Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Hollowing Tools

Posts

Hollowing Tools

#1

Hollowing Tools

Scott Blundell

I have been cutting end grain on some Mesquite I have here locally. The end product looks very nice, but the process is beating me to death. I've had several requests ("Make me one of those"). So, I've been tool shopping!

I think I really like the Hollow Pro Tool by Mike Jackofsky, but have not found anyone besides him who says it is a really great tool. (my search skills could be deficient, but I did try the archives) Is this offerring really that new or simply too expensive to try if you have already solved the problem?

I have read a lot of good things about the Hunter tools which seem to be the same concept but have never used one. Although it seems like having the angle of attack set in the tool and a square shaft to keep it oriented would be advantages over the round Hunter tools.

It seems a little tricky to figure out what you need, and it seems to have a pretty high entry cost, but the replacement blades are reasonable and the cutters should have similar life to other carbide cutters.

Here is a link to a picture and a video: http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Turning_Tools___Hollowing_Tools___Hollow_Pro_Hollowing_Tools___Hollow_Pro_Tool___hollow_pro?Args=

Re: Hollowing Tools

#2

Re: Hollowing Tools

Karen F.

There are many of us here in the San Diego Woodturners that have and used Mike's tools. I use them for Medium to Large size hollow forms for end grain, side grain and burls. The angle built in to the tip really helps with finding the right angle to cut using the Hunter cutters. These things cut so fast you are constanly stopping to blow the chips out. I can get 2 or 3 cuts inside before I have to stop.

The other thing I like about Mike's tools is using them on dry wood. I tend to have both green and dry burls laying around so it's nice to have tools that cut either just as well. I have tried and own several different hollowing tools that this is my go-to tools for most of my hollowing. I hope this helps and good luck. If you can try them first that helps. If you're in San Diego you can try mine. Good Luck, Karen

Re: Hollowing Tools

#3

Re: Hollowing Tools

john lucas

I'm a Hunter tool fan as you may know. I like being able to change the angle so the round shaft works great for me. However for hollowing I prefer either the fixed angle #1 used in a Jamieson adjustable tip holder (I forget what he calls it) or one of the new bent tools that also has a fixed angle. I still use the round bar for some hollowing.

I tend to use the John Jordan style scrapers for most hollowing. The small 3/16 cutters can really hog off material. You do need to sharpen them often.

I do agree, the Hunter tools fill up the void with shavings really fast so there is a learning curve for when to stop and clean out. With the small cutters this isn't a problem at all but with the larger cutters the curls can be large enough it's hard to get them out of a small hole. It's not really much of a problem just something to be aware of. Keep a bent coat hanger handy to scoop them out.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#4

Steven Antonucci

If you are getting beaten up, it's not the tool

steven antonucci

Odds are that your problem isn't the tool, but how you present it. If you break down the tool into components, the facts become simple. You have a cutting edge attached to some kind of shaft, and you need to present that cutting edge the proper way.

One of the things I stress is that you never want to cut end grain if you can avoid it. If I am making an end grain vessel, I drill a small hole and then stick my tool into it to widen by cutting into side grain. If I am cutting a face grain vessel, I will cut the top half using my hollowing tools and the bottom half using a bowl gouge.

In the end, if you have a hook tool, carbide disc, scraper, or Ellsworth style tool, you simply need to put it on centerline and try to cut with the grain. If you aren't it will beat you up.

Steve

Re: Hollowing Tools

#5

Scott- for a first hollowing tool I

JamieDonaldson

..suggest the Hunter #5, and later when you're ready to hollow thru a smaller opening the Jordan hollowing tools in a Sorby armbrace handle. If you haven't had the opportunity to see a hollowing demo, that would be a great learning experience for you.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Hollowing Tools

Brad Vietje

Scott,

I haven't used the Hunter tools, but generally, I agree with what Jamie and Steve are telling you. I'd say the best tool depends on the size of the vessels you intend to make, the height of the piece (distance over the rest), and the size of the openings.

If you have the right tool and the right presentation, you shouldn't have to work too hard. If the cutter is working at or above center, with a slight downward angle, and never below center, you should be OK, even with really tough wood.

I tend to use hand-held John Jordan hollowers and Ellsworth style home-made tools for smaller openings, and a stabilized boring bar set-up like Lyle Jamieson's system for larger openings or tall vessels. I have adapters so I can use the JJ tools in the stabilized boring bar rig.

