..likely due to heat treatment for hardening. I have 2 P&N gouges that are soft on the tang, and the entire lengths of the flutes are obviously harder than the tang. There is also an obvious variation in color along the tool shafts as a result of the heat treatments used on the cutting ends.
Are you sure the angles on both tools are the same. Since the flutes are often ground differently this would affect the angle when grinding the outside. The nose to flute angle could be the same but as you rotate around using part of the wing the different grind could easily fell different.
Exact same profile, same jig, same grinder wheel. I was grinding all my gouges the same swept back then. I always hold my tools pretty much level, and never could get the hang of the dropped handle method.
I'm not a metallurgist either. Nor do I play one on TV. I have read a few metallurgy texts.
I used to have a photomicrograph that showed an edge that had carbides pulled from the steel matrix. So my understanding is for any steel that forms large carbides with a edge angle that creates a sufficiently small angle that the carbides aren't adequately held in place the carbides can be pulled for the matrix when sharpening regardless of the abrasive. Therefore in some cases alloy does make a difference. How you sharpen your tools may be such that alloy differences may never been seen but alloy can affect the sharpness of the edge.
Different brands have different flute shape. On the tight radius flute, the width of the cut is narrower. It would require less effort to have the same depth of cut. Just as the U & V gouges can't have the same grind even every setting is equal.
Perhaps there will be a Damascus bowl gouge forthcoming?...
My son is pursuing his Masters in mechanical engineering. His research is into "friction stir welding". He says that previous research has demonstrated that friction stir processing makes a knife's edge last several times longer than an untreated edge. IIRC, he said that they took a custom knife maker's best blade (with his active participation) and tested it by cutting through inch thick hemp rope. After 10 or so cuts through the rope, the knife was dull. Then, they treated the edge with friction stir processing. After more than 100 cuts through the rope, the knife was still as sharp as new. That research led to the formation of a new custom knife company, DiamondBlade Knives.
Perhaps we should see how one of Doug's bowl gouges respond to friction stir processing.
It would be more accurate to say that it's easier to get M2 to scary sharp then it is to get A11/V-10 or M42, just as it's easier to get HCS scary sharp then M2.
I say this as a result of a chat I had with a (former) co-worker that has his Master in materials (metal) and the fine articles that have appeared in the American Woodturner.
I wonder if Mike was using a CBN wheel what he would find?
Many years ago in my college days, I worked in a bicycle shop that served the bicycle racing crowd. I learned a few life lessons during that time that are relevant here.
At times a racer would come into the shop to buy the latest high dollar item with the hope it would help him ride faster and win races. Usually it was some item that saved a few grams of weight. I would often ask how much he was loosing the race by and the answer was almost always not tenths of seconds but instead many minutes. I would sometimes point out that saving
10 grams in an expensive seat post would not help him win races.
I do not turn for a living. Before I can appreciate the subtle differences in tool steel, I need more practice and more consistent technique. Even then, I try not to be swept away with marketing hype to get the latest and greatest new twist on a gouge in the hope it will make me a better turner. What will make me a better artist is practice and good mentoring.
To be clear, I am sure some folks can tell the difference. My point is that for me, my focus is on things that can have a greater impact on my work. ( I sure have learned a lot in this thread though.)
While I may not have been able to agree with Mark about much over the last year I do agree on his statement above 100% and I'm copying it again here.
Ed,
I can tell you that this urban myth about which alloy will take the sharpest edge is pure bunk.
"Huh?" you say.
The crystalline structure of any particular alloy at the molecular level, often sited by would-be experts on this topic is irrelevant for turners. If you grind an A11, V12, HOZ9 with cobalt, or a nail pulled from your great granddaddy's barn door on the same 100 (or 220 or 600 or 2000) grit wheel, you will get virtually the same edge on each alloy. The sharpness of the edge is determined by the size of the abrasive,not the alloy of the damn metal. One alloy may be more resistant to wear and heat than another, so the sharp edge will last longer, but that's it.
Now, if you're planning on sharpening your tools down to a fineness that's commensurate with the molecular structure of a particular steel, it's a different story. It'll also be a raging cost for the equipment to do it and a monumental waste of your time.
I work mostly with Doug's tools and most of the time they are just fine, but in certain woods, I revert to my M2 tools for the final cut. Same grind. I must be lazy, I grind all my gouges with the same jig, same settings. The only noticeable difference is that the M2 tools, are my "comfort zone" as they were with me several years before Doug's and they are noticeably shorter, I did learn to grind on those...
There is always something new -- that is what keeps woodturning fascinating!
Of course,like all things "new" to us, this has been around for a while -- since 1991. There are some excellent articles on it if you google the technique.
I've posed this very question to several metallurgists, one also a turner and master machinist, over the years and the answer has always come back that at the grit sizes that we use "every edge that leaves the same wheel will be the same." Will one alloy ultimately take a finer edge than another? Yes, at the level of the crystalline/molecular structure of the alloy, grain size will make a difference. But at the size of abrasives turners use, it's irrelevant.
