Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

What did you learn from ...

Posts

What did you learn from ...

#1

What did you learn from ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

the metallurgy thread?

I came away with two dominant thoughts.

1. M42 steel is different from A11/V10. Most notably, it is a little harder.

2. After sharpening, the sharpness of the tool has more to do with the wheel one used than the particular metal of the tool.

Some secondary thoughts emerged as well.

1. It is possible to have an exchange of ideas on WC without allowing emotions to have a track meet and run wild.

2. The woodturning world is fortunate to have (in alphabetical order) Paulo Marin, Dave Schweitzer, and Doug Thompson producing the best tools they can for us. I appreciate each of them and I wish them each the absolute best.

3. Mike Stafford needs to buy more tools in order to reduce his deep-seated problem with tool envy. Mike is very generous to others, but he has a hard time being generous to himself.

And I thank each person who contributed to the thread. There was a lot of meat to chew on.

Ed

Re: What did you learn from ...

#2

Re: What did you learn from ...

Bill Neddow

Thanks, Ed. This is a good summary.

I am glad the old theory about being able to get high-carbon or M2 steel sharper than the newer steels is getting put to rest. I could never see a difference, myself. I now sharpen with a 180 grit wheel, because I use the newer steels almost exclusively and find they are tough enough to keep the finer edge.

Toughness makes the difference -- it keeps the tool sharper longer. And both CPM10/V11 and M42 are tough steels.

Re: What did you learn from ...

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: What did you learn from ...

Mike Stafford

Every time I read a discussion on tool metallurgy and manufacturing I learn something. I thought that the grit of the sharpening stone had as much to do with the tool's sharpness as anything. I mean, if you sharpen the same tool on a 60 grit wheel and then sharpen it on a 120 grit wheel there would be a noticeable difference in the edge. I am always amazed at how many things I know absolutely nothing about and have decided that I know nothing about anything.... :(

However, I have done so much with so little I am now qualified to do anything with nothing....

The one thing of which I am absolutely positive is that tool manufacturers Paulo Marin, Dave Schweitzer and Doug Thompson all know Ed Moore's credit card numbers by heart..... :D

Re: What did you learn from ...

#4

Steven Antonucci

I learned it doesn't matter what steel it is

steven antonucci

and that marketing the subtle differences in properties is the thing that matters. :b

If the edge is sharp (or sharper), and it's presented properly, it's going to cut. If you can't remember the last time you sharpened, it's time to sharpen again.

Finally, folks are beginning to realize that a Tormek will make your expensive tooling sharper than a 120 grit wheel will because it can be graded to 1000 grit... (a familair old coversation, no?)

Steve

Re: What did you learn from ...

#5

Re: I learned it doesn't matter what steel it is

John Lucas

I learned that Ed and Mike can crack me up even on a bad day. :) I also learned that I will produce the work I do no matter what tools I get. That being said I'm somewhere between Mike and Ed on the tool aquisition ladder.

Re: What did you learn from ...

#6

Re: I learned it doesn't matter what steel it is

Steve Criscenzo

I learned that there is much that I do not know about tool steel but it does not really matter that much to me. Good sharpening habits and turning technique are more important as long as we use quality tools.

I also learned that Steve A and I both were playing with bikes in north Jersey in our youth.

Great discussion folks. It was refreshing.

Steve

Re: What did you learn from ...

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: What did you learn from ...

Steve Kubien

Honestly, not much. Lots of great info to be had, no doubt. I am not a metals-guy. Personally I really don't care of the steel is powdered metal, tool steel, laser guided or it comes with breath mints on the side. What I do know is that I love the tools I have and the service I get from the manufacturer (you know who you are). I have no reason to switch or even try something else right now.

Well you asked....

Re: What did you learn from ...

#8

Re: What did you learn from ...

Brian McInturff

I learned that we are very fortunate to have this group and the wealth of information the people of this group are so happy to share. Well, I've known that for a long time but it was re-affirmed.

Re: What did you learn from ...

#9

One more thing ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

that has been etched in my mind by the thread and a super conversation today with Dr Jerry Wright, metallurgist, is that you need a grinding wheel of sufficient quality (Norton SG wheels, for example) to cut the A11 or 10v steel. What does this mean? It means that if you bought a Doug Thompson or Glaser bowl gouge and it didn't seem to sharpen to an edge that you liked, the culprit may be your grinding wheel. It needs to be a wheel that will cut the high-grade steel and be dressed so that the wheel is sharp.

A consequence of this new knowledge may be that I take my grinder to JCCFS when I teach there in three weeks. This grinder has a Norton SG wheel. I will also spend some time sharing this new-found knowledge with the class. :) :)

Ed

Re: What did you learn from ...

#10

Re: One more thing ...

john lucas

Ed I have white aluminum oxide wheels that i purchased at a metal supply house. I think it was Enco. They seem to cut fine on the Thompson tools. They are 100 grit. I do final sharpen my skew with diamond hones but everything else is done with the 100 grit wheels.

Re: What did you learn from ...

#11

Re: One more thing ...

John Jordan

The powdered metal tools are much easier to grind-that's a major reason for the PM steels. Ease of grinding= more production time in industry (not woodturning). Grind a Sorby or similar from a rough to finish shape and do the same to one of Doug's or the other PM tools. The PM will grind much easier as the alloying metals are no longer in (relatively) big chunks as in regular HSS. Once a tool has the shape one wants, this doesn't really matter.

In my experience, the PM tools grind about as well on a cheap white wheel as they do on the more expensive SG wheels. I use both for different reasons, but have no preference for sharpening gouges etc. The grit of the wheel makes more difference to me, 60-80 being my preference.

Hardness is a function of the heat treating process, not the steel. All the steels can be hardened beyond usefulness to us.

John

Re: What did you learn from ...

#12

Re: What did you learn from ...

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

I learned theres allot of knowledge on this forum and everyone has their own.It's the same with everything it's good to get the info we need to make the decisions on how we fell we should do things.

I started using Norton SG Ceramic wheels a couple months ago.I have about 12 of Doug's tools and I found to ME that the SG wheels seem to shape and sharpen the tools faster and better then my AO wheels did.I also hone my tools with 600 grit Diamond which I believe does help the edge.

The thing I don't get is why no one ever talks about shape, I've always thought if the shape isn't right the sharpness isn't going to help.

To everyone that contributed I Thank you,The knowledge base here is unbelievable and the sharing is also.

Re: What did you learn from ...

#13

Re: Once again, its in the details

Steve Criscenzo

I use mostly Doug's gouges and like John I do not see much difference in wheels. (Assuming of course that the wheel is of the proper grit and of some basic quality.) What I have found to be much more important is to have the wheel balanced, running true, and properly dressed. I started using Don Geiger's dressing tool a couple of years ago and it made a huge difference on the quality of the edge. (It also minimizes that steel loss and heat generated while grinding.)

For me, having a simple, and efficient sharpening method is the key. As soon as I sense I have lost an edge, I resharpen. It takes but a minute and I am never forcing a dull tool. I use gouges right off the grinder except for the "last pass" on tough grain where I may swipe it with a diamond hone.

Steve

Re: What did you learn from ...

#14

Don Geiger

Re: Once again, its in the details

Don Geiger

Hi Steve:

I'm glad the wheel dresser worked well for you. You should check out my Vertical Solution sharpening system if you want very repeatable results. I've had literally hundreds of people report back to me that it does just that for them. I make two models; one for 6" and 8" grinders and one that switches back and forth from a Tormek and 6" or 8" grinders.

Don