Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Safety cage

Posts

Re: Safety cage

#26

Mike Stafford

I didn't know that....learn something every day.

Mike Stafford

Re: Safety cage

#27

A thick plexiglass

Jorge Casta�eda

bullet proof wall between you and the lathe, sensitive robotic arms so yo can do the turning. It may be the way of the future...

I'll stick to the old fashion way, just will do my best to be careful.

Re: Safety cage

#28

Mike Stafford

Re: A thick plexiglass

Mike Stafford

Many years ago I worked while in college as a machinist at a turbine components plant. I advanced in my skills to the point that I was trained to operate a 5 axis machine.

These machines were operated by computer paper tape with holes punched in it. The machine had a conveyor belt of tools and a mechanical arm that changed tools as needed. The operator had to set up the fixtures and monitor tool wear and make adjustments using compensators.

Every time a new part was to be machined with a new tape in control the operator, me, was expected to dry run the tape using a jog control to make sure there were no programming errors.

I was doing this and the first tool that was loaded into the machine was a massive "hog" mill about 3" in diameter and 12" long. Its purpose was to remove the bulk of the waste before switching to other tools for refinement.

Everything was going along fine as the fixture table moved toward the cutter when suddenly the fixture table lurched several inches into the hog mill. There was a loud explosion as the hog mill disintegrated and chunks of stainless steel were ripped out of the fixture.

It turned out the tape did contain a feed rate error and where the fixture table was supposed to be moving at 0.1 foot per minute the programmer had misplaced the decimal point and the table was actually moving at 1000 feet per minute. Even with jog control I was unable to react quickly enough to prevent the accident.

The point of this story is to tell what happened to the plexiglas shield that I was standing behind as I operated the controls. A section of the hog mill several inches long and roughly half the diameter went through the 1/2" plexiglas shield and embedded itself in the compensator panel. I didn't even know that it happened until after the event. It must have missed me by inches. Thank goodness I was wearing my safety glasses..... :b ;)

Re: Safety cage

#29

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Are you seroius?

Katherine Kowalski

LOL! I was specific that I wanted a force-field generator... though the USPS might be tempted to confiscate it as "hazardous" material!

Katherine

Re: Safety cage

#30

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Seriously? - LaForge?

Katherine Kowalski

Scotty's a good lad to be sure, but LaForge has actually *done* this before! Perhaps he could even make the forcefield sensitive enough to bend around the tools, so that if the piece blows up, there would not even be a scratch on one's fingers!

And it could have an automatic chip collector which would periodically beam the chips right out of a hollow form and into a collection area outside, (possibly even to the city compost heap).

And the new micro-abrasive pulse feature would have sanding done in no time!

Gosh, I'm really beginning to like the future. (If anyone up there is listening, BEAM ME UP!)

Make it so!

Katherine

P.S. Of course, this is just silliness... in the future, we will have tools that will "read" our minds, and do exactly what we want them to.... anyone remember the TNG episode about Aldea, and the young boy who "carved" a dolphin with a similar tool?

But it won't be as much fun...

Re: Safety cage

#31

I bet you also needed some clean pants!

JamieDonaldson

Re: Safety cage

#32

Keith Tompkins

Re: Safety cage

keith tompkins

You know Katherine....that's pretty funny. Perhaps you should email that to the lady lying in the hospital with a fractured skull.

By all accounts, she was a skilled, experienced, and cautious turner. I'll bet she never expected this to happen to her.

Thanks for such a sophomoric response.

Re: Safety cage

#33

Ouch!

Jim H

I don�t post alot but visit several times a day. One of the things I like about WC is the humor and personality that goes with the great advice.

I don�t believe that Katherine was making light of Joan or her injuries. Just using an old TV show as a wouldn�t be nice kind of thing.

I hope it is just the horrible nature of Joan�s accident that caused your response, as I have never noticed you post in such a sharp manner.