Generally, smaller tip sizes cut easier, but they can be harder to control. Wider tips cut smoother curves, but have a lot more cutting resistance due to their larger tip radius. Curved shank tools are always used with the rest supporting the straight part of the shaft,so the cutter is in-line with the handle; otherwise you're amplifying the torque and stress, and eventually going to the physical therapist for treatment (DAMHIKT).

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Hollowing Tools

#7

Re: Hollowing Tools

George Guadiane

I looked at the link you provided. The multi shaft thing seems less than ideal to me.

I prefer Rolly Munro articulated hollowers for two reasons:

With an extra link, I have been able to get into the depths of virtually every hollow form I have worked on, and generally through a one inch opening.

The articulation allows one to configure the shape of the hook from long and open to short and tight. ALMOST no area on the insides of hollow forms are inaccessible.

The cupped cutters shear cut when properly presented and work really well on end grain turnings (and fine on side grain turnings). The hood sometimes cause clogging, but clearing them isn't that difficult with practice. With that exception, the hood is a great help in controlling the depth of the cut and the torque of the tool when the tool is extended over the tool rest.

The cutters can be purchased in sharpenable HS Steel and carbide.

An other advantage (some think of it as cheating), is that this tool fits into the standard Monster articulated hollowing rig. I hollowed for quite some time without the Monster, and still do it from time to time (to keep up my chops), but I get remarkable results without a lot of stress on my body by using it.

I have no financial interest in either of these tools and offer this information as a user only.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hollowing Tools

Lyle Jamieson

Scott, use it before you buy it. I do have a bias but I want to give you something to think about. So far nobody has mentioned the laser measuring. You can not put a laser on a hand held boring bar. You can be in complete control of the wall thickness, control the bottom depth and shape inside, dont have to work hard, dont need a long learning curve, have twice the fun at half the time. People spend a lot of money on hand held tools before they purchase a captured system. Somebody in your club has my system and would be glad to give you a trial run.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#9

Re: Hollowing Tools

George Guadiane

I'm going to agree with Lyle, to a point:

The laser is a fantastic help, and it DOES shorten the learning curve, but that is not necessarily a good thing in my opinion. I go back to hand held, from time to time, just to keep my other senses sharper.

His system and the Monster I mentioned (and use with joy) both have lasers that make it difficult to mess up, but doing it by hand, learning to measure, to watch from the outside - getting an idea of how to imagine where the cutting head is based on practice and watching is another "tool" in my trick bag, in my thinking... Another value is learning to listen to the sound that the hollow form makes, as it gets thinner, and even that ticking sound we hear when the cutter goes through is important information. The more of our faculties that we can invest in the process, the better we'll be able to gauge our work.

I don't think that skill is just a matter of getting the desired result. I think experience, practice, learning from our mistakes all play a part in developing, not just success, but style.

Now if you want to talk about power sanding, I think doing that should be one of the first things that a new turner tries.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#10

I believe that learning to hollow........

JamieDonaldson

..should be first attempted without all the gadgets, making the process much more up close and personal. Once the process is understood, then production can certainly be enhanced with whatever toys the billfold will allow.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#11

Re: I believe that learning to hollow........

john lucas

I have to disagree with Jamie on this one. Although I think it's a good idea to learn to hollow by hand but if you don't have someone like John Jordan standing over your shoulder to tell you what your doing wrong it is a daunting and frustrating task. I remember it well because I learned on my own and distinctly remember blowing up vessels, cutting through the side and at one point thought I broke my wrist when one exploded. Learning to hollow by myself by hand was very frustrating.

On the other hand I put a brand new turner on my lathe with my Lyle Jamieson copy and lazer and said hollow this. The only instruction I gave him was to watch the lazer and to stop and blow out the shavings very often. He did it with no problems. It was pretty uneven on the inside and a little rough but more or less 3/8" thick through out. This was someone who could barely rough out spindle with a roughing gouge. He needed an urn but wanted to turn it himself. I did have to clean up the outside. He used a scraper to get it roughly to shape because we didn't have time to teach him to use a gouge.

The only problem he had was he kept hitting the lip when removing the tool so the hole got larger and larger which was fine in this case, we simply made the lid bigger.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#12

Barring Exigent Circumstances;

George Guadiane

While I understand that the circumstances you describe warranted the actions you took, I don't think that should necessarily set the standard.

