Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Posts

Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#1

Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

charlie belden

At a club Saw Dust Session, grinding and sharpening was the topic of the evening - specifically for a bowl gouge - with a fingernail grind. Various jigs, their set up and use were discussed - the pros and cons of each gone over. Then a favorite grind and jig was selected and a member was talked through setting up the jig, - with another jig (Raptor) - and using the set up jig to shape, then sharpen the gouge.

Compared with free hand grinding and shaperning, the use of jig's value were noted as being:

1) once the grind was established with the jig, a minimum amount of metal is removed with subsequent sharpening, and there�s minimum amount of wear on the grinding wheel -thus extending the working life of both the tool and the grinding wheel.

2) repeatable, consistent grind and, by implication, a more predictable use of the tool after each sharpening.

For somone who does a LOT of turning, a production turner, someone who turns BIG pieces or someone who turns very abbrassive woods - minimizing the amount of metal removed with each sharpening might be a significant thing. For most turners I wonder if gouge longevity is a major concern. In fact, given the rate of change of turning tools, continuing to use an older tool when a better one is available could be a disadvantage. Frugality can have its disadvantages.

As for the grinding wheel wear being minimized . . . ?

Now let�s look at the Consistency Thing.

When you're using the tool on different types of wood, punky wood, wood with bark inclusions and segmented pieces made of of different woods, oriented in different ways, all require "feeling you way along" when initiating and making cuts. You�re constantly adapting to the wood and the cut you want to make. Is reducing or minimizing changes between sharpenings in order to maintain the consistency of the grind really significant enough to warrant the fun & games of using a shaprening jig?

One of the things mentioned during the �grinds / jigs/ jigs set up� show and tell seems significant to me. Setting up a �finger nail jig� for a specific bevel angle That is using the same set up - with the same bevel angle for all fingernail ground gouges - bowl or spindle - the Middle Of The Road Bevel Angle - around 45-55 degrees - pick ONE. But if you're doing tall narrower bowls, you probably want a 55 or 60 degree bevel angle - to "get around the corner" towards the bottom of the bowl. The One Jig, One Set Up seems to reduce or eliminate the Best Bevel Angle For The Job idea.

So I'm wondering, assuming one is not a professional turner, and Time does not equal Money, how significant is extending the life of a tool to you?

How important is grind repeatability / consistency to you?

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Lyle Jamieson

It does not matter what your skill level is, you will soon realize that you have to sharpen OFTEN. The tool will not work unless it is sharp...very sharp. Remember the last time you sharpened and how easy and fun it was for the first few cuts. We want to be turning that way all the time. So a jig is necessary in my opinion to sharpen quick, easy, and accurately. I learned to sharpen way before there were jigs. I would never go the grinder without one. I can sharpen all my tools at all the different angles without moving the jig set up at all. It only takes two seconds to go from my bowl gouge at 65 degrees to my spindle gouge at 50 degrees, and in 2 seconds, Im back to the bowl gouge again. This sure beats me standing with a dull tool in my hand and looking at the grinder and thinking "I have to move everything to sharpen, Ill use this dull tool for some more time". Thats not fun!!

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#3

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Jerry Klug

Cascade Woodturners had a "grinding" session at our meeting Thursday evening too. Dale Larson demonstrated his bowl tool grinding set up using a Varigrind jig. Dale utilizes three protrusion settings for the gouge in the jig to vary the angle of the gouge nose. Shorter for his 5/8" to allow a steeper grind for bowl bottoms, longer for the 1/2" general working gouge and longest for the 3/8" detail grind spindle gouge used for rim detailing. There was much more demonstrated and discussed on grinder set up and tool grinding technique but the variations on the length setting was interesting. I am going to try it now.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#4

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

steve worcester

For me the constancy of the grind allows me to have several gouges all sharpened at the start of a project. Tool gets dull, change the tool and it reacts the same as the one you took out.

