I don't normally get a lot of green wood to turn, but lately I have turned some wood and got a shower as I was turning. However, I am having trouble sanding it for a final finish. How do I sand wet/green wood? I have been putting it in plastic bags and then reversing the bags daily to limit the drying time and wait for it to get dry enough to sand. Help please.
I found it way easier to let the wood dry before sanding. You spend a lot less time cleaning your abrasive discs. I turn to final thickness, 1/4 to 3/8 inch and let the bowls dry. They are totally dry in 10 to 14 days, and dry enough to sand out at about 4 to 5 days depending on thickness, wood type, local humidity, etc. For drying, I make sure to round over the rims, and then use some plastic stretch wrap (5 inch roll from shipping places or office supply that is used around boxes on a pallet). About an inch on the inside of the bowl, and the rest on the outside. I start the bowls on the ground/floor as the humidity is lower there, then after a few days, up on a wire rack to finish. You can force dry them, but time is better spend turning more bowls.
The problem with sanding dry warped bowls is that you need to power sand, and have a lathe with very slow speeds, in the 10 to 20 rpm range. You just can't keep your hand, drill, or abrasive on the wood at higher speeds. If your lathe won't go that slow, then you can use the spindle lock to hold it while you sand, then rotate the bowl and sand some more.
Don, you don't say what kind of pieces you are turning. I often turn small thin walled natural edge vases and the like from green madrone or manzanita. I wet sand these pieces immediately on the lathe, rinsing off the sandpaper frequently in a pan of water to unclog the paper. I sand through all the grits keeping the work piece wet at all times. The slurry that forms under the paper seems to inhibit scratching compared what I find with dry sanding and I end up with a very smooth surface with no hand sanding. If I were to let these pieces dry before sanding, they would distort enough that sanding of the lathe would not be practical.
The ones I have now are silver maple. I have some sweet gum that I plan on turning this weekend and expect the same problem. It looks like I'm going to have to wait a little bit for them to dry down some.
Don, I'm with Dennis on this one. Personally, I don't know why wet sanding isn't more popular/promoted/recommended. The only downside is it can get a bit messy but there is *NO* dust.
When I was doing this I would just use typical power sanding techniques and a good spray bottle full of water. Keep the surface wet enough to develop a bit of a slurry of mud. Works great. The sand paper will last longer, the water works as a lubricant and keeps everything cool.
Most sandpaper can handle the water. I was using the blue stuff on foam pads.
I turn wet wood all the time. I also don't sand wet wood. I rough turn pieces and let the dry and then return then to the thiness I want and then sand.
Depending on the size of the bowl I will leave the walls 1"-2" thick.
I turn all my stuff to final thickness while the wood is green, and sand while it's still on the lathe. I prefer Astra Dot sanding discs. It is only available from Woodchuckers in Canada. The abrasive is put on in dots, so it resists clogging. If it does clog, just clean it off with a soft wire brush. It also stays sharp a long time. Abranet is nice, but it snags and tears on natural edge bowls.
I use a hair dryer to dry the surface and then sand as usual. If I sand through the dry and it clogs the disc I use what is called a file card (used to clean metal files) to clean the disc. Then I'll dry it some more.
I will have to give wet sanding a try. I'm not sure I'll like the mess but it's probably faster than drying the outside with a hair dryer.
There is a world of difference between "wet sanding" and "sanding wet wood".
Wet sanding refers to keeping the wood wet and keeping the abrasive wet. The wood fibers that would become dangerous dust in dry sanding become a slurry or paste, so there is a little more mess, but dramatically less danger to your lungs. There is no issue of the abrasive "clogging". Instead, the sand paper or cloth is repeatedly dunked in a bowl of water, which rinses the paper, and helps keep the wood wet. There should be no distortion of the wood while sanding, as you are constantly re-hydrating it. Put down a plastic sheet to keep the lathe from getting all wet.
Sanding wet wood (with dry abrasive) is asking for trouble, as the abrasive is almost instantly clogged. As soon as friction drys the wood, you have the same dust issues as sanding dry wood, but you also have relatively useless sandpaper, and the same friction that dries the wood produces heat that distorts and cracks the wood....
I wet sand up to 320 or sometimes 400, then dry the wood slowly and evenly. When it is air-dried to your satisfaction, either hand sand with some 400 or 0000 steel wool, or use a small piece of Scotch Bright pad on a Velcro-faced padded sanding disk.
In addition to dust relief, one great benefit of wet sanding is that you can sand figured/curly/burl wood while wet, and then allow a wonderful texture to develop as the wood dries. By using the grey and white Scotch-Bright pads, you can remove the raised grain fuzzies from drying without losing the tactile qualities of the textured wood. Works superbly on green-turned burls. Light colored woods like Maple or Beech can sometimes turn gray-looking... and, be sure you use clean abrasive with no metal dust or grit from a nearby grinder on tannin-containing woods like Oak, as these can be darkened by blue-black spots from the iron dust reacting with the wet wood.
I commonly towel off the wood and dry it with paper towels, then apply Danish oil or urethane oil finish directly to the wet wood. It slows down the drying process, which helps prevent cracking and such, and while it may not penetrate as well as in dry wood, you can wipe on a few additional applications when the wood dries, and it works great.
The home improvement box stores will sell a sanding "screen" made for sanding drywall. It looks kind of like window screen and is impregnated with grit. Easy to clean.