I WOULD agree that having someone "at your shoulder" would be a great help, I don't think its absolutely necessary.

I'm sorry about your wrist. Without knowing the circumstances, its difficult to know how, or even IF you could have avoided it.

Don't misunderstand, I don't have anything against easy or safety, but that too can be learned incrementally.

I hurt myself along the way, and learned without instruction early on, but I thought I could figure out almost anything (WRONG).

I think that ruining a few (in my case, a bunch) of pieces of wood is a part of the learning curve. I also think (in hindsight) that having a mentor is vastly more important than having gadgets that make learning and experience less necessary.

I guess, I'm saying I would rather that we evolve as craftspeople, as "artists." Years ago, I had a CNC guy tell me that he could produce the same things I was making and at absolute tolerances, if I'd like. It just didn't feel right. I wanted to feel the process, know the steps, learn the skills, not just get the outcome.

I still feel like those are valid objectives and using all of the shortcuts before learning what we're taking shortcuts from feels less genuine to me.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#13

Much to do about.....

Gary Asbury

Folks, seems like alot of really deep controversies about these tools. A most impressive artisan friend years ago told me, "it's not the tools, it's the mechanic." I once witnessed a third-world turner doing beautiful furniture with a sharpened screwdriver. There is no magic tool, just alot of practice with what you have. Thanks

Re: Hollowing Tools

#14

Re: Barring Exigent Circumstances;

john lucas

George I understand the attitude toward hand held vs captured. There is this I'm an artist if I do it hand held but not if I do it captured, or for that matter CNC. I'm all about the final product and having fun and being safe. The captured bar systems are safe and relaxing to use so you can concentrate more on the form. It still takes technique to really smooth out the inside, kind of like learning to sharpen with a jig. The jig won't solve all the problems.

When I hurt my wrist I still don't know what happened. I had made maybe a dozen hollow forms with hand held tools. I was turning an 8" holly round hollow form and had it almost done. I went in to further thin it out (and is wasn't thin by todays standards at all) and either got some kind of catch or possibly the wood simply decided to go. I don't know. All I know is my wrist hurt like crazy and I actually thought it was broken for afew minutes.

I still hollow small pieces by hand but the captured bar system just makes it so much easier and enjoyable that I turn all the larger pieces that way.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#15

Re: Hollowing Tools

Scott Blundell

Thanks to all for the advice, encouragement and support. I'm a beginner and really feel like a captured system would make hollowing seem more like work and less like turning, but I will have to try it for myself. I also thought drilling a center hole and hollowing our from there was cheating from the viewpoint of a "real" turner (not that I have not done it).

I'll put on a new edge and sharpen my techbnique before I invest in any magic solutions.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#16

Re: I believe that learning to hollow........

Stuart Johnson

I agree with Jaimie. I had never had a real shop class or made a made a thing from wood that was fit for anything but firewood. I had watched hours of Norm and Roy so I did have the desire. I jumped at the chance to take some woodworking courses at Homestead Heritage down by Waco. After about 15 days I progressed from simple shelves and a small dovetailed box to a coffee table and rocking chair. All done with hand tools except the provided milled stock. Once you know how to do something by hand and understand the process it is time to mix in power (lasers and articulated hollowing) which ever is appropriate.

By the way, after the 15 days my skill level was about that of their 13 year old kids :) . If you go to SWAT try to get out to Homestead for a visit.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#17

None Of It Is "Cheating"

George Guadiane

At the end of the day, anything that works for you is fine.

When I first started going to turning club meetings, I was getting LOTS of dos and don'ts. The funny thing is many of them seemed diametrically opposed to each other. The drilling thing for instance, some thought it was cheating and others thought it was just more accurate, a better use of time.

In the end, a hollowing rig with a laser makes getting a good, predictable outcome. Its just that I feel, after having done it by hand first, you learn more hollowing by hand and then going on to using the other tools.

You don't want to find out the battery in your laser is dead at 7PM on Sunday when you have to deliver a piece on Monday afternoon and you want to get some finish on the inside, but you can't finish the inside, because you don't have the skill to do it without the laser...

OK, that was an extreme hypothetical.

Turning is a craft for me, an art form when taken to its logical extreme. If its just about getting to a product, use whatever tools you can afford, if its about learning a craft and creating, learn as much as you can and enjoy the journey.