It also aids in teaching when the students encounter the same scenario. Likely, they won't remember how the tool reacted a minute ago vs the one they just changed, but that comes with time.

i hand sharpen some tools, but never took the time to learn to sharpen a swept grind without a jig.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#5

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Dave Belser

Lyle nailed it - A big problem for beginners (and a fair number of the rest of us) is sharpening procrastination. In a perfect world sharpening is so quick and easy that you do it as soon as your tool is dull. Sharpening should take less than 10 seconds - if you have accurately matched the grind setup you don't need to remove much metal at all. My sharpening station is on wheels and includes both a grinder and a belt/buff machine. It gets parked near the headstock and sharpening is quick and easy.

BTW - this also applies to scrapers. I have seen so many people have a terrible time with scrapers because they continue to use them long after they stop producing ribbons and start producing dust.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#6

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Joe Herrmann

I too learned to sharpen before jigs were widely available and Lyle is right--I never sharpened as often as I do now that I have a jig to help. I don't think extending tool life is a big deal to me--turning is supposed to be fun and it isn't if the tool isn't sharp.

And consistency is important too. Having the same bevel angle makes each cut the same and muscle memory is a big factor in consistent results. Being able to present the tool in the same manner each time makes turning easier in the long run. I too wouldn't be without the jig.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Brad Vietje

I agree with Dave & Lyle.

Going back to Charlie's original questions, for me -- a non-professional -- it does matter how much steel I grind away, as I do turn often (at least, when I'm not building a house), and good tools cost real money, and I'd prefer not to waste it. I also appreciate a consistent bevel geometry, but perhaps not in the way Charlie asked. We may search for just the right tool presentation between different pieces with different species, degree of spalting, etc -- this is true. But I'm more concerned with a consistent grind not between bowls, but between individual cuts on a given piece.

Ideally, we'd sharpen or hone the tool before making the final cut, so we can minimize tear-out and sanding. We'd also sharpen or dress the tool a number of times on a single piece, especially if our sharpening method was fast, easy, and reproducible. With such a system, you could turn away from the work piece, touch up the tool, and return to the piece to make that all-important final cut. If your sharpening system takes too long, or causes stress, you return to the piece all tense and annoyed (maybe at having ground up too much of your expensive tool), or so much time has passed that your body's "muscle memory" of how to make that last, perfect pass has been lost.

Now you're back to finding the correct presentation of the tool, re-acquiring the right eye-hand motions at the lathe, and worse -- you might be doing this with a tool with a different shape than it had moments ago.

Luckily, Dave and I both know a very good turning mentor named Jon Siegel, from central New Hampshire. He has long been an advocate of a very simple, extremely fast, and very easy sharpening system that literally takes no more than 7 - 10 seconds. In that 10 second interval, you turn to the sharpening station, take off less than 0.0005", buff the flute to remove the burr edge, and you're back at the lathe, which I usually never even switch off! This is a sand-buff system based on a 4" wide belt sander and buffing wheel modified so the belt runs UP, away from the tool. An adjustable stop can be positioned for almost any tool, and the positions can either be numbered or color-coded for very quick and accurate placement. I don't think Jon is currently selling these, but you could run with the idea and try making one for yourself. My setup currently uses a 12" disc sander on a foot switch instead of a belt, but the rest is essentially the same.

Getting back to Charlie's query, if you are setting up a complex jig or machine, it simply takes too long, so you are tempted to use a tool for too long between sharpenings. Steve's solution of multiple tools is a good way for professionals to address a slower or more intricate system, but only if time is money, or you have more of it than I do.

A good strategy is not so much to sharpen a tool when it becomes dull, as to maintain the edge, and keep it from getting dull.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#8

Jon Siegel

Dave Belser

was selling his sharpening system at the Hartford symposium. He most likely has some in stock at this point. He is a great guy. If you are interested Goggle his name or his company which I believe is "Big Tree Turning"

- Dave

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#9

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Doc Green

I'm a free-hand sharpener. Took the cue from Richard R in one of his books.

