What terrifies me the most is letting a newbie sharpen a tool. It is so nerve wracking to watch them even with the Wolverine as they try to sharpen and they are going to go off the edge of the stone. I bought the Sharp-Fast Tool Guide in hopes that I will feel safer letting a newbie sharpen a tool. Soon to be tried.
friend who is in my woodturning club says that he uses up one of his favorite spindle gouges in a year or so.
He qualifies that by saying that he allows his students to use his gouge when they are in class with him so between himself and his students it is constantly in use.
My first Sorby 3/8" bowl gouge has 2 1/2" less flute than my new one after 7 years of use.
I am not making much money for the tool companies on replacement tools. Now, for new tools, I buy more than I need.
My friend Ed Moore, buys a new tool when the old one gets dull.....
First time I taught there, I wondered how anyone ever cut wood with any of the tools. We spend almost the first hour of the class on day one evaluating the spindle gouge and rouging gouge do that people understand what sharp means, how to get to sharp, and how to build a "recipe" for sharp that is repeatable when they get home (assuming that they won't have the same equipment...)
I usually pull out any tools that have been ground into oblivion and fix them or it would take me three hours too...
In the event that someone reading this thread doesn't know about the fingernail grind jig - wolverine, varigrind or ellsworth - here's the basic idea - and the four set up variables.
As you can see from the annotated illustration it's not all that apparent which variable to change to
get the bevel angle you're after. And even when you have the tool projection, "leg angle" and
"wheel to heel" distance set, as the wheel diameter get smaller, due to use, you either have to "recalibrate" or accept the fact that the bevel angle will change over time. It may be that the gradual change in bevel angle due to wheel wear is uncosciously adapted to since it occurs gradually
While it certainly is true for a newbie to turning,that a jig like one of these makes sharpening easier,
and therefore probably done more often, my question was addressed to intermediate and more advanced turners.
As for gouges being screwed up by a Free Hander, this problem is not limited to newbies. We had a demonstration by a well known pro turner - who arrived with NO turning tools. He borrowed a couple - and reground and sharpened them to his taste. His taste and the tools owner's were VERY different, and the owner had to waste a lot of steel getting his tools back the way he wanted them.
Regarding the consistency of grind and muscle memory I have difficulty in understanding how a few degrees one way or the other would significantly effect how the tool is presented to the wood when initiating a cut. If you turn green, the wood may move - while you're making the cut - or while your sharpening. Starting a cut at the top inside rim of a bowl - where there is not support to ride the bevel on - can be tricky, which is why I use a skew to cut a little step for the bevel of the bowl gouge to start on - or better yet (for me) - a draw cut up to the rim.
Given only two choices - sharpen using a jig or sharpen free hand - both while not able to see where the wheel meets the metal - the jig is a better bet. However, there is a THIRD alternative -the JoolTool and the WorkSharp systems. Both are Free Hand methods - but they let you SEE the bevel as you're removing metal from it since the sharpening is done with the tool UNDER the rotating abbrassive surface - which is slotted so you can see through it. (More about these two sharpening systems in a separate thread).
Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency? *LINK*
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
Charlie, this is a very good drawing, take away the setting for the leg angle (make that fixed) and the distance the tool extends (keep that the same). So now the only thing to adjust is the vee arm, sharpening is simple.
It's Easter (almost dinner time) but you pick a flute shape by determineing what the guge will be used for. If you want wings for a Ellsworth grind then you need a V shape flute (small nose radius then all wing) OR a large nose radius and small wing then go with a U shape flute.
This thread has pictures of the different flute shapes view the entire thread.
The consistency of angle is a no brainer if you use the Raptor jigs. The jig takes the guesswork out of the angle and all you have to do is set the projection and grind the tool.
I agree totally. For turning newbies, there is an awful lot to learn in a short period of time. One problem with newbies is, they "think" their tools are sharp, when in reality they are not. I was one of those.
You can't learn to turn well, until you learn to sharpen well. A jig just shortens the learning curve. If someone has developed a "special grind" that is so complex that it cannot be duplicated by any jig, they should feel free to grind by hand. As for me, leave me to my Wolverine jig.
Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency? *LINK*
john lucas
Mike The Raptor jigs are very similar to what I use and learned from Mike Darlow. With that set up and never adjusting the Oneway Wolverine my tools are repeatable, I remove almost no steel and all the angles are repetitive.
I have several jigs like the Raptor for different tools. It takes seconds to change the V arm with one of these and then sharpening that tool is also dirt simple. I tried to show that in the youtube video below.
While I've seen the Raptor used, and saw The Raptor Set - of three or maybe it was four - it seems odd that you need a jig, or a set of jigs, in order to set up the finger nail jig that will be used to actually sharpen the gouge.
John, I saw your video and and had intended to comment in the original thread about how excellent it is.
I saw the Lucas jigs and was impressed because of the obvious repeatability they provide.
I am too cheap to buy the Raptors although I see their value in setting the grinder up consistently. I still use the old eye ball technique which evolved from the mark the bevel with black marker technique and see when the marker is uniformly scratched before powering up the grinder....
I need to make a set of your jigs since you explained how easy it is.
No one said you need the Raptor jigs. Folks have sharpened tools for years without them. They are available for people to use who desire to consistently set the angle of grind. Like most folks I sometimes find it necessary to change the bevel on some tools to achieve the cuts I wish to make
I set my grinder up by eye and adjust if necessary. The Raptor jig or John Lucas's jigs which are similar would probably save me time when I want to re-establish a bevel or grind a new tool.
Charlie I learned to sharpen by hand and then gradually moved to the jig which gave me more consitency but since you had to set the V with very small adjustments to be really accurate it was slow and sometimes I missed and had to remove more metal than necessary.
The use of the V setting jig is extremely quick and once I've set it I don't move it. Using the V setting jig and various riser blocks I made I can sharpen my 3 most used tools without ever moving a thing. That makes it extremely accurate. Since nothing changes you remove so little metal it only takes one light pass and it's sharp again.
did we mention you also had to have a jig to set the distance from the jig to the tip of the tool. Again it only takes a second and that one never moves so it can't go out of adjustment.