Most of us actually still use old tools. I have 2 old carbon steel craftsman tools that are my go to tools for certain applications. It is definitely more about how you use them than what they are.
Now if you could just tell me how to ride up that big hill that kicks my butt every year I would greatly appreciate it. I was on a 100 mile ride one time and very large hill was killing me. I decided I needed to lose weight on my bike so I drank the water in my bottle which of course emptied it and made it lighter. It was a long hard ride.
According to Stuart Batty, the heat treating to harden the business end of the tool usually ends before the end of the flute. The tool shank needs to be softer to take the pounding. He said that if you are using the flute all of the way to the end, on most tools, you are using softer steel.
Having said that, I find that the really short tools are less functional anyway, so I quit using them before the tool gets that sharp.
I have no science back ground so can't explain or fully comprehend all the science between the different steels. I can explain that some tools feel different when they cut than others. My one remaining HSS gouge does go through the wood with less effort and leave a slightly cleaner surface, especially on more difficult woods. Measurable differences? Probably not. But, if you use one gouge for 100 or more bowls, then switch to another one that is a different steel, and of course the same wood, you will notice a difference. When a production turner like Mike says there is a difference, I believe it, even if science can't explain it.
As for the CBN wheels, I can't really say that there is a cutting difference because of a finer edge, but the wheels last forever. I think I remember reading that it may look smoother than a comparable grit aluminum oxide wheel, but a microscopic picture shows the difference is almost non existent.
I didn't say it was relevant to turners. I even stated that any differences in sharpness due to alloy may never be seen. But your post that I responded to implied that in no case would alloy ever make a difference. And while that may be the case for turners, it isn't an absolute. I used to have a photomicrograph of a D2 knife edge that the large carbides were such that they were removed at the edge at that fine of a sharpening angle. It was an angle that a carbon steel knife would hold. In this specific case alloy made a difference.
I have no problems with the statement "For turners, alloy doesn't make a difference in sharpness" but I do have a problem with "The sharpness of the edge is determined by the size of the abrasive,not the alloy of the damn metal." As the latter implies an absolute that just isn't always the case.
The answer to your question is easy. Go back a few years to when Craft Supply introduced the Hamlets to the US market - I believe the graphic in the catalog was 7.5 times longer lasting. "Just as Mike". :-) Of course, your mileage may vary.
This is a great thread. Confession: I'm an engineer who loved my materials and metalurgy classes.
I demonstrate at the San Diego County Fair every year and the hand tool neanderthals are 20 feet away. I always make this comparison:
if a production woodturner is making a 3" diameter baluster at 3000 rpm, their tool tip will go through a mile of wood in about 2 minutes - knots, bark and all. The wood plane guy, pushing his or her jack plane 20 times a minute for 2 feet per stroke would take close to 2-1/2 hours to go one mile through the wood. If you have ever hand-planed, only Popeye has the arms to hand-plane for that long continuously. And, think of the heat we generate at the tip.
Moral of the story is that we have to sharpen OFTEN.
I raced for the Ramapo Valley Cycle mountain bike team out of Oakland. Bob (forget his last name) was kind of the local NORBA guy in the early 90's.
I do remember being passed (lapped) by Jan Weijak, a Polish cyclocross champion who raced one category higher than I did. I heard "TRACK", felt the whoosh as he blew past me on the downhill, and never saw him again...
We were almost neighbors. I managed Ridgewood Cycle in the late 70s. Trained with the racers but did not race. Used to ride from Ridgewood to West Point on Sunday mornings just for fun.
That's fine Ron. In fact, I said exactly that in the second paragraph of my post, to wit:
"Now, if you're planning on sharpening your tools down to a fineness that's commensurate with the molecular structure of a particular steel, it's a different story. It'll also be a raging cost for the equipment to do it and a monumental waste of your time."
Are we on the same page now (I hope)?
This is a turning forum, so I expect stuff posted here to be in some relation to turning, and I expect what I write to be interpreted in that same context. I wasn't making a blanket statement about metallurgy, but rather responding to Ed's question pertaining to his turning tools. Were I being so literal as you seem to have taken me, I certainly wouldn't have referenced "HOZ9 with cobalt" since there is, that I've ever heard of, no such alloy, it being I term that I just made up.
I would chase the Central Park crowd on weekends, riding over the GWB- sprinting through Harlem- and then into the park. Once I bought a mountain bike, I was pretty much done on the roads. No cars, no doors, no potholes...
It's been 20 years since I ridden seriously, and the last time I went out for a ride, I was so slow it was embarassing. I also tend to drive somewhere with the bike in the back of the truck before I ride...
S
P.S. Tried to ride to Bear Mountain a couple of times, but never quiet got that far north...