Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Wood ID query

Posts

Wood ID query

#1

Wood ID query

Chuck Engstrom

Hi folks -- I posted this once before but didn't record the response --several folks came up with the same ID -- and can't raise it in the archives. Any idea what this is?


Thanks again --

Chuck

Re: Wood ID query

#2

Mulberry?

Jorge Casta�eda

Re: Wood ID query

#3

Steven Antonucci

Some kind of elm?

steven antonucci

Judging by the side grain, if it grew here in the US...

S

Re: Wood ID query

#4

Looks like Sycamore to me

Carole Valentine

Re: Wood ID query

#5

Osage orange,AKA hedgeapple, bodark,..

JamieDonaldson

..bow wood.........fence post wood here in KY! :D

Re: Wood ID query

#6

I'm with Jamie.  Osage Orange.

Greg Haugen

Re: Wood ID query

#7

Re: Wood ID query

Don Evans

Is it really light in weight compared to other common woods like maple etc. if yes then it could be "butternut". If that, it is great carving wood.

don

Re: Wood ID query

#8

Osage Orange - Jamie's Correct *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

See attached. Note that the plate is of a sample that has darkened with some aging by the time of the photo. Click on the enlarge function of the transverse section to make the comparison.


Osage

Re: Wood ID query

#9

Re: Wood ID query

LJ Wallwey

I see wood that looks like this at work and it is called Apitong. A very hard wood that comes from Malaysia and is used under the aluminum floor in semi trailers. It is very straight grained as comes from large trees.

Re: Wood ID query

#11

Walt Bennett

Re: Looks like Sycamore to me

Walt Bennett

Couldn't agree more - I don't think any other wood has that 'fish scale' appearance.

Re: Wood ID query

#12

Re: Wood ID query

Steve Worcester

To me, the endgrain doesn't look like any US wood I have seen.

Osage is usually waveyer in the sidegrain and not a lot of quartersawn definition. Sycamore - I have't seen that overall color cast and the endgrain , just doesn't look like the Sycamore we have in this area (of Texas).

Re: Wood ID query

#13

Ric Taylor

Sycamore

Ric Taylor

It looks just like the Sycamore that we have abundently in my part of Texas. It doesn't look anything like any Osage Orange that I've ever seen except for the color, which might not be correct in the photo.

Ric

Re: Wood ID query

#14

sycamore

Jeff Willaford

Lookes like the sycamore I have in my shed and any I've turned.

Re: Wood ID query

#15

Re: sycamore

Steve Worcester

Is your sycamore that yellow? I have stuff cuts years ago and it is pretty white, bit maybe covered in something, wax, clear paint, maybe that is where it is throwing me off. I will have to look at some when I get home today.

Re: Wood ID query

#16

Re: Wood ID query

robo hippy

I wouldn't guess sycamore because I can't see any meduallary rays going across thee growth rings. Maybe if the cut was cleaner, but I picked one up yesterday and I could see them through the chainsaw marks.

I wouldn't guess Osage either. Osage growth rings tend to go wavy, rather than straight circular rings.

I have seen Apitong that really looks like that, and hard as nails.

robo hippy

Re: Wood ID query

#17

Re: sycamore

Jeff Willaford

The sycamore I have in hand is definitely that yellow.

Re: Wood ID query

#18

sycamore in Virginia

Jeff Willaford


Cut 3/31/2011

Re: Wood ID query

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wood ID query

keith tompkins

Nothing I've seen growing locally....where's it from?

Re: Wood ID query

#20

Re: I'm with Jamie.  Osage Orange.

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

If it is heavy, so hard it rings like metal, and darkens on exposure to light -- my vote is osage orange. Definitely not the sycamore I know which looks exactly like the sycamore photos posted. Mulberry would be my second guess.

Re: Wood ID query

#21

Re: Wood ID query

Rob Cohen

This looks like plane American Sycamore(Platanus occidentalis).


img

Re: Wood ID query

#22

Apitong is looking likely....

Greg Haugen

I'm starting to think LJ and Robo has it. If it was domestic, I'd think Osage Orange. After looking up Apitong, I think LJ and Robo cracked the mystery.

http://www.abswood.com/pages/apitong.htm

There's no medullary rays in the wood, like in Sycamore. Osage O. still could be it but it's just a bit off.

I've had a piece of Apitong, and didn't know it. A friend gave me a 2X2 piece of "dunno" (dunno what the heck it is) but comparing it to Osage side by side, that was ruled out. The stuff was hard, but splintered when cut like Wenge. I made mallet out of it and used it a lot until it started to splinter. Once it started, it just kept going.

We should have formal "Wood ID" challenges. Maybe some sponsored prizes??

Chuck, to find a true and accurate answer, send a small cutoff piece to a nearby university to their botany/ bio/ forestry lab. Our University of Wisconsin welcomes and asks for wood samples for the students to test and problem solve.

Re: Wood ID query

#23

Re: Wood ID query

Tom Stevenson

I have a sample of Iroko sap wood. It looks the same as your picture. Iroko is a very heavy wood. What are the dimensions of the top of your square sample? The end grain pattern on my sample looks slightly larger, but maybe that is because my piece is only 1 1/2" square. What is the easiest way to send my picture?

Re: Wood ID query

#24

Re: Wood ID query

Chuck Engstrom

Wow, what a response! I got far less than this, as I recall, when I posted the same query and photo last July.

However....with all due respect to the many familiar names I see in the responses, I'm going to have to say that it's not sycamore, mulberry, osage, or elm, all of which I know and have samples of from local trees. I will dig some of them out for a group photo with the "mystery" wood.

Someone last summer came up with a name which I recall very vaguely as something like -- and here I'm pretty much guessing at spelling -- suspira or something sort of like that. And I think that more than one person was familiar with this wood so there was at least a two-person agreement on a name for it. Researching the name they gave seemed to confirm that it was correct. Unfortunately the archives won't bring back that thread.

The square piece in the photo is about 2", the octagonal slightly less.

Many thanks to all of you for your interest. This may end up going off to Wisconsin as suggested unless last summer's wizards come by again.

Best to all--

Chuck

Re: Wood ID query

#25

Re: I'm with Jamie.  Osage Orange.

Barry

I'm with Jamie, too. It looks like Osage Orange, aka Bodock, aka Hedgeapple.