Not A Metallurgist
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Don't sleep in a Holiday Inn Express [if I can help it]
But
Ed,
I can tell you that this urban myth about which alloy will take the sharpest edge is pure bunk.
"Huh?" you say.
The crystalline structure of any particular alloy at the molecular level, often sited by would-be experts on this topic is irrelevant for turners. If you grind an A11, V12, HOZ9 with cobalt, or a nail pulled from your great granddaddy's barn door on the same 100 (or 220 or 600 or 2000) grit wheel, you will get virtually the same edge on each alloy. The sharpness of the edge is determined by the size of the abrasive,not the alloy of the damn metal. One alloy may be more resistant to wear and heat than another, so the sharp edge will last longer, but that's it.
Now, if you're planning on sharpening your tools down to a fineness that's commensurate with the molecular structure of a particular steel, it's a different story. It'll also be a raging cost for the equipment to do it and a monumental waste of your time.