I'm of the opinion that most turners make too many sparks when sharpening, with or without a jig. For example, the opening photo in the article on grinding wheels in the latest issue of American Woodturner shows a shower of sparks coming off the tool that would horrify me. Further, I'm not convinced that free hand sharpening necessarily means that more steel will be ground away.

When I sharpen, using a 120 grit aluminum oxide wheel, I use an extremely light touch, just enough pressure to keep the tool in contact with the wheel. Sparks are minimal. When I refine the edge on a diamond wheel, I try to avoid sparks altogether.

There is a dynamic instability inherent in the design and use of the sharpening jigs. The force of the wheel against the tool tends to "suck" the tool against the wheel even more. Much more force is applied between tool and wheel than what is applied by the operator. In the extreme, the tool can be sucked downward with great force and go flying out the bottom. Personally, I'm afraid of the jigs, because of this instability.

Grinding consistency is not an issue for me. Whenever I apply any gouge to the wood, I always glance at the bevel "to see where I am" and then go from there. If the bevel angle is a degree or two different from what it was previously or from what it might be on a different gouge, it is not a significant consideration.

Free-hand sharpening seems to work for me and I don't have to know anything about how to set up the jigs. If your preference is to use a jig, I suppose that's OK too.

My $0.02. ~Doc Green

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#10

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Bill Neddow

I am the guy who took the picture with all the sparks in the AAW journal. The purpose was to create a photo that was dramatic to get people interested in the article -- not to show a typical grinding situation. I actually had to push down very hard on the tool to get this effect. I made sure I was using an old and soft gouge that I had abandoned many years ago. I would never push down this hard when I was actually grinding a tool to use on a lathe. I agree with Doc. It is important to be very gentle in the amount of pressure you use -- you should be just touching up the edge, not changing the geometry of the tool or grinding it away unnecessarily. I make a major point out of being gentle in the article. Also, sparks are dangerous -- they start fires. The best grinding wheels for minimizing sparking are the new diamond and CBN wheels.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#11

Steven Antonucci

With a jig- a no brainer

steven antonucci

whether or not you get some commercially available system or make something on your own, this is a no brainer to me. A jig allows me to repeat a setup (whatever it is) and quickly and efficiently reestablish a cutting edge. It plays into muscle memory, whereby humans become proficient at a task through repetition. If you are constantly reshaping a bevel +/- a few degrees, it means that you are constantly making small adjustments in your positioning and presentation.

As far as preserving steel goes, why not? If a jig can get me sharp with 1/2 the metal removed, the tools will last 2x as long. I use diamond hones in between trips to the wheel to extend this even further.

No contest for me on this question.

S

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#12

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

john lucas

I sharpen both ways. I learned by hand and I think I'm pretty good at it. I now sharpen as often as possible with the jig. It's just so nice to have exactly the same cutting angle from time to time. I have a very light touch but I know I remove less metal when sharpening with the jig.

There are a couple of tools that I sharpen by hand simply because a Jig doesn't exist or I haven't take the time to rig one up since I don't use those tools often.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

keith tompkins

Charlie, If you teach regularly, you will soon discover the need for grinding jigs. I've seen some of the most horrific grinding jobs on all sorts of turning tools, week-old bowl gouges with only six inches of steel remaining, tools that were blue for two inches behind the grind, and worst of all, tools that were not fit for use because the grind was so bad.I've seen tools ground so badly that I wouldn't even attempt to use them. In nearly each case, the turner felt he had to grind by hand because somebody who had written a book said so. Using a grinding jig was just a crutch, something used by complete neophytes.