Brad, it appears as though I have been merely sanding wet wood. So, to get the benefits of wet sanding I need to keep things MORE wet than I have been? As it is now, I am getting clogged, useless sanding discs which look like they are made of termite barf (aka, particle board).
yes Steve. I use a good 1 quart spray bottle and end up refilling it a few times. If you are not getting a slurry of water and wood dust it's not wet enough. Other folks here have suggested dipping the sanding pad in water.
This might be better than my approach as far as mess goes but I imagine that you would need to dip often - maybe a small bucket of water on the lathe bed.
I put enough water on that it gets a bit messy. As Brad said you will want to put a narrow sheet of plastic over the lath bed. You just need to cover the area where stuff flies off - you know that line we all have up the wall and across the ceiling.
Sounds that way, Steve. I find wet sanding to be pretty enjoyable, though a little messy, and I really don't like dry sanding at all. Dunking your hands in warm water can also feel pretty good when it's cold in the shop, too. The piece gets slippery with a slurry of water and wood fibers (dust), so wiping it off occasionally will reveal what's happening. I've read that some people like to drop down one grit size when wet sanding -- starting with 180 instead of 220, for example, but I can't say I do that very often.
Along the same theme, some people wet sand with either mineral oil, or a finishing oil like Watco, right on the wet wood. Assuming you want to wet turn to completion, here's another option:
Wet turning to completion: Wet sand with Mineral oil, followed with an oil finish.
If you are doing a lot of work, and doing this pretty often, you can keep a squeeze bottle of mineral oil that can be used right on the wet wood, and use that to sand up to 320-ish. Instead of a bowl of water, you just apply a little more oil when needed, and the slush comes spinning off -- going slower will prevent extensive wardrobe malfunctions, and a raincoat helps, too. Then towel the piece off real well, and it can either be air dried (M.O. preventing it from drying too quickly, but I'd still put it in a paper bag), or use another (different color?) squeeze bottle with a polymerizing oil like Watco to repeat the 320 and go to 400 with the finishing oil, wipe off, and dry. That way the piece is somewhat protected from checking, and you've already got the first application of the finish right in the wood. Once it air dries to your satisfaction (again, I'd put it in a bag for additional protection), you can apply more finishing oil to your satisfaction, or even sand in a little more finish oil with 400 wet/dry, 0000 steel wool (if not Oak, etc...), or a piece of fine Scotch-Bright pad -- either on the lathe or off, depending on your needs, chucking methods still available, and your sense of adventure.
This method works quite well. I'm not sure if I've ever lost a piece to cracking when done this way, (turned to 1/4" or less), but they do still warp, so sometimes the piece distorts enough that I don't like it as much, but that's a planning and grain orientation issue unrelated to wet sanding and putting the finish on wet. I tried microwave drying of a thin hollow form after this treatment a few weeks ago, and found that some of the finish will be squeezed out onto the surface and harden there as a slightly rough texture, but hand scrubbing with a Scotch-Bright piece takes that away. I'd only microwave a piece with finish in it when time is tight, and you have to meet a deadline. I have not done this with bowls more than about 1/2" thick, so it may not be good for all projects or all comers.
Dry sanding is less work. The problem is the dust. This is easily taken care of with a dust collector and a sanding hood. Not a vent, hose, big gulp cup, or even 2 hoses. If you look at Oneway's site, they have a sanding hood. I didn't check the price, but I would think it is pretty expensive. You can easily make one similar to it. I used a food grade white plastic 55 gallon drum that I cut to size. I can sand black walnut for hours, blow my nose (disgusting I know) and there is NO dust at all up my nose. The more enclosed the bowl is, the more dust you collect at the source. I have an architects chair on wheels that I sit on for sanding. Almost makes it easy.
I'll be teaching a class on green wood turning at Marc Adams school July 18-22. There are advantages and disadvantages to using green wood, and a lot of myths and folklore. We'll try to cover them all in this class. Jennifer Shirley will be the assistant.
Vic Wood during a demo at our woodturning club about 10 years ago sprayed some denatured alcohol on a freshly turned green bowl (after cleaning up all the wood chips and removing flammables about 6 feet away) and then set it on fire with a match. When the flame went out in about a minute he sanded as you would dry wood. When the sandpaper started to clog he reapplied alcohol and lit it again.
It would take me about about a half day to get my shop clean enough to safely duplicate this technique, but it is an alternative method.
We've been throwing comments around about the sanding issues, but I just remembered your comment about waiting for some blanks to season until the were dry enough to turn, or words to that effect.
Wood does not need to be dried to a lower moisture content to turn it. In most cases, the best practice is to rough turn the wood when perfectly green -- I wait for the tree to hit the ground first, but I don't intentionally wait any longer than absolutely necessary. Then either finish turn green, or rough out leaving enough thickness to allow the wood to warp, and dry using your favorite method. After the wood has air dried, (or been microwaved, DNA'd etc...) finish turn to desired dimensions. You don't need to wait to rough turn it.
Wood should be turned when green or when dry, and not in-between. Partially seasoned wood is the worst of both worlds, and still moves.
BTW: allowing some wood to season means the sap wood will start to look dull and gray, the bark may separate, and in some cases spalting starts before too long. Many turners get the notion in their noggin that the wood has to be dried down before turning -- not so! Mount that blank and let the chips (and water) fly!
I have been turning over three years and today was the first time I have wet sanded wood successfully. Thanks to all you guys for the tips. I think I'm hooked. I even enjoy the mud. May try shaping it into something.
You can also blow the free water out with compressed air. As long as the surface appears dry, it will sand OK. The wood is not dry, just the free water is not wetting the outside surface. Blow from the outside to dry the surface. This will also greatly reduce staining in light colored woods and white sapwood.