Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?
charlie belden
At a club Saw Dust Session, grinding and sharpening was the topic of the evening - specifically for a bowl gouge - with a fingernail grind. Various jigs, their set up and use were discussed - the pros and cons of each gone over. Then a favorite grind and jig was selected and a member was talked through setting up the jig, - with another jig (Raptor) - and using the set up jig to shape, then sharpen the gouge.
Compared with free hand grinding and shaperning, the use of jig's value were noted as being:
1) once the grind was established with the jig, a minimum amount of metal is removed with subsequent sharpening, and there�s minimum amount of wear on the grinding wheel -thus extending the working life of both the tool and the grinding wheel.
2) repeatable, consistent grind and, by implication, a more predictable use of the tool after each sharpening.
For somone who does a LOT of turning, a production turner, someone who turns BIG pieces or someone who turns very abbrassive woods - minimizing the amount of metal removed with each sharpening might be a significant thing. For most turners I wonder if gouge longevity is a major concern. In fact, given the rate of change of turning tools, continuing to use an older tool when a better one is available could be a disadvantage. Frugality can have its disadvantages.
As for the grinding wheel wear being minimized . . . ?
Now let�s look at the Consistency Thing.
When you're using the tool on different types of wood, punky wood, wood with bark inclusions and segmented pieces made of of different woods, oriented in different ways, all require "feeling you way along" when initiating and making cuts. You�re constantly adapting to the wood and the cut you want to make. Is reducing or minimizing changes between sharpenings in order to maintain the consistency of the grind really significant enough to warrant the fun & games of using a shaprening jig?
One of the things mentioned during the �grinds / jigs/ jigs set up� show and tell seems significant to me. Setting up a �finger nail jig� for a specific bevel angle That is using the same set up - with the same bevel angle for all fingernail ground gouges - bowl or spindle - the Middle Of The Road Bevel Angle - around 45-55 degrees - pick ONE. But if you're doing tall narrower bowls, you probably want a 55 or 60 degree bevel angle - to "get around the corner" towards the bottom of the bowl. The One Jig, One Set Up seems to reduce or eliminate the Best Bevel Angle For The Job idea.
So I'm wondering, assuming one is not a professional turner, and Time does not equal Money, how significant is extending the life of a tool to you?
How important is grind repeatability / consistency to you?




