closed but two and they stock less and less.

You can get the wedge anchors anywhere, I just used the HD link for convenience so I hope that doesn't offend anyone.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#24

Don Leydens

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Don Leydens

Somehow my computer didn't show more than half of the comments listed but here, it's fine now. My appologies for not posting sooner.

I found some rubber blocks made for vibration dampening in the Mc Masster Kerr catalog. I'll be going that route and will let you guys know how it goes.

I realy appreciate all the comments, Don

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

#25

Re: To bolt or not to bolt, the lathe

Bill Howatt

My 20" General has 6 bolt holes. I used washers as shims and bolted it to the floor with standard concrete anchors.

If I ever get another lathe it will be bolted too. I agree with Bill Neddow's observation, I also have never seen equipment in a machne shop that wasn't bolted down. IMO, a bolted lathe makes the turning experience better - I've done enough lathe chasing.

Bill