Many turners approach the hobby after they retire from a previous and totally unrelated career. They are afraid of the grinder, especially high-speed grinders. To expect them to pick up a bowl or spindle gouge, and grind a complex, repeatable grind is asking far too much. In most cases, it's not going to happen. Period. I say use a grinding jig.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#14

I agree completely

Jennifer Indy.USA

Keith,

I've come to find that when you have a class full of students the jigs are a life saver. Getting everybody up and running, grinding their own tools and making shavings takes very little time. If I were to expect a class full of new turners to grasp free hand sharpening alongside learning to turn it would be almost overwhelming and even worse frustrating and no fun for them. I introduce them to the jig first thing and use the method that Doug Thompson uses where the leg of the Vari Grind jig never moves. It simplifies things and everybody is on the same page. I will usually leave one Vari Grind jig open for people to move the leg just so they can see how many variables they can get into when they move it around. That being said, I'm glad I've assisted so many of Alan Lacer's classes because now I know how to free hand sharpen. He doesn't promote the use of the jigs but he doesn't disallow them either. I think knowing how to free hand is just one more skill anybody who spends a lot of time at the lathe should probably know how to do, but it certainly is a larger learning curve than using the jigs.

My 2 measly cents.

Jen :)

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#15

Sparks for the photo

Doc Green

Hey Bill, I suspected as much, and I'll admit that all the sparks does make a captivating photo. And may I add, I found your article to be very interesting and informative. I hope to see more of your articles in future issues.

And to all you jig users, just go right ahead if that's what you prefer. However, be careful, especially with tools having a steep bevel. ~Doc

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#16

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

robo hippy

How much steel you remove (how quickly you grind away your tool), and consistent grinds has nothing to do with using jigs or free hand sharpening. It is all about how much pressure you use, what grit wheel you use, and a little practice. I now free hand. I have a platform that I made where changing to pre set angles takes maybe 10 seconds. I can put a new edge on in about the same amount of time that it takes to put a gouge in a jig. I can sharpen any profile. The difficulty is in learning properly. My gouges all have fairly consistent profiles, but some are a bit more rounded to one side or the other, some thing that I did when I used a jig. Facets are pretty minimal, and the tools still cut as well as they ever did.

I have only taught one "this is a lathe" student. I did not teach sharpening, only turning. If I was to do an extended lesson on all phases of turning, I would spend part of a day on sharpening. Free hand is really simple. I can't imagine taking a whole class of totally beginning students and teaching them at the same time.

robo hippy

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#17

Steven Antonucci

large classes...

steven antonucci

Even with a jig, i've had issues with folks not understanding that the jig has to be set to the same extension and distance to the wheel. I usually can tell when i see someone at the grinder for more than a minute... gouge and it's the bowl gouge in the spindle gouge setup...

Jigs are a 10 Commandments thing for turning...

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#18

Totally messed up grinds

john lucas

There was an instructor at the Craft Center once who would not let the beginning students use a jig. That person will go nameless. I was teaching the next class. Fortunately I came in early. Every tool in the place was almost ruined. It took about 3 hours to resharpen them and lord knows how much metal I had to remove to get them to decent grinds again. I'll bet the students were frustrated as well because the poor grinds probably were not sharp and the angles made them difficult to use.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#19

OK-  Survey ?

jim miles - Charlotte

OK so how many people out there have actually ground a gouge down to the point it had no flutes ?

Yes, I did, it took 20 years and for most of that I was sharpening on a belt sander because that was all I had. So, yes I am a little skeptical of the idea of wearing out a gouge too quickly. But let's hear from some other folks

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#20

Re: OK-  Survey ?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

I have many times... turning a few times a week with a freehand grind. It didn't matter as long as the tool worked like I wanted it to and yes it wasted steel. Jigs are the way to go!

Sharpening is so simple but so misunderstood, why people buy a bowl gouge flute shape is another mystery.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

keith tompkins

Doc, I have to disagree with you on the jig having a tendency to pull the tool inward. On almost any tool the handle hangs way out beyond the jig, so it's bottom heavy. One has to gently LIFT the handle to maintain contact with the grinding wheel, otherwise gravity pulls it away. I will argue that attempting a swept-back grind freehand, especially in the hands of a beginner, will have a greater tendency to be pulled into the wheel, especially if the tool is not kept flat on the platen.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#22

Maybe I missed something...

