Re: Hollowing Tools
Katherine Kowalski
John,
I guess I should have been more specific. I do a lot of hand-hollowing of small projects, like boxes and ornaments. However, on large pieces, I find that the extreme length of the tool handle and the heaviness of the tool on the rest makes it difficult to achieve a light cut.
I, personally, have not done enough hand hollowing on large pieces to be "beat up." The reference was to personal accounts I've heard from several local (semi-pro) turners who either got a catch with the tool, (and had their shoulder severely injured), wrist injured because of torque issues, and other problems, (including holding the tool in a small opening while trying to reach across the machine to turn the lathe off, and getting one's bone displaced from the shoulder socket). These injuries seem to occur at least once or twice a year, despite these being experienced folks.
I also think that the wall thickness of a project matters -- if one is hollowing to 1/16 inch walls or less, I would always choose a captured system with the laser -- it just makes life easier. Thicker than that... say for carving...
Well, it's up to the individual turner.
Sooo... aside from the smallest projects, I have to say I'm a convert to the captured system -- it works for my needs, and it feels safer. (And it's sooooo much easier, and more enjoyable to achieve those light light cuts, and the finesse that you mentioned in your post). 
Katherine