Re: Safety cage

#34

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Safety cage

Katherine Kowalski

Keith, I did not intend to be funny, perhaps you did not read my response as carefully as you might have. Let me reiterate from my original post:

I think the best option we have is education... teaching good turning techniques, grain direction and how to cut it, wood types and their individual characteristics, safety, etc.

My first priority in turning is safety. Perhaps my imagination got carried away, wishing and hoping that there would be a better solution on the horizon. (If we do not dream, how can we invent?)

Do not mistake my imagination for a lack of concern. I feel very deeply for the good lady who is in intensive care right now. I wish her all the best.

Sometimes accidents happen, but we can attempt to avoid them by educating ourselves, turning within safe limits, and using safe wood. Personally, my lathe doesn't have a safety cage. Thus, I don't have the option that others do. My best option is safe operation. (If you've read the other topics, as I have, it appears that "experienced" people are not immune... in fact, are at risk just as much as amateurs). Accidents happen.

And though I do not know this lady personally, I wish her a speedy recovery. She's in my thoughts -- both in a healing prayer... and every day since when I've stepped up to the lathe. I make damn sure my turning is safe.

Please read more carefully before you accuse me of being heartless. My friends will testify to the exact opposite. Please get to know me better before you pass judgement.

Katherine

Re: Safety cage

#35

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Safety cage

Katherine Kowalski

Keith,

One other note: I, personally, (an experienced, professional turner), have had my own share of accidents.

Once, I was turning a crochet hook and working too close to the chuck. My gouge hit the jaws and went straight for my eye. If I had not been wearing safety glasses, I would have been blinded.

It scared the living daylights out of me, and I couldn't turn for at least two weeks, and then very gingerly at that.

I would never make light or fun of someone's injuries, ever.

Thanks,

Katherine

Re: Safety cage

#36

Re: I bet you also needed some clean pants!

Bart Leetch

No the ones he was wearing were brown.

Re: Safety cage

#37

Keith Tompkins

Re: Safety cage

keith tompkins

Katherine, My intention was not to imply or accuse. Nobody wants to see a terrible accident. I don't believe you are making light the accident that happened , but I don't believe you took my post too seriously. I was asking a simple question.."Do you use the shield that came with your Powermatic? How could it be improved?" The fact is, if Joan was using a shield similar to the one that comes standard on PM machines, she would not have been hurt. The current shield obviously has many flaws, otherwise many more turners would use the thing, rather than toss it into a corner. Another truth is that on a side-grain orientation bowl, the tenon can snap off unexpectedly, as the wood is at its weakest possible orientation. It can happen to anybody...including myself. We've all heard of or seen pieces explode for no apparent reason. I'm a bit of an inventor....I've long considered ways to make the lathe a safer machine...anything that can deflect a flying bowl, absorbing some of the energy before it hits someone in the face cannot be a bad thing. There are THOUSANDS of newbie turners out there, just a few who we've seen on YouTube. How many injuries could be avoided with a few simple precautions? BTW, I too consider myself a professional. Over the last 40 years, as a shop supervisor or owner, I've trained or been responsible for scores of woodworkers. I currently serve as an Industrial Training Supervisor for the State of New York, where I am legally responsible for training inmates in a modern woodworking facility to re-enter the workforce as fully trained professional woodworkers. I have to go through hours of training each year, and comply will all OSHA regulations and fill out all required paperwork. Occasionally, I am required to testify in court as an expert in my field on behalf of the state. I consider myself a funny guy, but not when it comes to workplace safety. Many accidents I've seen over the years were completely preventable..a worker wearing gloves on a drill-press had his thumb peeled back all the way to his elbow when the glove got entangled in the bit. A friend and co-worker who had his head split open when he looked into a rough-mill planer because the board had stopped. Another who felt the guard on a 20" jointer was unnecessary until he lost his left hand. I think you get the idea. So, yea, I got a little upset when my questions were taken lightly. for that, I'm sorry. I'm sure you are a most gracious person, and excellent turner.

Re: Safety cage

#38

Steven Antonucci

Two thoughts from two walks of life

steven antonucci

Keith-

I have never seen a safety cage installed on a lathe anywhere but a showroom floor or a catalog photo. I think that everyone agrees that safety is a common goal, but the cage creates as many problems as it solves.

