Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Metallurgy questions

Posts

Metallurgy questions

#1

Metallurgy questions

Ed Moore in SW VA

Folks, I am interested in facts, and hope to avoid a peeing contest.

Questions:

1. Is A11 steel the same as CPM 10V? Is some A11 steel actually 9V?

2. How does M42 steel compare to A11 or CPM 10V? Which takes the sharpest edge?

3. Is the steel that takes the sharpest edge (maybe not A11 nor CPM 10V nor M42) possibly too brittle to be a good woodturning tool steel?

TIA,

Ed

Re: Metallurgy questions

#2

Re: Metallurgy questions

Ralph Lindberg

Ed

A complex question with with no simple clear answer

Hardness, toughness, wear resistance and probably a dozen other factors figure into how well suited any particular alloy is to being used for a turning chisel.

I seriously doubt, that in a true blind test any of us could tell the difference between any of those three steels.

But yes, there are steels are would be too tough, too hard, etc, to make a good turning chisel

Re: Metallurgy questions

#3

Not A Metallurgist

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Don't sleep in a Holiday Inn Express [if I can help it]

But

Ed,

I can tell you that this urban myth about which alloy will take the sharpest edge is pure bunk.

"Huh?" you say.

The crystalline structure of any particular alloy at the molecular level, often sited by would-be experts on this topic is irrelevant for turners. If you grind an A11, V12, HOZ9 with cobalt, or a nail pulled from your great granddaddy's barn door on the same 100 (or 220 or 600 or 2000) grit wheel, you will get virtually the same edge on each alloy. The sharpness of the edge is determined by the size of the abrasive,not the alloy of the damn metal. One alloy may be more resistant to wear and heat than another, so the sharp edge will last longer, but that's it.

Now, if you're planning on sharpening your tools down to a fineness that's commensurate with the molecular structure of a particular steel, it's a different story. It'll also be a raging cost for the equipment to do it and a monumental waste of your time.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#4

Re: Metallurgy questions *LINK*

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Ed, to keep it simple.

A11 is the common name for Crucible's Powder Metallurgy CPM 10V It's the same metal just a different name.

A11 gets the wear resistence from the Vanadium content, at 10% that's high and the reason it's a powder metal.

M42 gets any wear resistance from the hardness of the steel instead of the element Vanadium.

A few years ago (AAW mag.) Al Laser proved any steel sharpened with the same method was just as sharp.

Knock yourself out... everything is here and more :D


Steel data sheets

Re: Metallurgy questions

#5

Re: Metallurgy questions

Bill Neddow

Doug, I have looked 8 years for an understandable and reliable comparison like this. Thank You!

Re: Metallurgy questions

#6

Thank you each for your responses.

Ed Moore in SW VA

In looking at the bar charts for the different steels on the link that Doug provided it would seem that M42 and A11 might perform differently as turning tools. But, the differences might be too subtle for a woodturner like me to detect in normal use.

For some reason I find that there are detectable differences in the spindle roughing gouges that I have. Each is sharpened at the same angle on the same wheel and they are the same size (diameter). Some just seem to stay sharp much longer than others. I turn ornament icicles from purpleheart and this is where I get my "data". When I switch to spindle or detail gouges after rounding and shaping the blank, the steel that underperformed as an SRG does absolutely fine for the detail work. Maybe I am looking for consistency of performance where none is available. :D :D

In the grinding thread my good friend Mike Stafford accused me of buying a new tool when one gets dull. I am going to get him for that!

What steel does P&N and Ashley-Iles use for their tools?

More than one flavor of ice cream always confuses me. :D :D

Ed

Re: Metallurgy questions

#7

Re: Metallurgy questions

john lucas

I'm certainly no expert either although I try to keep up with what is going on. As was mentioned above any steel that turning tools are made of can be sharpened to the same degree. I have done this test with 3 skews, a carbon steel, High speed steel and A11 steel. I was able to get each one of them sharper than needed to shave hair. I'm talking seriously sharp using sandpaper up to 1500 grit and then strop.