By the way, I still use sharpened screwdrivers almost every time I turn, on close work, without a long hang over the tool rest, for details. They make inexpensive hardened steel blanks that I can shape to a particular purpose and reshape without worrying about cost. I buy them at garage sales, usually spend from $0.25 to $1.00 - the bigger the blade the better.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#18

You're An Artist!

George Guadiane

I don't think anyone would argue that statement, at your skill level, it doesn't matter what tools you use, you have mastered them. I think that's the point I was going for; Over time, with practice and at least a little instruction (which I resisted for a long time) one can master the flowing curve, the flawless finish, the uniform thickness things. A big part of the process (FOR ME) was the progression, and I learn more every day. At least some of that evolution comes from the actual time I spend in front of the lathe, another important part for me is the input I get from club meetings and hard but fair evaluations of the pieces I post on the board.

Using any captured system is definitely safer. Even if one learns all their is to know about safety, I don't think anyone would argue that getting out of the line of fire of exploding things is safer. I have been fortunate to not have had the kind of catch that you did, but I've had a few "exciting" experiences. I was lucky that I mostly learned from them rather than being hurt. That might be coloring my views on this.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#19

Steven Antonucci

Drill w/spindle gouge and you are still turning 

steven antonucci

Re: Hollowing Tools

#20

Re: None Of It Is "Cheating"

John Lucas

George I have 2 sharpened screw drivers that I have used for maybe 15 years. They are perfect when needed.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#21

To add to a captured system

Stephen Mushinski

There is no reason to beat up your body with hand held hollowing tools. I am not a very small guy with hands and wrists to match. Due to working most of my life with my hands my wrists and elbows are shot. They still work but if abused in the very least, me and ice packs become every good friends for days to weeks afterwards. I enjoy hollowing things but my body doesn't. I hope to still hollow things if I am lucky enough to be like Wally and be turning for 70 years. As with many others I first turned in grade 7 or 8 so I guess I have about 40 plus more years to go. :)

I am starting to learn being tuff doesn't have to include pain. :)

Re: Hollowing Tools

#22

Re: To add to a captured system

Doug Turner

I attended and all day seminar by Mike in Utah demonstrating his tools on some dried boxelder burl and he was complaining at the end of the demo about how hard the wood was. I have also used Lyle Jamisons capture system and you can control it with your finger tips even in dried burl or mesquite. Both can use the hunter tips and in Lyles system you can also use HSS cutters for the majority of the work.

I learned to hollow on the Stewart system from John Jordan when I was 25 years younger and turned dozens of large hollow forms with it (and it beat me up severely).

No one mentioned it, but you can consistently turn hollow forms with 1/16th inch thick walls with Lyles system which is useful for pierced work. Try that with a hand held system and see how many blow ups you have!!

Re: Hollowing Tools

#23

Re: Hollowing Tools

Charlie Drake

Might I suggest something a little different. Like you, I've looked at different hollowing tools and purchased a number looking for that "perfect" solution. A while back, I bought one of Jeff Nicol's (google search)modified drill bits and have been very pleased. I've modified the grind somewhat but at least for a rather unexperienced turner like me, it works very well and the price is right (I think I paid about $4). Good luck.

Re: Hollowing Tools

#24

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Hollowing Tools

Katherine Kowalski

Hi Scott,

From my experience, your statement should be reversed:

Hand-hollowing is a LOT of work. It beats up your body, and takes much longer to do. Furthermore, it is stressful, and can be frustrating.

Hollowing with a captured bar system is an absolute JOY. I have Lyle's system, and I have found it extremely relaxing, easy-to-use, controllable with the most delicate touch. I can create any shape with any wall thickness, and have never gone through the side, despite hollowing to 1-2mm wall thickness on many hollow forms.

And though you've seen everyone's opinions, I heartily encourage you to try both types out (at a symposium, or visit a friend), before you buy to see which matches your philosophy.

Katherine

Re: Hollowing Tools

#25

Re: Hollowing Tools

John Jordan

Captured systems can work well, and I have nothing against them, and in fact use Lyle's D handle from time to time on a large piece. They may be the best option for some. But I would take exception with the ideathat freehand hollowing beats one up. Rather, freehand hollowing done wrong may do that. I teach people all the time how to successfully do it freehand, and I wouldn't do it if it was physically hard. I'm hardly a macho brute. :D

Finesse and a light touch are always the way to go, and usually the solution to whatever problem one may be having. :)

John