Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Glaser Screw Chucks

Posts

Glaser Screw Chucks

#1

Glaser Screw Chucks

Michael Pinto

Have learned the 'hard way' not to use cheap tools or 'home made' versions. Glaser Screw Chucks are the best and worth every penny !

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#2

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

Nick Tuzzolino

AMEN! I was fortunate enough to learn that about tenyears ago.

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#3

Steven Antonucci

Never has something come off a screw chuck

steven antonucci

I have 2 screw centers for my Nova's and I can't remember ever having something come off? I've heard great things about the Glasers being the best, but what improvements do you feel warrant buying one over the center that came with whatever brand chuck you own?

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#4

I agree with Steve..................

Greg Haugen

I've never seen a purpose for the "stand alone" screw chucks. One exception would be if you were working with multiple fixtures, like metal spinning but I'd probably faceplate those or thread them. I prefer to use, and always use, the screw that came with my Stronghold. I like the fact that I can change the amount of surface area by using different jaws with it, if it's a bigger bowl or platter I can use the #3 jaws, something smaller I'll use the standard jaws. The Oneway Woodworm Screws are incredibly durable and hold very well. Never have had any issues.

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#5

Re: Never has something come off a screw chuck

John Lucas

I have 5 screw chucks. One comes with each chuck. I can hardly remember the last time I used one. Occasionally I use one for turning a platter but that's it. What do you all use them for?

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#6

Re: Never has something come off a screw chuck

Greg Haugen

John,

I use them for most commonly for mounting bowl blanks. I'm more of a production turner and a lot of my techniques I learned from Mahoney, Glenn Lucas, Batty, and Bosch. I use faceplates to make reversing mandrels to finish the bottom of a bowl, but that's it. I don't turn enormous, or very long pieces that I can't have between centers so faceplate collect dust in my shop. The Woodworm screws are very fast (about 5 seconds to change from one bowl to the next-when I turn bowls I turn them in stages, all of the outside profiles first, then all of the interiors) and hold extremely securely. Out of all of them that I've seen, the Oneway Woodworm Screws have the deepest threads as well as the securest hold in the chuck with grooves/flutes that meet with the interior slides of the jaws. Some screws do lack a bit on the threads (rather shallow and fine) and chuck hold (just a round surface, not much grip).

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#7

Re: Never has something come off a screw chuck

Guy Bratt

Here is a project I've been working on using the screw chuck. Woodriver chuck with supplied screw. Everything held togeather nicely.

Turning left handed in the air resulted in some design oppertunities so I'm not done. With out the screw chuck or a more expensive chuck I don't know how I would have gotten this far.

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#8

Steven Antonucci

Like that a lot!

steven antonucci

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#9

Steven Antonucci

Sort of the same as Greg...

steven antonucci

I don't make a lot of bowls, but when I make bowls, I make a lot of bowls (if that makes sense?)

My process is to work in production mode. I get all of my bowl blanks to a rough round on the bandsaw and drill them for mounting on the screw chuck. Thread them on, turn the outside with a tenon, remove. I probably take 2 minutes per bowl shaping the outside from mount to dismount.

Next, I remove the screw chuck and remount all of the bowls for hollowing. Last time, I made 11 bowls (4-6") in an hour (roughouts).

A screw chuck cuts a lot of time out, and mounts really securely to allow me to cut at about 1500RPM without worrying...

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#10

Re: Sort of the same as Greg...

John Lucas

Thanks Greg and Steve. Production was what I suspected. My bowls are all different and the front surface is usually varied quite a bit. I start them between centers so I don't have to do anything to the top (ie, drill a hole, etc) It also gives me the option of changing the center point at any time if I think the piece would look better with a different orientation.

I suppose if I were to cut my blanks round for production work the screw center or Glen Lucas style mounting system would make more sense.

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#11

Thanks

Guy Bratt

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Never has something come off a screw chuck

Steve Kubien

I cannot remember that last time I used a screw chuck. I simply do not trust them for anything but the smallest pieces (less than 6"). I have had a couple of larger pieces come off and that was enough for me to fall in love with faceplates. Yes, a faceplate takes more time but I have a lot more confidence in them. Heck, most small pieces I do get mounted with a spur drive (yes, bowl blanks).

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#13

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

JerryW

This an interesting thread because it starts with two postings of happy campers relative to their screw chucks and moves on to posts that run the gamut from (my paraphrasing) �don�t have problems with screws holding on any chucks� to �how do you use screws?� to �I use screws in 4 jaw chucks� to �here is how I learned to use them� to basically, � I don�t need no stinkin� screws�. :)

I then wondered why was it designed in the first place? Since I am always interested in how technology originates, especially design technology, I looked up Jerry Glaser�s patent (www.USPTO.gov) on the screw chuck � yes, he took the time and $$ to apply and was granted a design patent! It is a simple design patent with drawings, and gives no insight into his reasons for the design, however the patent credits all other possible sources (patents) which might bear on the originality of his design. This is especially interesting to me, because it peeks into the soul of the man � so full of ideas but very concerned that they were really his. The whole topic of original ideas vs knock-offs is for another time, but as an example: If I developed talent I don�t currently have, and worked really hard and took the time to make a copy of a Rude Osolnik signature candle stick � would I have copied its shape or its soul??? .. and of course would anyone buy it, without its soul?