The difference for our purposes seems to be toughness, and I'm probably not using the right term here That's where Cryogenics and Vanadium come in. I have not seen any real evidence on Cryogenics making a tool tougher although according to the experts it helps take all the possible carbides in the steel and changes them where some might have been missed by less than perfect hardening. I first found out about it making metal tougher from a friend who was a NASCAR mechanic. He said they started using it years ago because it made parts wear longer. He is a turner and still couldn't prove it helped edge retention.

Vanadium seems to make metal hold an edge better. However you can only get so much into the metal by melting it. That's where Particle metal comes in. Using this method they can get much more Vanadium in the steel which in theory makes it hold an edge better. I proved this one day while turning a bunch of aluminum for a friend. The V11 Thompson tools would turn a whole piece without sharpening. I would go through anywhere from 2 to 4 of my HSS tools to do the same task. There's still arguments about whether it holds a fine edge like a freshly sharpened tool any longer than HSS. It's such a subjective thing and I haven't been able to prove it at home.

I think the book is still out on V15. V15 has more Vanadium than V11. Some say it's great and few other who have used the tools say that the edge chips. I don't know and there aren't enough tools out there yet to get a good comparison. Stewart Batty had a V15 negative rake scraper and said it hold an edge longer than V11. However he was talking about tool that holds an edge for 15 to 30 seconds. Don't know where that leaves us when talking about a sharpened edge rather than a burr.

With enough searching you can find out what the difference in the actual metal make up is. My memory is not good enough to quote those which is why I didn't put any numbers in here. I know that doesn't really answer your question but I hope it helps and I hope I don't have any of my statements wrong.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#8

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Peace :D

BTW, Ed, how're you feeling? Memsab has your box sitting next to Jake Brubaker's saffron jar.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#9

Steven Antonucci

Answer to #3...yes.

steven antonucci

Think razor blades. They snap because they are so brittle, but hold a shaving edge. Most turners think that their tools are sharp, but like Mark mentioned, a 100 grit wheel isn't very fine.

If you have ever used a large hand plane with a 2"+ edge to plane a curl board to 0.00015", you know that A2 can be made much, much sharper than any turner has ever attempted. We may make our skews sharp enough to take a hair, but that's about it.

The real questions in the various steels is wear toughness. The edge degrades the second it touches wood and how long it goes from sharp to useless is where the compromises are. Japanese swordsmiths needed to made and edge that accomplished both sharpness and durability, and to my knowledge, did it by pattern welding only carbon steels together.

Perhaps there will be a Damascus bowl gouge forthcoming? Where is my forge...?

S

Re: Metallurgy questions

#10

Re: PS

Ed Moore in SW VA

Hi Mark,

I am feeling pretty good. Each day my energy level seems to improve by a small increment. The initial reassessment following my treatment is quite encouraging. The cytology showed no cancer cells and I am told that this test is a good indicator. In mid-June I will be checked out again. It has been quite a ride. Hopefully this chapter is over - and when I realize that I had an aggressive form of bladder cancer and I still have my original plumbing and the cancer is gone - that is INCREDIBLE! I choose to give credit to God who worked through a super team of doctors to do this.

Now to get ready for John C Campbell Folk School and go teach Ornaments starting May 22.

Thanks for asking, and the best to you, Mark. I hope that the box still pleases you and "Memsaab".

Ed

Re: Metallurgy questions

#11

Mike Stafford

The truth hurts...

Mike Stafford

I think the reason that Professor Moore is making an inquiry about the different grades of steel is so that he can make sure that he has one of every tool (plus 5 backups) in every grade of steel including pig iron.