I like the idea of having a "catcher's mask" with some safety goggles under it. When I was in college, we had a floor hockey team that I was on. Having never played floor hockey, I volunteered to be the goalie. We had a "Jason" style mask that had two little eyeslits. About half way through the first half, one of the forwards wound up a hard slapshot that I saw, then lost as it got closer. You guessed it. It hit me right in the mask and I would liken it to being slapped very hard.

The next game, I debated not wearing any mask, figuring that I could get a glove up if I could see it. Someone suggested a lacrosse helmet because the faceguard didn't have any blind spots , and it wasn't pressed right up against my face. Inevitably, when I took another headshot, it wasn't anywhere near as violent because the mask was engineered to direct the force AROUND my head, not through it.

So, when I was turning and the bowl blew apart many years ago, I was very grateful to have a face shield on, since it distributed the slap, but it was merely dumb luck that the bowl didn't hit me square in the face (it was a glancing blow...)

Perhaps a chainsaw mask is a better starting point than a thin faceshield...?

S

Re: Safety cage

#39

I was just going to leave this alone but...

Toney Robertson

I can't.

What a jerk response.

Katherine gave you the perfect protection scenario all be it a little tongue in cheek and then proceeded to give a thoughtful and reasoned reply to your question based in today's technology. Like she implied and I will state more plainly, maybe it is your reading comprehension that should be called into question. NO WHERE did she make light of the unfortunate accident that Joan had. That is why they call them accidents - an unforeseen event.

And to top it off, after calling her post sophomoric you have enough guts to state "Katherine, My intention was not to imply or accuse." EXACTLY what was your intention with the "sophomoric" comment if not to "imply or accuse"?

And you follow that gem up with "I don't believe you are making light the accident that happened". Really? Want to explain "You know Katherine....that's pretty funny. Perhaps you should email that to the lady lying in the hospital with a fractured skull."?

And last but not least, "I was asking a simple question.."Do you use the shield that came with your Powermatic? How could it be improved?" and she gave you a simple answer "Of course, practically speaking, it would be quite a difficult thing to design any contraption to hold the piece and allow sufficient access/view to the form.". Or did you just not read that far?

I personally think you own her a public apology.

Re: Safety cage

#40

Keith Tompkins

Re: I was just going to leave this alone but...

keith tompkins

I usually try to avoid conflict and controversy, but this time it looks like I'm the one who started it. I misinterpreted Katherine's post, and responded pretty harshly. For that, I'm sorry. I should have stepped away and collected my thoughts before I posted. Katherine, I'm truly sorry; you didn't deserve that. Toni, yes, I can be a jerk. Sometimes I need to be reminded of that.

Re: Safety cage

#41

"yes, I can be a jerk."

Toney Robertson

Everyone has faults.

You acknowledged your harshness and apologized for it.

I respect that.

Re: Safety cage

#42

Re: Safety mask/helmet

Carole Valentine

I have yet to see one of the cage type guards actually used. On the other hand, I have heard somewhere of someone wearing the Stihl chainsawing helmet/mask when turning. Have never seen one in person so I don't know how effective it would be in stopping a flying chunk of bowl, or whether or not it would affect vision.

Re: Safety cage

#43

Re: Safety mask/helmet

John Lucas

A turner in Birmingham who had been hit hard by a blown up bowl started using a baseball helmut and added one of the lexan police riot facemasks to it. That thing will stop anything and is comfortable. Still has the dirty faceshield problem especially if it's wet wood.

I think something like a catchers mask with a fine wire mesh behind it to keep out the small dust and chunks. Then put a clear replaceable shield where the eye cutout would be.

Or we could all go around looking like Jason with the Hockey mask.

I think I'll go along with Katherine and start dressing like Darth Vader.

Re: Safety cage

#44

Katherine Kowalski

Re: I was just going to leave this alone but...

Katherine Kowalski

Thanks, Keith.

Katherine