Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

First Turning Video

Posts

First Turning Video

#1

First Turning Video

Joe Landon

Here is the first video I have produced. It is showing how I create hollow form vessels. All comments and critiques are welcomed and appreciated.

http://youtu.be/wkRDj_NHxnk

Thanks,

Joe

Re: First Turning Video

#2

Re: First Turning Video

ronnyeelen

Good job on the video Joe.

I will have a second look at home this evening, with sound :)

Re: First Turning Video

#3

Re: First Turning Video

Cyril Griesbach

Joe,

That was a first rate job on the video as well at the turning.

Cyril

Re: First Turning Video

#4

Nicely Done.  Excellent Video!

Greg Haugen

Re: First Turning Video

#5

Re: First Turning Video

Ralph E Watts

Joe,

Very good job on the video! Vessel looks good also...

Best regards, Ralph

Re: First Turning Video

#6

Re: First Turning Video

Grant Wilkinson

Very nicely done, Joe. I would have liked to have seen some "end on" shots when you were hollowing it. I'm a novice and I can use all the angles that I can get.

Also, you mention that the tool rest is a couple of inches from the top of the vessel when you are hollowing, and you warn against getting your fingers between the top of the vessel and the tool rest. Then, though, from my angle, you do exactly that. Maybe, I misunderstood what you were explaining, but to me, your index and middle finger were between the tool rest and the top of the vessel when you were deep into the vessel.

I'm really looking forward to seeing how to dye and finish it. I have had terrible results finishing maple bowls if I do anything other than oil them.

Thanks for posting this.

Re: First Turning Video

#7

Re: First Turning Video

Terry Quiram

Well done. Lots of good information in a short span. Its a great feeling when the pupil surpasses the teacher.

Who cleaned the shop???? :D

Re: First Turning Video

#8

Steven Antonucci

Saw it on your FaceBook page

steven antonucci

Very well done.

S

Re: First Turning Video

#9

Re: First Turning Video

john lucas

Joe good job. I'd like to see a little more light. It seemed a little dark to me. It would be nice for beginners if you discussed where the tool is cutting (as far as height or do point the cutter down or just how it is oriented). I think it's also important to discuss cleaning it out often before the shavings grab the tool. These are just minor points. It done well.

Re: First Turning Video

#10

Re: First Turning Video

Dick Strauss

Joe,

It is a good video that is well edited to show an overview of a lengthy process in a short amount of time! If anything, it might be too much info without the blanks being filled in for the novice. Overall, very well done!

One minor point about terminology...make sure that when you are using the wing of the bowl gouge on its side to get your desired shape on the vessel that you don't call it a shear scrape. A shear scrape implies that you are applying an angle (other than 90 degrees) between the cutting surface and the direction of wood travel. The only exception in my book is when the wings are parallel to the bed but you are actually using the rounded nose of the bowl gouge for the scraping. When presented this way, the nose creates its own shear angle with respect to the travelling wood surface.

Re: First Turning Video

#11

Re: First Turning Video

Ed Moore in SW VA

Excellent. Others have covered some technical points, so I will address content. You provided good information, but I think that you could have done better in describing your cuts. You made reference to a shear scrape, but you never said, "And here is a shear scrape. I am holding the tool so that ... ". Also you referred a couple of times to a "hero" cut, or at least that is what I thought I heard. I have never heard that term, so you have an undefined term hanging out there.

All in all I found your video easy to watch. You spoke clearly and in an even manner. I suggest that you watch the video with a pencil and pad and imagine that you are a total novice watching your first turning video. Make a list of little points that that novice needs to know.

There were several things I have seen in videos that set me off and I was pleased that you did none of these. You did not bang the tool on the rest to remove the shavings. You didn't slide your thumb down the tool to do that either.

Good job.

Ed

Re: First Turning Video

#12

Delightful!

adrien

Re: First Turning Video

#13

Re: First Turning Video

roger lance

Joe....I really enjoyed your video....it was well made in all aspects (lighting, video, sound, dialogue, etc)....I'm looking forward to seeing your video on finishing this vessel...well done!!