Back in 2008 before the AAW Symposium Ed was hosting Richard Raffan and me at his house. He took us on a tour of his shop. Tragedy was narrowly averted during this tour due only to the cat like reflexes Richard and I possess. Ed has his tools stored in heavy wooden boxes which are large enough to hold 50 tools each. Each box holds a different tool type; bowl gouges, spindle gouges, skew chisels and so on. These boxes are mounted in an A-frame arrangement built from timbers like those you would see in a timber frame for a barn in such a manner that the boxes can be slid out like drawers to select a tool. Ed was showing Richard and I this arrangement and I suppose he had too many drawers pulled out and the A-frame became unbalanced and a tool avalanche occurred. A tool avalanche happens very infrequently in nature so I doubt many of you have experienced the abject fear of having thousands of sharp (and blunt) pointy objects cascading at you at the speed of gravity. Fortunately Richard and I survived without injury and spent the next 6 hours helping Ed pick up tools.

I have it on good authority that the situation has worsened as Bob Rosand reports that Ed now stops at every hardware store he passes in hopes that it might contain a woodturning tool to add to his collection.

I offer as proof of this incident a picture of Richard and I taking shelter behind Ed's American Beauty....and another of Professor Moore.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#12

Re: The truth hurts...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Professor Moore has that need to know that doesn't stop. Start from the other end, the tool is dull when the cutting edge wears away and the radius is to large to cut wood and yes the cutting edge is a radius... think about it. What angle holds up the best for our application 30,40, 50, 60, 70 degrees?

Those charts are mind numbing... :O

Re: Metallurgy questions

#13

Mike, as a writer of hysterical fiction ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

you should go far. Unfortunately, I do enjoy using excellent sharp tools and since the manufacturers prefer that I pay for them the family Finance Minister, aka SWMBO, has threatened me with bodily harm if I purchase any more tools. :D :D

It is hard to find a bedan with a trapezoidal cross-section made from good steel. I use my Sorby bedan quite a bit and I confess that the Glaser 1/2" bedan is acting like a magnet to me. I am trying to resist the urge, but I don't know how long that will last. :D :D

BTW Mike, I appreciate you editing your post and adding the "s" to "tool".

Ed

Re: Metallurgy questions

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Answer to #3...yes.

Dick Hines

I here that Ed is a charter member of THO...........Tool Horders Anonymous

Re: Metallurgy questions

#15

Richard Allen

Re: Metallurgy questions

Richard Allen

There is more to a turning tool than the steel it is made out of. There is hardening, tempering, steel finish, grind, polish, balance, flute shape, flute length...

The steel composition question supposes "all things being equal". All things are not equal in the turning tools available. For example how the surface of the flute is treated is important because the flute surface is half the cutting edge.

Customer service is also important. If something slips by you need good customer service. I have heard of and experienced good customer service with several different tool makers. I have heard of one bad experience of customer service. Even that bad experience was a little questionable. Was it the maker or the user. I am unaware of the customer service for most tool makers.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#16

Ed-after taking a class with .....

JamieDonaldson

JF Escoulen 2 yrs. ago, I was informed that those trapezoidal bedans are English bedans, and his favorite 1/2"square bedans are French, and of course are therefore far superior. So now you know another tool needed to add to your collection! ;)

Re: Metallurgy questions

#17

You are quite correct.

Ed Moore in SW VA

A mutual friend of ours, Don Riggs, has some beading tools that are not symmetric - meaning that the flute is not centered so that the "prong" on one side is longer than on the other. Not good.

I know that D-Way Tools goes to a lot of effort to polish the flutes.

I also wonder if A11 steel purchased from Company A is the same as A11 steel purchased from Company B. And then the tool makers get involved.

It may not be realized by some, but as purchasers we seek predictability and consistency. We expect a tool purchased from Company A to perform at a certain level since the steel is %$@. When tools purchased from the same company perform at different levels I scratch my head in confusion. Maybe it's Batch A versus Batch B and the tempering was a little different.

Ed

Re: Metallurgy questions

#18

Mike Stafford

Yeah, I thought an "S" was needed....