Jerry Wright

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#14

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Ed Moore in SW VA

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#15

Steven Antonucci

So, is a soul transferable like patent rights?

steven antonucci

If you invent something, and then sell the patent rights to it, does it transfer your soul into the Chinese manufacturers? Or the marketing company that now owns the name?

I have heard anecdotally that the Glaser screw chuck is the best out there, since it has the deepest and sharpest threads, but I've never used one (so I am only repeating what I've heard). My original question to the users wasn't to challenge the Glaser vs. the world debate, but merely to ask "why do you think it's so much better"?

It may be the best screw chuck in the world... I just wanted to know why Mike Pinto thought so. An opinion with no data is just an opinion. An opinion with data may just be a fact...

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#16

Re: So, is a soul transferable like patent rights?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve,

If process A is identical to process B, then the souls should be the same in tools made from the same steel.

Like you, my knowledge of the Glaser screw chuck is anecdotal because I don't have one. So, I am reduced to asking the question that you alluded to, "What makes the Glaser screw chuck the best?"

I think that reduces the question to asking what can go wrong with a screw chuck?

1. The chuck could have wobble if the threads do not sit well with the threads on the headstock.

2. The screw could be unstable if it is not welded securely to the faceplate.

3. The screw could have threads which were dull and not large.

Maybe someone with a Glaser chuck can address these issues.

Ed

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#17

Ellis Walentine

Enough speculation

Ellis Walentine

>Ed, you're crossing the line here. Yes, certainly, it's fair enough to say that different manufacturers may (or may not) heat treat identical steels differently, but you have no hard evidence to show that any one of these companies produces a different or better tool (or that this amounts to some kind of soul). I know your logic makes eminent sense to you, but it is implicitly understood as disparaging Glaser's competitors. It's speculative, unjustified and unfair. You're entitled to your opinion, but I will appreciate your refraining from posts that essentially denigrate manufacturers without a shred of evidence.

Thanks.

Ellis Walentine

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#18

Steven Antonucci

Issues I've seen teaching

steven antonucci

I think you have illustrated some things that make a Glaser dedicated screw chuck better than one for a chuck. Here are some stories that might back these ideas up:

When I teach, I try to cover a variety of mounting methods over the course of the class to get people to think about the what, why and when of each. I usually start a beginner bowl with a small block no bigger than 3x5" and we mount them in a demo on a screw chuck.

I had three issues this past year. The first issue was that one of the students had mounted the screw in the chuck wrong (not grabbing the right part of the screw). The second one hadn't grabbed the screw on the flats, so the screw rotated loose. The last one hadn't screw the bowl all of the way down, so it wasn't seated.

Would a Glaser dedicated screw chuck overcome the first two issues? I think it would. Might it overcome the last issue? Perhaps if it threaded more easily, but this is subjective...

Is it a better alternative to a screw in a chuck? That's still a matter of budget and personal preference. A chuck screw used properly probably has sufficient holding power for most of it's intended operations, but if I was a production bowl turner, a Glaser screw chuck might be something of a nice to have...

Where are my lottery tickets...?

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#19

Murphy's Law

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve the problems with screws in chucks, versus screw chucks, sounds like Murphy's law, where if something can go wrong some student will find a way to make it happen.

I note that the new Glaser screw chuck accommodates a larger plate, which I think would be safer in some circumstances than the original.

Ed

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#20

Steven Antonucci

On another note: Glaser's Patent is expired

steven antonucci

According to what I read, US Patents issues before 1995 had a 17 year duration from the issue date or 20 years from the file date. Glaser filed the patent for his screw chuck in 1988, and it was awarded in 1990.

By either calculation, it expired 3-5 years ago. Wonder why no one has knocked it off since? Seems like it could be a Wood River item if there was a market for them?

Just wondering...

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#21

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

There is a cottage industry on the southern Oregon coast consisting of many large and small woodturning shops turning out bowls made of myrtlewood, a wood that's unique to the area. Sometime in the early 80's I spent several days visiting many of these shops studying their turning methods. Most of them were using shop made screw chucks. Shop made because there was nothing suitable available on the market. The chucks were made using a shortened full thread lag bolt which was embedded into a block of wood and fastened to a faceplate. The threads were deepened and sharpened using a round file. Their method was to rough turn the bowl, put it into a kiln to dry, then remount it and finish turning it. In the large shops it then went to another (lower paid) person who sanded it before applying a finish. It's easy to see the advantage in using a screw chuck to mount it and remount it several times. (That was years before the 4-jaw chuck used by turners today had been invented). Unless things have changed in recent years you will find a small label glued to the center of the bottom of their bowls. It covers the hole used for the screw chuck.

