I used to put things in a plastic tote with a small dish at the bottom of regular household ammonia. With the lid on, it would just fume away until I took it outside to air out. I don't think you can over-fume it?
I'd finish things when the wood no longer smelled...
Thanks Steve. I have seen some one else's work (Richard Kennedy I think) where they fumed elm to nice results. Not as deep as oak but very nice. When I have it done, I will be sure to post pictures.
Steve, I ran a series of experiments on fuming awhile back for a presentation to my turning club. I fumed samples of 15 woods, mostly hardwoods, but including pine. These were fumed for 3 days in a sealed container using household ammonia with the samples on a rack out of contact with the liquid ammonia. Without exception, the fuming darkened the wood substantially, generally as one might expect to see from long aging of the wood. Elm was not one of the samples, which did include maple, sycamore, madrone red gum and other light-colored woods. I would be very surprised if elm would not darken also.
The ammonia smell of the wood disappears within a day or so. I have used the process for several pieces made of cherry and madrone and have successfully applied finish after one or two days.
BTW, I posted pictures of the results of the experiment here a few of months ago. A search should find them if you are interested.
Steve.....I'm just a utility turner but as a flat worker, I've been taught not to use any oil based finish on the inside of any case piece that will be closed up or store cloth as the oil finish will turn rancid and affect the cloth items stored there.....so do you have an issue with the oils you mentioned on bowls that will be used for food??
I also don't know what you can expect from Elm. Try a test piece of wood from the same stock before to get an idea of what your results might be. (Fume it, let it air out until it no longer smells and then put some finish on it. Fumed and unfinished does NOT look like what you would hope.) If you are not getting the results you want, you can buy tannic acid, I believe in a dry, powered form that you would mix with distilled water, at the grocery store. It's used for canning. Apply this to your pieces (sample piece first) and then fume them.
Let the pieces air out until no trace of ammonia can be smelled and then finish and they should be safe for food...as long as you don't use any finish with heavy metals. Mahoney's Walnut Oil is a good choice if you are really worried.
Craig has a good point. I failed to mention that in my tests I sanded the pieces before fuming and then afterwords applied a lacquer finish to both the fumed and the not-fumed comparison pieces. Although fuming darkened all of the woods, the darkening was not necessarily attractive.
Hey Roger, great question. Mike Mahoney makes a walnut oil which cures (polymerizes) in the wood, like tung oil does. This is what I use for 95% of my functional work. Every now and then a piece seems to beg for a higher shine and I will tung oil that. I have never heard of an oil which polymerizes going rancid. Olive oil and other cooking oils will go rancid and no, they don't cure.