Mike Stafford

:b :b :b :D

Re: Metallurgy questions

#19

Re: Answer to #3...yes.

John Lucas

Steve There is a Damascus class coming up at the craft center and I want to take it sooo bad. However it's one more hobby I don't really need. I love knife making and want to learn more. By the way Damascus isn't necessarily any better than modern steels. It was back in the day.

If you really want to get into steels talk to a serious knife maker. They go way beyond what we know.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#20

Re: You are quite correct.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

You purchase steel from a quality supplier but the fact is you don't really know what mill it came from. Some steel sold by a American company might be made in China or other parts of the world. The stamp on the steel can be changed... don't worry about A11 most of it is made in the US but there are a couple of mills that make it.

IMO there can be a change in the steel but I don't think it's common.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#21

Steven Antonucci

I know the smiths at Peters Valley

steven antonucci

so I have access to knife makers and couple of guys who do pattern welding (Damascus is a "brand name" from Syria)

I agree that it's no better than modern steels. In fact, it was created to overcome issues that don't exist in modern steels or powder metals. By laminating a hard layer with a softer layer, they could get the sharp edge and wear characteristics the required without the brittleness.

Still, there is something about seeing that pattern pop out when you etch it that makes me smile. Perhaps I'll make a mini skew this summer. I have the forge, the steel, and the welding flux I need to do it...:)

S

Re: Metallurgy questions

#22

Re: Thank you each for your responses. *LINK*

Gordon Seto

Don't know what steel P&N use. Their process may be different. I always use metal handles. I notice the grub screws would leave indentation marks on the P&N gouge shafts but not on other brands of gouges. That means the P&N shaft steel is softer than set screws and the shaft steel of other brands are harder. The business end should be hardened. Now the question is where and how is that transition. Will the steel be softer as the tool becomes shorter?

P&N

The chart from Crucible: The wear resistance of CPM 15V is way up, but the toughness is less than half of M2 or CPM 10V. The same CPM 10V would have different wear resistance & toughness values when heat treating to 60 or 63 HRC hardness.


Crucible Data Sheet

Re: Metallurgy questions

#23

Re: Thank you each for your responses.

David Walser

Gordon,

Some tool manufacturers use one type of steel for the blade and another type for the shank. This allows the use of (expensive) steel known for its edge holding ability in the blade and another (inexpensive) steel known for its strength in the shank. So, the relative softness you're seeing in the P&N shanks may not be due to a difference in tempering.

Re: Metallurgy questions

#24

It's a Fruit Basket

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'd feel safe in making a statement that you (the end-user) couldn't possibly tell the difference between A-11 from one source or another. Even if you could precisely sharpen each identical tool in the same way and to precisely the same point (er, edge) the differences in wood, even from the same tree, the number of revolutions of the wood that actually went past that edge, yada, yada . . There being so many variables, you'd be challenged, indeed, to be sure you were making valid comparisons. It wouldn't be an "apples-to-oranges" issue but rather a "Honey Crisp to Fiji" problem.

I take a practical/economic approach. I bought a Glaser A-11 and passed by the V-15 because the ridiculous [my view] difference in price was simply not worth it. I bought one 2060 Hamlet 1/2" bowl gouge. I bought a second one in 2030 steel. I cannot tell the difference, although I can tell a lot of difference from M2. How many more 2060's would you think I've purchased? Yeah, this is a trick question. ;)

Re: Metallurgy questions

#25

Re: Metallurgy questions

robo hippy

I can notice a difference in how M2 HSS cuts and my other (mostly Thompson) gouges cut. The M2 does cut more cleanly and with less effort. Maybe I am not supposed to be able to notice the difference, but I can feel it. Bonnie Klein made the comment that Mike Mahoney was probably the only one who could feel the difference. Well, maybe not. He does, in his new DVD (Heirlooms) make the statement that M2 will get sharper, and that is his preferred tool for finish cuts.

robo hippy