Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

It went boom..

Posts

It went boom..

#1

It went boom..

avalon

And left a dent in my metal ceiling..

Turned a piece of wood a bout 3 months ago, made a vessel and cut in half to hollow out... I bored out the whole thing with a forstner bit before that, and tried using sorby's hollowmaster to carve out the insides... it took a long time and then it developed a crack and i put it aside to figure out what i wanted to do.. i now have a jamison hollowing rig,,,.. so...

i put the bottom on the lathe, filled cracks with sawdust and ca, turned it back into 9.5 inch diameter round, put a 24 segment of paduk on and shaved that one down to about 1/8th inch thick...

then i made a 24 segment of alternating maple and walnut, left them about 5/8 ths inch tall, and set aside..

made another paduk ring, intending to do same as first ring, so i would have a thin band of paduk, thick of walnut and maple, and another thin of paduk to hide the fact that i cut the vessel in half..

Then i took the top part, glued the top opening to a waste block, rounded the outside back to true, and proceeded to hollow out the inside....with the jamison tool....after about 5 minutes a 45 caliber pistol went off near the bowl which then proceeded to hit warp speed and disapear from this dimention. loud bang, no bowl,,,its gone...

i search the shop and found one section behind the air compressor....another by the base of the lathe, but the third eluded me for an hour,,,, finaly found it in the rafters of the roof, next to the dent in the ceiling it had made.

I was out of the line of fire, but it scared tthe fecal matter out of me,big noise, bowl shatters and dissapearsd, and leaves dents in metal.

our local guys said i was turning to slow, and was getting chatter, so i cranked it up to 1500 to turn all this. Apparently that crack was really bad and caused it to expode,,so speed was the culprit...plus a crack

so what;s the general rule of thumb in turning regarding speed?

how fast when turning bark off, how fast to shape, how fast to use a bowl gouge, how fast to run out of the shop whne something goes wrong...

I'll try to send photos tomorrow.

Re: It went boom..

#2

Steven Antonucci

Turn as fast as you can safely

steven antonucci

Rules for balance, diameter, wood type, chucking methods, all depend upon the turners ability. The less ability you have, the slower your lathe should be running. Bad things can always happen unannounced, but 90% of the failures are probably initiated by the turner. Wood doesn't usually spontaneously fail.

Hard to say what happened, but failure analysis is a good idea. If you had a catch, cut through a wall, or had glue fail probably is a good exercise to evaluate.

Steve

Re: It went boom..

#3

Re: Thread in May related to speed

Doc Green

There was a long discussion with various points of view relating to lathe speed, safety, etc., back in May. Go back about 13 pages in the index and you should find it.

Re: It went boom..

#4

RPM x Dia = 6,000 to 9,000   ???

Doc Green

Does anyone know who came up with the rule of thumb that says the optimum turning speed should be such that if you . . .

Multiply the diameter (inches) by the RPM, you should get a number between 6,000 and 9,000?

Was it Dale Nish?

Don't know if this means anything, but if the diameter of the bowl that blew up was 9.5 inches and it was turning at 1,500 RPM, the number that comes up by multiplying them together is 14,250. ...way above 9,000.

A point on the rim of a bowl 9.5 inches in diameter turning at 1500 RPM would experience centrifugal force that amounts to a g loading of over 300. That's right much.

Steve, help me out. Is this correct?

~Doc ... slow morning here.

Re: It went boom..

#5

Re: It went boom..

John Lucas

When the piece was chattering it is not speed. At least not usually. You could have simply lightened up on the cut. turning the speed of the lathe up usually means you take a lighter cut using the same cutting technique. It can also change the harmonics so the piece vibrates differently. If you have chatter look for the source rather than turn the speed up. I'm not against turning fast. it does allow you to get cleaner cuts with smoother lines but simply turning up the speed of the lathe does not solve the initial problem.

Was it the crack, possibly, maybe a bad glue joint somewhere, how did you have the piece fastened to the lathe. If in a chuck the vibrations can compress the wood in the jaws and let the piece vibrate more which makes the jaws looser and then the wood flies out. If in a faceplate how many screws did you have.

Vibration causes the tool to want to grab the wood and pull itself in deeper which or course causes more vibration. How far the tool hangs over the tool rest and the size of the bar can cause vibration.

