Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Beauty is in the eye of ...

Posts

Beauty is in the eye of ...

#1

Beauty is in the eye of ...

Steve Criscenzo

...Who??

Steve A. and I had an interesting exchange on a post below about what is "good enough" to sell, donate, gift ...

It got me thinking.

I would never gift or sell anything I was not satisfied with. This is not to say it could not be any better but at a minimum I would be proud to have it displayed with my name on it.

I have a bin in my shop with rejects, some in rough form and some finished. They are items that for whatever reason I did not like. I periodically give the contents of the bin to a neighbor who uses it for kindling or burns it in his fire pit. Occasionally, someone comes into my shop and wants an item from my reject bin. Most of the time I refuse. Once or twice, with a persistent person who has an artistic eye, I have given in and let them take a piece. (I did discover however that my neighbor's kids have a fine collection of bowls and hollow forms in their sand box)

I am an engineer and tend to think linear. It does not take me long to learn a technique. But after six years I still struggle with creating a consistently pleasing form.

So what is "good enough"? And who's opinion matters more, mine or the person reviewing or receiving the piece. Would you ever let something go out of your reject bin?

Food for thought.

Steve

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#2

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I won't sign it if I'm not happy with it. If someone wants an unsigned piece, I will explain why it isn't signed and if they persist they can have it. I emphazie that as far as I am concerned it is a reject and considered (by me) to be kindling.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#3

Selling one's Work

Fred

I quit selling my woodturnings in 1996 after I calculated my profit over the previous three years. I still give pieces to friends, donate them to organizations for fund raising auctions, etc. There were a couple of events in the three years that I sold at craft fairs, which made me feel that I didn't have any idea what people really liked. The first craft show that I sold at, I had my first bowl, which I considered awful. My wife pushed me to take it. It happened to be the only piece I sold. A lady walked up looked at what I had and said OH! and picked up that awful bowl (in my eyes). She didn't ask how much, she just said this is mine.

A couple of years later, I was at another much larger show. I had a little vase that I thought was awful, again my wife had insisted that I take it. A lady pushed her way through the crowd in my booth and grabbed the vase saying, This is mine!

The wife I'm referring to was an artist. She died in 2000. My current wife is also artistic and is a turner.

Do we really ever know what is good, I don't know.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#4

Re: Selling one's Work

steve worcester

If it should be in a reject pile, I cut them in half on the bandsaw first. My wife likes to give them away, but not if they are cut up.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#5

Who can guess what others think of.....

JamieDonaldson

..our creations, because "turning for the market" is an impossible guestimate, and not always satisfying for the turner. As the ol' country philosopher once said, "there just ain't no accountin' fer good taste!" ;)

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: Who can guess what others think of.....

Steve Kubien

Jamie, you are so right about this. I have tried to make turnings for the masses (pens, razors, spurtles, ornaments blah blah blah) and I have hated it. It's not fun and quickly saps the enjoyment tuning provides me with. Now I try desperately to turn what I want to turn. Mostly that means functional bowls. I love 'em and like to think I decent at it. Will I sell less since taking this course of action? Perhaps. But, I have a lot more fun. Hmmm, I think there is a blog post in here somewhere.....

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#7

Steven Antonucci

I make work that I like and to my standard

steven antonucci

If I don't like it (happens a lot), I won't sign it. Odds are, I won't even let it in the house. Most of it clutters my shelves in the shop waiting for inspiration or the next cold December day. I'm ok with burning something that didn't quite get there...

It is far more important for me to develop a critical eye for myself than for what others may like. If you look at some of the things people buy, it will make your brain hurt. I don't understand how some people are wired, but then again, I don't make stuff for them. I make for me, and it just happens that occasionally, some with money appreciates what I do.

Most of the time, they appreciate it without the money, and that's OK too (except that it's much easier to appreciate something that you aren't buying...)

Make a contribution to the burn pile this morning. Possibly another on on the lathe right now...