Of course I went home and made a couple of screw chucks of my own and have used them ever since. I chose to use a glue block instead of fastening the chuck directly to the blank.

I purchased a Glaser chuck soon after they came on the market. The screw itself is what makes them the best available. The thread is thinner and sharper and deeper than any of the others. Because it's so thin it displaces less wood giving it a more secure hold.

When problems occur when using a screw chuck, it's usually because the blank wasn't tightened enough. I often use a large slip joint pliers applied to the glue block to give it that little bit of extra tightening.

Screw chucks won't work with end grain. If the wood is soft it helps to apply some thin CA to the bored hole. Be sure the glue has dried before inserting the screw.

Is a screw chuck as secure as a faceplate? No. Several screws around the edge of a faceplate is the most secure holding you can get.

As a point of interest, unless things have changed recently, most of the Oregon coast turners hollow thier bowls using large, heavy duty scrapers with a tantung steel cutting edge. They hollow a bowl remarkably fast.

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#22

Great question!

Ed Moore in SW VA

Hi Jerry,

Before your question can be answered, one must decide whether one must have a soul before one can steal a soul. I contend that the answer to my question is "Yes!" People may physically copy an object such as a candlestick or a turning tool, but if they have no soul they will never copy the essence or spirit of that object.

Recently I have given a lot of thought to turning tools and your question is most applicable there. I have decided that two companies, say A and B, can buy tool steel from the same source. Their machinists can make 100 1/2" bowl gouges of the exactly the same shape. Company A heat treats and freezes the tools according to process A. Company B heat treats and freezes their tools according to process B. I take one tool from Company A and one from Company B and sharpen them exactly the same. Should I expect the same quality cuts and performance from the two tools? ABSOLUTELY NOT!

The two tools above may look exactly alike, but their souls are different because they have been heat-treated and frozen using different processes. Their Rockwell Hardness numbers may be quite different! One may be 57 and the other 62. The performance of such tools would be remarkably dissimilar. The brittleness of the tools may be quite different, so much so that one may be safe to use and the other less so. The heat-treating processes gave these tools different souls.

Ed

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#23

Re: On another note: Glaser's Patent is expired

JerryW

Steve:

You are correct that patent life is in the range of 14-20 years depending upon type. Whether a patent is then duplicated by another producer (China or U.S.) depends on whether the size of the market and cost to produce warrant it. Some products that are made to very tight tolerances and excellent finish may not lend themselves to low cost manufacture. This has little if anything to do with whether they are useful.

Also when a company sells itself to another company or marketing group, normally all patents, trademarks, and technical know-how are included. Technical know-how is where the �soul� of the product tends to be. That is why when highly technical companies are sold, the sales agreement often includes the consulting input of the company founder. Much of a proprietary product lies within its production processes, and are well beyond what most imagine.

I spent a career working with customers that used and mis-used CPM steels. The mis-use always seemed to stem from a lack of understanding of the depth of processing and materials knowledge and process control necessary to produce consistent, high quality products with advanced alloys. There is an old adage �the more a person knows, the more they know that they don�t know.� Too often, I have seen pristine multi-million dollar machining operations where the heat- treating department looked like something out of the dark ages. Why � �Heat treating is simple, machining is complex.� :)

I turn a lot of glue-ups (large segments, if you will). I will not turn a glued up block that I did not personally complete. Why? I need to know what is in that part of its soul.

I have a Glaser Screw Chuck as well as several Teknatool Nova chucks with their furnished screw insert. The Glaser is dead nuts on center, while you have to be careful in positioning the screw insert in the jaws of the adjustable chucks, or things do not stay on center. This is particularly noticeable when I reverse a bowl and grab either a spigot or a recess with the jaws.

Jerry Wright

Jerry Wright

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#24

Steven Antonucci

QA and QC

steven antonucci

Having the know-how is certainly valuable, but executing flawlessly in the manufacturing process is also paramount to success. Knowing that heat treating requires special attention and actually having that attention to detail to make sure it happens is how special products are created.

I know that you have an extensive background with the Crucible steel products, and the metallurgy. I know that Jerry Glaser knew what he was doing as an aerospace guy. (His other patents all had big words in them and were very complex.)

I'm just wondering what the reason for not seeing a copy cat product is? The Oneway screw looks pretty good @$25. I think the Glaser was more then $100? I'm betting that is the reason (folks won't pay the premium, so companies won't knock it off...)

S

Re: Glaser Screw Chucks

#25

Re: QA and QC

JerryW

Steve:

I am not familiar with the $25 Oneway screw that you are referencing. I do see that they market a morse taper screw chuck for about $70. The Glaser screw chuck that I have is relatively involved in that one can change the diameter of the face plate behind the screw by threading on and off different diameter plates. The standard is a 3 inch diameter. It might be good to have one in your teaching kit.

Jerry