It may be it was all just the crack I'm just trying to throw out possibilities for the chatter. Normally when I have chatter I stop the lathe, tighten the chuck jaws if I'm using a chuck. Then take lighter cuts with a freshly sharpened tool. I check the wood by tapping on it to see if I can detect any strange sounds that might indicate a crack. I don't think I ever increase the speed.

Re: It went boom..

#6

Re: It went boom..

Mike Foster

I have been turning a lot of thin pieces lately. Once you start getting real thin, the tendency for harmonics to cause chatter increase. Changing speed is one solution to decrease the vibration, but I don't always increase the speed. Very often I will decrease the speed, sometimes to a crawl. You have to pay closer attention to the cut and form when decreasing the speed to minimize time sanding, but it often allows me to turn something to size and minimize vibration. I find that with these thin pieces, turning the speed up often only changes the nice chatter pattern that results and does not help to get a nice finished surface. So next time you run into this situation, consider slowing it down, especially if speeding it up does not seem to help.

Re: It went boom..

#7

Re: RPM x Dia = 6,000 to 9,000   ???

Bill Howatt

It may also need another fudge factor for glued/freshly glued joints/repaired cracks!

Bill

Re: It went boom..

#8

Richard Allen

Re: It went boom..

Richard Allen

A bowl steady can make a big difference with eliminating chatter.

Re: It went boom..

#9

Chuck Jones - West TN

I agree on the bowl steady

Chuck Jones - West TN

I made a pretty simple one from roller blade skate wheels and scrap 2x4 pieces. I though I got the pattern and idea from "Russ Corner" on this site, but I couldn't find it tonight. I'll look at the print out in my shop and see if I can determine where I got it. It's dirt simple (if you can find the skate wheels) and cheap and reeeaaallllly works to reduce the vibration.

Re: It went boom..

#10

Re: I agree on the bowl steady

avalon

already have one... wanted to try to make a vessel without it... i see people making bowls using outboard equipment.. and i dont think you can use a steady rest on that...

Re: It went boom..

#11

Steady rest not really necessary

john lucas

It's about sharp tools and pressure on the bevel. Surface speed of the wood is also a factor. If you look at the guys turning hats, I have never seen a steady rest used on those and they are quite large and very thin.

Once you get chatter you have to go back and cut the tops of the chatter marks off. If you keep doing the same cut the tool bounces with the chatter mark shape and just creates more. Make sure your tool is sharp and at least on the first few passes make the cut as light as possible. I'm not necessarily talking about a small cut, I'm talking about being very light on the bevel pressure. The first few passes should be very light cuts as well as light pressure.

Sometimes it helps if you change the angle of the cutting edge by rotating the tool so a different angle hits the chatter. This helps prevent it from dropping into the same chatter mark dips. This is much easier with the skew and much more difficult with a spindle gouge. Bowl gouges are in the middle.

Re: It went boom..

#12

Leo Cuellar

Re: It went boom..

Leo Cuellar

In light of John's thread on tail stock alignment, the chatter could been caused by the head stock being slightly misaligned.

Re: It went boom..

#13

Katherine Kowalski

Re: It went boom..

Katherine Kowalski

Avalon,

In addition to what everyone else has said... (slow your speed, obtain a bowl steady, etc.) I would also like to advise to work on tool control -- take light, gentle cuts. (And make sure those tips are sharp!)

In my experience, CA glue is NOT an appropriate fix for broken pieces. Some people use it with inalys, (like turquoise or brass), however, it is brittle and generally will fly apart on the lathe. My general rule of thumb -- if a piece develops a crack as I am turning I chuck it in the firewood pile. (If the piece develops a crack AFTER it's completely finished, I will consider repair with titebond glue, or a dovetail insert, etc.)

Turning cracked wood, (as you will see from our discussion a few months ago), is NOT SAFE.

One thing I found myself curious about -- what orientation was the piece? End-grain or side? End grain does NOT glue well with ANY type of glue, and gluing the open side to a waste block doesn't sound like a good plan. (There's not enough surface for the glue to stick even on side grain... could this be part of the difficulties you are experiencing?)

Anyway, it's good to see someone with your enthusiasm in turning -- please be safe, and please keep asking questions. (That's the way we learn!)

Katherine