Steve

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

keith tompkins

Good topic Steve. Turning, like all craft forms, is a two-edged sword. We must learn not only techique, but also design skills. I believe they go hand-in-hand, and that is how I approach the classes I teach. I constantly work with turners who have five years or more experience on the lathe; many have good technical skills, but have made little to no progress on the design end of things. ( I posted a motorcycle analogy a while ago; a rider with 17 years experience realized he only had a year's experience, repeated 17 times) Too often we focus on new tools, new equipment, and neglect the design aspect all together. How do we know a good design from a bad one? Is is possible to consistantly produce good forms and shapes? Until recently, there has been precious little written on design in the woodturning community; as though there was a big mystery concerning the subject. One of the better new books on bowl design was written by Richard Raffan. If you read through his book, you will have a good grasp on what it takes to produce a well-designed bowl. Guesswork and trial-and-error won't be necessary any longer. If you are serious about the work you produce, seek out a turner (or other craft artist) known for producing good form. Ask their frank, honest, opinion of your work, along with any suggestions. There are other, often more frustrating and humiliating, ways to know if your pieces are well designed...Enter several juried exhibitions. If your work is accepted to even a few, you are on the right track .Piles of rejection notices can be a very depressing dose of reality. Approach well-known art/craft galleries (inquire about the correct procedure) and show them your work. Trust me on this one...you will absolutely KNOW how good your work is, or not, by their response. They have seen it all, from the worst to the very best. Today, with so many good turners out there, it's hard to impress them.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#9

Re: Can you learn pleasing form in a class?

Steve Criscenzo

Keith

Good thoughts.

The reason I started the thread is because I have a couple of artist friends who have looked at items I did not like and they have had very different opinions. Their artistic eye focuses (or filters) differently than mine.

I have done several shows. In the last one, I had to be convinced to include a couple of pieces that did not strike me as pleasing forms. These two pieces sold while I was setting up the show and I had numerous additional offers over the six week durration of the show. The buyer was an artist that liked the form.

So, I guess my point is that I have learned to get another opinion as to the the "beauty" of a form. I hope, with time, to get better at judging a form and get away from my linear, symetrical, engineer thought process.

I am self taught. I am thinking of taking a class but I wonder, can your learn the appeal of a good form in a three day class?

Steve

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can you learn pleasing form in a class?

keith tompkins

Steve, ask your artist friends WHY they liked certain pieces, and didn't like others. That would be a good start. Perhaps you can post images here for critique. Can good form be taught? Can it be taught in a three-day session? Yes, if the instructor is able to convey what constitutes good form, and why certain concepts work, and how they can be applied to improve your turnings. I have seen dramatic improvements in the work produced by many of my students when they applied the things they learned.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#11

Walt Bennett

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

Walt Bennett

I really like this topic, but I've multiple aspects to my answer:

I will put far more effort and work into gifts than 'craft' items - I spent almost eight months completing a dry honey locust crotch piece for one of my daughters as a wedding present.

The 'decor' bowls I sell have less work and time in them (obviously!). I'll spend more time sanding and finishing than turning usually, to get the right finish and look. In about one out of five pieces of wood (when I find some really interesting figure or color), I'll put more time and work into it.

Craft items (bud and flower vases, lamps, pepper grinders, etc.) get the least attention to detail and finish, but will still look very similar to the bowls I'm trying to sell. (Can't have something looking really ragged next to them.) These are the closest to 'production' work that I make for art/craft fairs, but they continue to sell enough to at least pay booth fees. These are what pay the bills and let me do better things.

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#12

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Can you learn pleasing form in a class?

Katherine Kowalski

Steve,

I agree with Keith -- why a form is good and pleasing to the eye can be learned in a class taught by an excellent teacher, one who is able to explain the why and wherefore, (and possibly the derivation) of such forms.

In addition, may I also suggest another approach? I find that the very best way to learn what is pleasing is to observe. Look at EVERYTHING around you -- art, architecture, every-day objects, leaves, flowers, toasters, space stations on sci-fi tv programs, clothing, phones, columns, "decor", paintings, sculpture, commercial art on product packaging: EVERYTHING.

Every time you walk around your house, notice the objects, every time you leave the house... when you see something pleasing to you, make a note in a sketchbook. (It could be just a simple profile). Example: when I watched an episode of Dallas the other day, they used a particularly lovely wineglass -- I couldn't help but jot down the form.

Not everything you see in the world will be beautiful -- but some of it will. And some of that may appeal to you. (In essence, you will begin to consciously create your own aesthetic). Look at what you've observed, discover what elements you like, and good forms in your woodturning are at your fingertips.

Katherine

Re: Beauty is in the eye of ...

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can you learn pleasing form in a class?

keith tompkins

Katherine, we're on the same page on this topic! Great suggestions. Try taking a walk to a destination you usually drive to. You will be amazed at the things you missed while driving!