Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Sanding with air?

Posts

Sanding with air?

Edited #1

Sanding with air?

Jorge Castaeda

My trusty Milwaukee drill, bit the saw dust. A couple days of slow sanding by hand, in this time of the year when bowls an platters are going to many places in this wide world, made think "there must be a better way"

Any of you uses compressed air to sand? I would like to hear how do you like it and if so, what tool(s) are you using. I've seen it done in auto shops and it seems to take a very short time, that would be very welcome if it works like that in wood...

Thanks for any info

Jorge

Re: Sanding with air?

#2

Re: Sanding with air?

Bill Neddow

A small compressor will not give you enough air to sand properly. A bigger one will -- but I have never been able to justify to myself running a 5 hp motor when a little hand held drill will do the same job. Also, make sure a large compressor is well insulated or you will get a migraine from the noise.

Why not try a Neiko close quarters drill? They look like the Milwaukee, but last a lot longer in my experience, and are only $59. One source is www.thesandingglove.com.

Re: Sanding with air?

#3

Re: Sanding with air?

robo hippy

I am with Bill on this one. I have a Sioux pneumatic drill, just like the electric ones. When using it, it kept the compressor running non stop.

The only way I know of shortening the sanding time is to perfect your cutting technique. I still have a long way to go on that. It takes longer for me to sand them out than to turn them, no matter how careful I am.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding with air?

#4

Re: Sanding with air?

David Walser

Jorge - Years ago (while I was still in school) I worked nights at a furniture mill. Virtually all our hand-held power tools were air tools. The advantages of air tools are numerous and significant: The tools are smaller, lighter, fit more easily into small spaces, seem to last forever with simple maintenance, and are typically less expensive to buy. This makes the air tools less fatiguing to use and easier to use accurately.

So why don't I have any air tools in my shop? Because they require a big honkin' (technical term) air compressor. When I expand my shop (on the to do list for about five years, now), I'll add a small room to house my new big honkin' compressor (right next to my new cyclone).

Re: Sanding with air?

#5

Re: Sanding with air?

steve worcester

Sure, they work great, you can get orbital or a straight sander. Issue is you do need a large compressor because the use A LOT of CFMs of air. Other downside is they are considerably more noisy than electric.

Just wish Sioux made the same quality drill they did years ago.

Re: Sanding with air?

#6

Re: Sanding with air? *LINK*

john lucas

Jorge My friend Brad Sells does chainsaw sculptures. He starts with the chainsaw then goes to various other power carving tools. Needless to say he (or his assistant) spends a great deal of time sanding. He uses only air tools. He started off with electric sander, and electric die grinders but quickly decided the air sanders were so much lighter and had lots of power.

It does take a big compressor. Brad went out looking for something that would let 2 or 3 people sand at one time. He purchased the biggest compressor I've ever seen. It came off a ship and is (No Joke) about 8 feet square with pipes that are 4" in diameter. He said it was half the price of way smaller units and since he had a spare area below the shop he put it there.

I have purchased a dual stage 5 horse compressor but haven't had the time to run more power to the shop to be able to handle this 220v monster. The air sanders are also noisy with that high pitches scream. However hearing protection stops that pretty well.


http://www.bradsells.com/

Re: Sanding with air?

#7

Re: Sanding with air?

Jorge Casta�eda

Reed,

I am getting a lot better and my sanding starts at 220 most of the time, but still takes me more time sanding than turning, I am too fussy with scratch marks...

Re: Sanding with air?

#8

Re: Sanding with air?

Jorge Casta�eda

Bill,

You make a strong point in there...

Re: Sanding with air?

#9

Steve, John

Jorge Casta�eda

So a large compressor is a must, the noise part both compressor and air turbine, are not really an issue, I am deaf, very deaf. I have 220 on the shop already and some rearranging could make the needed room, I will think about it, SWAMBO may object both to expense and noise... but looking at those pictures looks like it does a fine job.

