Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Posts

Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#1

Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Ronny Eelen

Hi,

I would like to get me a reciprocating carver.

But then of course there is always this question of which one.

When I followed a training class with Jacques Vesery there were 2 types in use I think.

A Foredom, of which I found the flex shaft to be a little stiff. Hard on the hands after a while. The other one I don't remember anymore. But that flex shaft was a lot easier on the muscles. And it turned out to be a lot cheaper as well as Jacques said.

So, who knows what Jacques uses? :)

Or, any good advice for me? I have read good things about AutoMach...

thanks for your help

regards from an early summer in Belgium

Ronny

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#2

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy? *LINK*

Greg Haugen

There are a couple of options that attach to a foredom style of carver. I've never used any of them. Nothing against them, just haven't used them.

The best known option is the Automach. Several turners use them and "wouldn't leave home without it".

I've been using a Ryobi carver that isn't made anymore but can be found often on ebay in the $80-$100 range for the last five years. They work well, and if you just to "play", they're great.

I'm going to be getting a new carver today actually via UPS. I bought the newly designed Proxxon. They've recently redesigned it and suppose to have vastly improved it. It now has gear head made of die-cast aluminium and main housing of glass-fibre reinforced POLYAMIDE. I want to try it out, it's getting rave reviews and is over $100 less than the automach.

If you want to experiment and play and not spend $200-$300, watch for a Ryobi on Ebay.

If you want a better tool that will take the abuse, I'd recommend the Proxxon or Automach, depending on your budget.

As far as blades go, Flexcut! Hands down.


The New Proxxon Carver

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#3

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Jennifer Indy.USA

Ronny, the Automach is a great ricip carver if cost is no issue. clost to $300 lately. If you can find one of the discontinued Ryobi ricip carvers those were a fan favorite too. I've been using a Proxxon ricip carver for several years now and love it. It's smaller and lighter and perfect for working on turnings. Have a Wecheer recip handpiece that i use in my flexshaft but as you say it's cumbersome and hard onthe hands. I only use it when I need to remove a lot of material. The only thing I don't like about the Proxxon is whever designed it put the air vents right where the hand grip is so the heat has a hard time getting out and the unit get a tad warm after a while of use. Apparently the person who designed it doesn't use one. Anyway, that's my 2 cents on recip carvers. Whichever one you buy use the chisels that come with for practiciing honing only. They are all cheep, and no good. Buy yourself a a good set of the Flexcut brand chisels.

Jen

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#4

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

John Lucas

wow $80 to $100. I think I paid $39 for mine brand new. That seems to be the problem. The step between the Foredom and Automach is a lot of money.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#5

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy? *LINK*

Greg Haugen

Hahaha. Supply and Demand, I guess. It's insane. I've seen a couple got for $150.

Here's a link of the current ebay listings. The ones with blades and/or the hard case will be in the $80 to $100 range by the time they end in 5 days.

If someone would uncover a "pallet" of these in some warehouse, they could buy a "dream" lathe from the sales.

There used to be another option from one of the tent "tool sales" places for about $20 and it came with the crappy blades and plastic case. It was basically the Ryobi after they stopped making them.

One thing I do like about the new proxxon compared to the Automach, it does come with a nice case. The automach doesn't. It is handy for traveling and storage.


Ryobi Carvers on Ebay

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#6

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Ron Bauman

Hey Ronny:

I just bought an Automach (on sale at Woodcraft, but no more) and have been pleased although with limited use so far. Utube video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H8xfSsSEafE

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#7

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Carole Valentine

The WeeCheer works well if you take the spring out plus you get the rotary tool to boot. The heavy duty one can still be had for $160. My favorite for the stuff I do is still the Ryobi...have 3 of them that I got on eBay. Keep two on the carving bench with most used Flexcut blades inserted and one in the closet as a spare. When I grow up I may graduate to one of the big girl tools.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#8

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

ronnyeelen

Hi Greg,

Please let us know how it turns out.

Ronny

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#9

Re: thanks...

ronnyeelen

All,

thanks for the suggestions so far.

For the moment the Proxxon seems a good choice for me.

In case that at some point I would want to put a flexible shaft on it anyway, I guess that would be no problem right?

thanks

Ronny

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#10

Re: thanks...

Greg Haugen

The flexible shafts are for the "motor" rotary carvers (foredom and wecheer) since they're way too heavy to hold while you use them. The attachments that go on them for the Recip. cutters change the "rotary" action to Reciprocating. The Proxxon, Automach, and Ryobi are just handheld reciprocating carvers, so they're most often used without them. A flexible shaft is available for the Proxxon and Automach, though.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#11

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy? *LINK*

Mike from St. Clair Shores

I have used the foredom, weecher, and a ryobi clone sold by cummins tools for $18. All will get the job done, but if money were no object, check out GRStools. The cheapest model they sell is around $700. I have included a link. They cut wood like butter.

Mike


GDS Tools

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#12

Re: thanks...

Ronny Eelen

Now that gives me a completely new insight. I never realized that. Thanks Greg.

Hmm, so I need 2 then... hey, it's 2 different tools, right? :)

I guess that for my current intended use, the Proxxon is still a good choice.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#13

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Ronny Eelen

You are teaching me some English here: get ... to boot. Had to look it up.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#14

Bill Blasic

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Bill Blasic

Not to turn the subject a little but I have the Mastercarver which has the recipro-carver but it is also a rotary carver like the Foredom. I really like the Rotary Chisels sold by Creative Technologies, Inc. They cut very well and come in different formulations. I'm just a happy user.

http://www.rotarychisel.com/info.html

Bill

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#15

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

Carole Valentine

LOL! At least you learned something from my post!

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#16

Re: thanks...

Greg Haugen

Ronny,

Nah, just one. If you want to put a flex shaft on it you always can. It's as easy as changing blades. To start, just look at getting the tool and try that first. You can always buy a flex shaft later for it. I don't believe there's any "bundle" deals out there. Start with one by itself and you'll figure out what you like.

Just my 2 cents.

The newly designed proxxon did come yesterday. It's a sweet machine. Beautifully balanced and features where you want them. The plastic case also has a lot of space to add blades to it. Very impressed.

Re: Which reciprocating carver to buy?

#17

Re: Which reciprocating carver: proxxon

Ronny Eelen

At least, that did it for me. I ordered it, from a local supplier even.

Together with a set of the flexcut blades.

And now we'll have to see what I can do with it.

All this stuff to do, and so little time... retirement is only 20 years away...

thanks all, you were a great help!

regards

Ronny