Doug Trembath

Can you explain your comment on why people buy a flute shape, Doug?

Doug Trembath

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#23

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

Doug Trembath

I guess everyone has two cents, and mine is probably worth just that, but although I find that jigs work better for some folks than others, I don't personally use a jig much at all. I have quite a number of gouges with different profiles on them, and each uses the appropriate flute shape that best suits the profile, for the desired purpose.

If you look at the vast assortment of different grinds advocated by instructors and demonstrators, you find that each has developed techniques they are successful with, and the resulting grind that supports those techniques are a part of their methodology, and contribute to their success. Some grinds, Ellsworth's for example, are very difficult to freehand. Stuart Batty proposes a different grind that uses only the grinder platform as a jig, and that works famously for him and many others. I would think it would be very difficult to get a jig set up that would afford a Johannes Michelson grind in order to turn a hat. Believe it or not, I use his and Stuart's a lot, even interchangeably. (Except when actually turning a hat, of course)

I think it depends a lot on the individual, how fluent they may be in presenting the edge to the wood, how well they understand, and react to, the changes in tool geometry and texture of the surface, and how easily they adapt to those changes. How much of the actual edge they use is also pertinent, as is how well they can coordinate their body movements when turning and sharpening. I believe it takes the same fluidity and range of motion to sharpen well as it does to turn well.

I use the Wolverine platform for Stuart's grind, and sometimes use the support arm for a spindle roughing gouge if I want to reshape it , but other than that, I freehand all of my gouges, because I'm more succesful that way. I just gently dance the bevel across the wheel. I seldom see much in the way of sparks, and virtually never blue even a carbon steel gouge. I grind my flatwork tools in the same manner, as well.

Teaching beginners, as I said, is a whole 'nuther exercise, however. The most important thing in teaching sharpening, to me, is to ensure a smooth, consistent, and usable profile, with no facets. When I evaluate grinds other turners have on their tools, I see two consistent problems, either they have facets everywhere from trying to freehand, or they have ground way too far into the sides of a gouge with a jig, and have lost the ability to use much of the edge. I did that as a newbie, too, and struggled to turn until it was pointed out that a clean, uninterrupted edge with a fair curve in the profile is critical to success, no matter how you achieve that edge, jig or freehand. For someone to say that more or less steel is removed by freehand sharpening or with a jig seems almost laughable. The only thing that results in lost steel is grinding too much, and you can do that with or without a jig.

The manner anyone uses to achieve this clean, un-faceted profile is up to them, because in the final analysis, each of us is different in very many ways, and each of us will find that one way just works better for us. It ain't right or wrong, it's just different, and that's OK. All too often, folks here make generalizations and "profound" statements of fact that apply only to their own understanding, capability, and knowledge level, and that when applied to the vast differences among us all, simply demonstrates to those with a larger experience bank that these folks just don�t know what they don�t know, and that is one of the biggest dangers for new turners.

Again, just my $02.

Doug Trembath

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#24

Re: OK-  Survey ?

john lucas

Jim My first 2 I ground down in about 6 years. Of course I do a lot of turning that doesn't require a bowl gouge and still have most of those. I have 2 more of the gouges I bought after the first 2 that are getting pretty short but since I use those now for specialty grinds they should last a long time.

My first Thompson gouge is 2 years old. I've ground of an Inch in that time, and I use it constantly and sharpen frequently. That's with a jig of course.

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Jigs & The Significance of Grind Consistency?

keith tompkins

Doc, An oversight on my part....when grinding a roughing gouge in the pocket of the jig, and grinding a very blunt angle, the tool is close to the center of the wheel..that can be a problem as the tool could be "sucked in" if one applied too much pressure. I hadn't thought about that, since I don't often grind that kind of angle on my tools. In that case, I agree with you.