Thank you all guys

Re: Sanding with air?

#10

Walt Bennett

Re: Sanding with air?

Walt Bennett

I think you should look at the cost/return ratio first, before going out and plunking down major dollars on anything. I've two Milwaukee right angle drills; one's over six years old and still working, the other three (I got it when I thought the first was about to croak). After getting the second I found out there are rebuild kits and parts available for them, and probably for others made around this side of the globe. A whole rebuild kit will run about $50.

The other way of sanding with air will cost you a minimum $400 compressor as well as the sanding tool. If you need the compressor then that's not much of an issue - I'm seriously wanting to upgrade my very noisy Sears oil-less to a belt type. Then you have to factor in the (I'm absolutely positive) much higher electricity to run that bigger compressor vs. the smaller electric drill.

The results as far as your bowls and other work will be the same (if you've a good air sander that gives variable speeds), but I believe just blowing out the dust will keep either a Milwaukee or Sioux running almost forever. (I've got one of the Chinese knock-offs from Sanding Glove, but don't have any long-term evaluation on it).

Re: Sanding with air?

#11

Re: Sanding with air?

Donna Banfield

Jorge, the need for a biiiiggg honkin' compressor is a necessity. But here is something that I haven't read in the preceding posts -- and what follows is only my experience, and therefore just my own personal opinion about air sanders. So read it, and decide yourself what works best.

I have two Random Orbital Air (ROA); the Sioux that Craft Supplies used to sell about 6-8 years ago, and the Grex, that they sell now. These sanders work best with the higher grits, i.e., 220 and up. I'ved used them with lower grits, but don't see any measurable difference when comparing them with a corded electric drill.

They will not shorten your sanding time because if you're using the ROA sander, you don't use your lathe to spin the bowl simultaneously. I'm sure there is a scientific, physics, mathematical (which is why I can't explain it) reason for what happens, but this it what does: as the sanding disc is spinning randomly, and the bowl is also spinning, you will begin to see a 'vortex' like pattern appear, and it gets bigger the closer you get to the bottom of your bowl. The way I avoid that is to move the bowl SLOWLY by hand, and use the entire pad (not just an outer edge) and go back and forth. This will take more time than if you could also run the lathe simultaneously.

Not all sandpaper works well with ROA. A while back I was using the Industrial Abrasives 1 meter by 1 yard sheets, and cutting my own discs. They were adequate with the corded drills, but whenever I tried to use them with a ROA sander, the disc would stall and stop. The Indasa sheets of grit (didn't matter the size/number) were too 'aggressive'. I was very frustrated; saw a few of Vince Welch's discs he sent as a sample, slapped them on the ROA, and they worked like a breeze. I now use Vince's sandpaper for all my hook and loop sanding needs.

Some bowl shapes don't work well with ROA sanders. If you have a very deep, steep curve/wall, the sander will stall. Even with the very flexible, soft inner pads.

Above, I said I use them for higher grits, but they take longer, so about now you're probably wondering why bother, right? I've found, and again, this is just my opinion, your (and hundreds of others mileage may vary) the finish I get from using the ROA sanders is superior to the same grit/finish using corded drills. For example, a 400 grit ROA sanded finish 'feels' and with some woods, looks like a 600 or 800 grit surface.

So if you're looking to shave time, this won't. If you're looking to spend a bunch of money, this is one way to do it :-) If you're looking to improve the overall quality and feel of the final finished surface, this might do it for you as well.

Good luck!

Re: Sanding with air?

#12

Re: Sanding with air?

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Jorge,

I just replaced a giant 120 gallon Ingersoll Rand compressor that was 60 years old. The 2 weeks I was without air was horrible. I finally found an 80 gallon 5hp dual stage compressor on craigslist for $450. I have 2 Grex Random Orbit and they work great and are quiet. I do most sanding by hand but the finish sanding with the Grex. I use Vince's discs and don't know what I would do without air.

Mike

Re: Sanding with air?

#13

Re: Sanding with air?

