What did you learn from ...
Ed Moore in SW VA
the metallurgy thread?
I came away with two dominant thoughts.
1. M42 steel is different from A11/V10. Most notably, it is a little harder.
2. After sharpening, the sharpness of the tool has more to do with the wheel one used than the particular metal of the tool.
Some secondary thoughts emerged as well.
1. It is possible to have an exchange of ideas on WC without allowing emotions to have a track meet and run wild.
2. The woodturning world is fortunate to have (in alphabetical order) Paulo Marin, Dave Schweitzer, and Doug Thompson producing the best tools they can for us. I appreciate each of them and I wish them each the absolute best.
3. Mike Stafford needs to buy more tools in order to reduce his deep-seated problem with tool envy. Mike is very generous to others, but he has a hard time being generous to himself.
And I thank each person who contributed to the thread. There was a lot of meat to chew on.
Ed



I also learned that I will produce the work I do no matter what tools I get. That being said I'm somewhere between Mike and Ed on the tool aquisition ladder.