Re: First Turning Video

#14

Re: First Turning Video

Don at Central Illinois

You should have mentioned this at the club meeting last night. Very, very good.

Re: First Turning Video

#15

Rob Wallace

Agree - not a shear scrape.....

Rob Wallace

Joe:

I agree with Dick's comments. I do not think you are showing a "shear" scrape, given that the angle of the gouge's wing is not presented at a sufficient angle to the path of rotation to obtain a shear cut. You are doing a "light" traditional scrape, which is essentially parallel to the axis of rotation. (You may not get much tear-out in maple with this kind of scraping, but that scrape will produce tear-out in many other woods....)

Other than this technical point (...and a few comments comments made by others, with which I also agree) that can be corrected in subsequent editions, overall this is an excellent video, and one I would feel comfortable recommending to beginners to watch (...which is my standard for "good" versus "bad" on-line woodturning videos). For years I told new turners to never watch Norm Abram turn wood on New Yankee Workshop, and a I still warn beginners to be very wary of on-line turning videos regarding technique and safety. There are some really terrible videos out there! At least for me, your video does a good job of showing proper technique and addressing safety concerns.

Well done!

Rob Wallace

Re: First Turning Video

#16

Re: First Turning Video

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

What is a hero cut? Where can I get some hero tools, I don't want to get behind.

I did cringe ever time I heard "this is where we are AT."

It looks like your fingers did get in some scary places, and that after you making the point of keeping fingers out of harm's way

Well done, good enough to re-stimulate my interest in hollow forms.

Re: First Turning Video

#17

Steve Kubien

Re: First Turning Video

Steve Kubien

Good point about re-stimulating interest in hollowforms. Me too.

Re: First Turning Video

#18

I first heard the term "hero cut" .......

JamieDonaldson

...used by Don Derry years ago during a bowl turning demo, and he used it to define an uninterrupted cut with a bowl gouge from rim to bottom center. This obviously eliminated a majority of the sanding when performed correctly, and that made him a hero to me! :D

Re: First Turning Video

#19

Nicely timed and narrated

Wayne Kuhn

Re: First Turning Video

#20

Re: First Turning Video

Harvey Ghesser

Joe, I really enjoyed your video! Very well organized and a pleasure to watch. I also enjoyed how effortlessly the Glaser gouge removed what seemed like layers of wood. In the hands of a skilled artisan such as yourself, the Glaser really shines!

I look forward to your next video.

Harvey

Re: First Turning Video

#21

Re: First Turning Video

Paulo Marin

Joe,

I found your video concise and easy to follow! Your technique was excellent and your delivery through the whole process was fantastic. Great piece of wood. Even without any finish it looks absolutely beautiful. Excellent job. I also liked the Fibonacci Gage your friend made... Pretty slick!

What was the size of the piece of wood before you started so I can have an idea of the size of the vessel you ended up with.

Keep it coming Joe... Keep it coming...

Paulo Marin

Glaser Hitec

Re: First Turning Video

#22

Great job Joe.

John Cotten

Might mention to the newby that you are turning green stock. Also might talk some regarding drying the piece before finishing. I am going to watch it again. I haven't done any deep hollows for some time, but getting ready too shortly.

Re: First Turning Video

#23

Re: I first heard the term "hero cut" .......

Joe Landon

You are correct Jamie. Don Derry coined this phrase. It is one continuous cut from start to finish. A cut so perfect that anyone watching says, "Wow - you're my hero."

Re: First Turning Video

#24

Re: First Turning Video

Joe Landon

Thanks Paulo. I did not measure the wood when I started. The finished piece is approximately 7.25" tall by 5.75" wide. If I were to guess, it probably started out about 9.5" by 6.5".

Re: First Turning Video

#25

Re: First Turning Video

Joe Landon

Thanks for all the kind remarks and excellent, insightful feedback. I appreciate them all.