Jorge Casta�eda

Donna,

I really appreciate your input. as you are using one. I had no idea that you cannot spin the piece while sanding, and everybody says I will need a big compressor, but I still have not heard a figure, do yo go by horse power of the motor, or by storage of the tank?

I had hopes of faster sanding, so you already told me it is not, but you are giving me also something very important to me, and that is the finish, I am very fussy about my shapes and about the finishes, some people like the looks and feel and they just have to have them, so the feel is very important. I am not much of a sales person, my pieces sell themselves, that is why the shape and the feel are very important to me.

All I use is Vince's papers already, I guess my main point for deciding will be the noise level, to me is not a factor as I am very deaf, but my better half is sensitive to noise...

Thank you so much

Jorge

Re: Sanding with air?

#14

Re: Sanding with air?

Jorge Casta�eda

Walt,

somehow your post came to me as email and I responded likewise, thank you.

Re: Sanding with air?

#15

Re: Sanding with air?

Jorge Casta�eda

Mike,

I am glad you are mentioning capacity, that was a missing piece of info. looks like I am ready to take the leap, but must consider that my wife is very sensitive to noise, so I will have to do some home work and find what compressor is quiet.

Do you have any idea? I have a 20 gal Campbell Housefeld, cast iron, and extremely quiet, but I gather is not big enough.

Thank you much!

Re: Sanding with air?

#16

Re: Sanding with air?

robo hippy

I have a 60 gallon tank, and a Cambell/Hausfeld compressor that has a "5" hp motor on it. That motor is a third the size of the 4.5 hp Baldor motor on my bandsaw.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding with air?

#17

Leo Cuellar

Re: Sanding with air?

Leo Cuellar

Jorge,

Find out what the total CFM(cubic feet per minute) of the air tool/sander that you would like to use uses. To prevent major wear & tear (on) the compressor should put out at least double that number, otherwise you will watch your electric bill climb enormously. Motor speed for the compressor should be 1725rpm as opposed to 3450rpm. This will mean quieter running and longer life.

Really good air tools are expensive and so is the cost of using them. Raising maximum air pressure, within safe limits for the equipment, will help with bogging down issues, but again raises the expense.

Leo

Re: Sanding with air?

#18

Re: Sanding with air?

Stuart Johnson

This is where it gets confusing. I have a Grex and a 26 gallon 5.8 cfm compressor. According to the write up on Amazon some of the Grex specs:

operating pressure: 90 PSI (6.2 bars); 15,000 rpm; air consumption: 2.2 SCFM; 1/3 HP; air inlet 1/4" (6mm) NPT male plug. NOTE: Sander requires a minimum of a 60 gallon capacity compressor, or equivalent, to operate.

I can use the sander for a couple minutes and then the compressor kicks on. I usually let it go to passive mode to let the tank fill up but if I continue using it I don't think the compressor will ever catch up.

The random orbiting doesn't seem to work well with the lathe running but I have never thought about turning it by hand.

Re: Sanding with air?

#19

Re: Sanding with air?

David Walser

Jorge - Donna was speaking about random orbital sanders when she suggested using them with the lathe off. Not all air-powered sanders are random orbital. You could just use an air powered screw drill and sand with the lathe on as you do now. The pneumatic drill would just be smaller and lighter than your electric drill.

As for size of the compressor, that depends on the air tools you plan on using. Most use at least 4 cfm (cubic feet/minute) at 90 psi. (The small GREX uses about half that number.) A large storage tank (as long as it stores air at well above 90 psi) can let you get by with a compressor that puts out less than the minimum cfm demanded by your tool -- as long as you only use the tool for relatively short periods. For example, a screw drill that requires 4 cfm would probably get along just fine with a compressor that puts out 2 cfm (the size of most home shop compressors) -- provided the screw drill is used to drive screws (which takes only a few seconds of air for each screw). On the other hand, the same compressor would be inadequate if you were to use the screw drill as a sander, because now you're consuming air for several minutes at at time instead of several seconds. A large tank might let you sand for a minute or more before the compressor kicked in, but then you'd have to wait several minutes for the tank to fill up before you could resume sanding.

So, what does this mean to woodturners wishing to use pneumatic sanders? As a practical matter, we're most likely going to want a compressor that is rated to produce at least 12 cfm. Which requires at least a 3hp (220v) motor. Most compressors that large come with 60 gallon tanks (or larger). That's about the minimum size compressor you'd need to sand a bowl without having to wait every few minutes for the compressor to catch up.

Re: Sanding with air?

#20

Leo Cuellar

Re: Sanding with air?

Leo Cuellar

Which should make your tank capacity at just over 4 cu.ft.(Gallons X 0.15556) I have no understanding of just how the actual volume of air compression vs consumption are determined. I can only surmise that the compressor ratings are determined without pushing against a pressurized tank? Maybe that would account for the performance discrepancy?

I don't use air at home for much other than cleaning out motors & pumping up the occasional tire.

Re: Sanding with air?

#21

Re: Sanding with air?

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Jorge,

My compressor is rated at 11.5cfm at 100lbs. Pressure. The 80 gallon tank shuts off at 160 lbs. I use an in line regulator that is set at 90 lbs. I run the Grex for 30 minutes and it will kick on the compressor maybe 2-3 times. I'll try to listen the next time to see how often.

Mike

Re: Sanding with air?

#22

Grex Reps suggestion.

john lucas

When I stopped by the Grex booth at the Woodcraft annual sales meeting I mentioned the fact that I currently had a small compressor and the Grex just ate up air. He suggested you adjust the limiting screw at the back of the unit. It slows down the rpm and saves a lot of air. I plan to try that on my next bowl which will hopefully be later in the week.

Re: Sanding with air?

#23

Re: Sanding with air?

Donna Banfield

Hi Jorge

Sorry for not replying sooner, but today was just another work day for me. :-)

Several people who posted pretty much covered your unanswered questions. My compressor is a 60 gallon Husky, 11 CFM. The regulator is set at 90 PSI for ROA sanding, and with a full tank of air, will kick on for me after 3-5 minutes (I've never really timed it). I don't notice any 'bogging down' of my sanders when the compressor kicks on.

It is very noisy, but not so much for me after I moved from the garage under my house, to my barn ( errr... studio for anyone who is a customer or collector and reading this). The barn is a stand alone building behind my home. All the noisy equipment (compressor, vaccuum pump, sand blasting cabinet) now sits on the second floor, and the only thing I detect is the slight rumble on the ceiling when the compressor kicks to start filling the tank. Now that's if I'm in my barn/studio, which is very well insulated. If I step outside while the compressor is running, it's pretty loud. So, in respect for my neighbors, I don't use the air after 7 pm, or before 9 am. That might be another thing for you to consider.

Re: Sanding with air?

#24

Leo Cuellar

Re: Sanding with air? Brrr!

Leo Cuellar

Jorge, one other thing about air tools that I don't think anybody mentioned is: where the exhaust is ported. If it blows back across your hands, it will chill them in a big hurry. This makes them very unpleasant to use for any great length of time when the weather is cold. Just something else to keep in mind should you take the plunge.

Re: Sanding with air?

#25

Re: Sanding with air?

Vince Welch

Jorge,

There are some facts most people do not understand regarding Pneumatic sanding.

1. Works best with higher grits 220 and above! Pneumatic does not have the torgue needed to allow you to get those deep scratches and tool marks out!

2. You will at least a 60 Gallon Compressor (per Cambell Hausman) to provide the CFM at a constaint flow rate. You can use a oilless unit such as 30 gallon just know that if you are using those units and the compressor is running more than 15 minutes an hour you are degragating the life of the compressor.

3. Use a soft innerface pad with higher grits.

4. Using a ROS will create a nice "soft" finish.

Hope this helps, Vince